9.3 Ethical Decision-Making at Different Organizational Levels

Ethical decision-making in organizations happens at different levels, from individual choices to company-wide policies. This topic explores how ethics play out across these levels, looking at frameworks, challenges, and leadership's role.

Leaders shape the ethical tone of an organization, influencing how employees make moral choices. By understanding ethical blind spots and using decision-making tools, organizations can build a culture that supports ethical behavior at all levels.

Ethical Decision-Making Frameworks

Ethical Frameworks and Moral Reasoning

Top images from around the web for Ethical Frameworks and Moral Reasoning

• 

  Lifespan Theories: Moral Development | Introductory Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Lawrence Kohlberg's stages of moral development - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Lawrence Kohlberg's stages of moral development - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Lifespan Theories: Moral Development | Introductory Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Lawrence Kohlberg's stages of moral development - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Ethical Frameworks and Moral Reasoning

• 

  Lifespan Theories: Moral Development | Introductory Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Lawrence Kohlberg's stages of moral development - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Lawrence Kohlberg's stages of moral development - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Lifespan Theories: Moral Development | Introductory Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Lawrence Kohlberg's stages of moral development - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Utilitarian approach evaluates actions based on their consequences for the greatest good
• Deontological ethics focuses on the inherent rightness or wrongness of actions regardless of outcomes
• Virtue ethics emphasizes moral character and virtues like honesty and compassion
• Rights-based approach centers on respecting fundamental human rights
• Justice approach considers fairness and equitable distribution of benefits and burdens
• Moral reasoning involves applying ethical principles to analyze and resolve ethical dilemmas
• Kohlberg's stages of moral development describe progression from self-interest to universal ethical principles
• Gilligan's ethics of care emphasizes relationships, empathy and context in moral decision-making

Stakeholder Analysis in Ethical Decision-Making

• Stakeholder analysis identifies individuals or groups affected by an organization's decisions and actions
• Primary stakeholders directly impacted include employees, customers, shareholders, and suppliers
• Secondary stakeholders indirectly affected encompass local communities, government, and activist groups
• Stakeholder mapping visualizes stakeholders' interests, influence, and interrelationships
• Power-interest grid categorizes stakeholders based on their level of power and interest in the organization
• Salience model evaluates stakeholder claims based on power, legitimacy, and urgency
• Balancing stakeholder interests requires careful consideration of competing needs and priorities
• Stakeholder engagement promotes dialogue and collaboration to address ethical concerns

Ethical Challenges

Ethical Dilemmas and Moral Intensity

• Ethical dilemmas arise when core values or ethical principles conflict (truth vs loyalty)
• Right-versus-right dilemmas involve choosing between two ethically justifiable options
• Right-versus-wrong dilemmas occur when unethical choices tempt decision-makers
• Moral intensity refers to the ethical significance or magnitude of an issue
• Factors influencing moral intensity include magnitude of consequences and social consensus
• Proximity affects moral intensity as decision-makers feel greater responsibility for nearby impacts
• Temporal immediacy considers how soon consequences will occur after an action
• Concentration of effect examines whether harm is focused on few or dispersed among many

Ethical Blind Spots and Cognitive Biases

• Ethical blind spots prevent individuals from recognizing ethical issues in their decisions
• Bounded ethicality describes systematic and predictable ethical errors in decision-making
• Self-serving bias leads people to overestimate their own ethicality and underestimate others'
• Fundamental attribution error attributes others' unethical behavior to character flaws rather than circumstances
• Confirmation bias causes selective attention to information confirming existing beliefs
• Framing effects show how presentation of ethical issues influences decision-making
• Overconfidence bias leads to underestimating ethical risks and overestimating ability to act ethically
• Ethical fading occurs when ethical aspects of a decision fade from view due to psychological processes

Moral Disengagement

Mechanisms of Moral Disengagement

• Moral disengagement allows individuals to engage in unethical behavior without feeling guilty
• Euphemistic labeling uses sanitized language to make harmful conduct seem acceptable (enhanced interrogation)
• Moral justification frames unethical actions as serving a worthy purpose (ends justify the means)
• Advantageous comparison contrasts unethical behavior with worse actions to make it seem less harmful
• Displacement of responsibility shifts blame to authority figures or circumstances
• Diffusion of responsibility spreads accountability across a group, reducing individual culpability
• Dehumanization strips victims of human qualities, making it easier to mistreat them
• Attribution of blame portrays victims as deserving of mistreatment due to their own actions

Ethical Fading and its Consequences

• Ethical fading describes the unconscious process of disregarding the ethical dimensions of a decision
• Ethical blindness results from ethical fading, preventing recognition of moral issues
• Slippery slope effect occurs when small ethical transgressions lead to increasingly unethical behavior
• Normalization of unethical practices happens when misconduct becomes routine and accepted
• Ethical numbing diminishes sensitivity to ethical issues over time through repeated exposure
• Ethical erosion gradually weakens moral standards and ethical decision-making capabilities
• Organizational factors contributing to ethical fading include time pressure and performance metrics
• Combating ethical fading requires deliberate attention to ethical implications and regular ethical reflection

Leadership Influence

Ethical Leadership Cascade and Organizational Culture

• Ethical leadership cascade describes how leaders' ethical behavior influences subordinates throughout the organization
• Tone at the top sets ethical standards and expectations for the entire organization
• Role modeling by leaders demonstrates ethical behavior for employees to emulate
• Ethical climate refers to shared perceptions of what constitutes ethical behavior in an organization
• Ethical culture encompasses the formal and informal systems that support ethical conduct
• Reward systems aligned with ethical behavior reinforce desired conduct
• Ethical training programs develop employees' moral reasoning and decision-making skills
• Whistleblowing policies and procedures encourage reporting of ethical violations
• Code of ethics articulates organizational values and expected ethical standards of conduct