1.2 Historical Context and Evolution of Improvisation in Management

Strategic improvisation in business has deep roots in jazz and theater, evolving from ad-hoc problem-solving to a vital management skill. It challenges traditional planning models, emphasizing adaptability and innovation in rapidly changing business environments.

Key figures like Karl Weick and Frank Barrett shaped the field, applying concepts from music and organizational theory. Their work, along with environmental factors and technological advancements, has made improvisation an essential strategy for modern businesses facing unpredictable challenges.

Improvisation in Management History

Origins and Early Development

Top images from around the web for Origins and Early Development

• 

  Safetymatters: Safety culture information, analysis and management: High Reliability ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Definition - Sensemaking Resources, Education, and Community View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  John Mehegan, Jazz Improvisation (1959-65) – SOCKS View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Safetymatters: Safety culture information, analysis and management: High Reliability ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Definition - Sensemaking Resources, Education, and Community View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Origins and Early Development

• 

  Safetymatters: Safety culture information, analysis and management: High Reliability ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Definition - Sensemaking Resources, Education, and Community View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  John Mehegan, Jazz Improvisation (1959-65) – SOCKS View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Safetymatters: Safety culture information, analysis and management: High Reliability ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Definition - Sensemaking Resources, Education, and Community View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Improvisation in management originated from jazz music and theater, gaining traction in organizational studies during the late 20th century
• Concept of organizational improvisation emerged in the 1990s challenged traditional strategic planning models
• Karl Weick's work on "organizational improvisation" in the 1970s laid groundwork for understanding improvisation in management contexts
• Evolution progressed from viewing improvisation as deviation from plans to strategic capability for organizational resilience

Evolution of Improvisation Techniques

• Improvisation techniques evolved from ad-hoc problem-solving to structured methodologies fostering innovation and agility
• Integration into management practices led to development of new organizational structures (adhocracies and holacracies)
• Contemporary management theories incorporate elements of improvisation to address rapidly changing business landscapes
  • Design thinking emphasizes iterative problem-solving and rapid prototyping
  • Lean startup methodology focuses on continuous experimentation and adaptation

Key Figures in Strategic Improvisation

Pioneering Theorists

• Karl Weick pioneered "organizational improvisation" concept and developed organizational sensemaking theory
  • Introduced idea of organizations as fluid, constantly evolving entities
  • Emphasized importance of real-time adaptation in complex environments
• Frank Barrett applied jazz improvisation principles to organizational learning and innovation processes
  • Developed "Yes to the Mess" approach for embracing uncertainty
  • Highlighted importance of minimal structures and maximal flexibility
• Mary Crossan contributed to understanding organizational learning through improvisation
  • Developed 4I Framework (Intuiting, Interpreting, Integrating, Institutionalizing)
  • Explored how improvisation bridges individual and organizational learning

Contemporary Contributors

• Claudio Ciborra explored role of improvisation in information systems management and organizational bricolage
  • Introduced concept of "bricolage" in IT management
  • Studied how organizations creatively use available resources in unpredictable environments
• Kathleen Eisenhardt studied improvisation in high-velocity environments and its impact on strategic decision-making
  • Developed theory of "simple rules" for managing in complex, fast-changing markets
  • Explored how improvisation can lead to more effective strategizing in uncertain conditions
• Miguel Pina e Cunha developed theoretical frameworks for understanding improvisation in organizations
  • Proposed typology of organizational improvisation (Opportunity-driven, Threat-driven, Learning-driven)
  • Investigated relationship between improvisation and innovation in various organizational contexts
• Christine Moorman investigated role of improvisation in marketing strategy and new product development processes
  • Studied how improvisation affects marketing performance and customer relationships
  • Explored improvisation's role in enhancing organizational memory and learning

Factors Shaping Improvisation in Business

Environmental and Technological Influences

• Increasing environmental turbulence and market volatility necessitated more adaptive management approaches
  • Rapid technological changes (AI, blockchain) require quick strategic adjustments
  • Unpredictable consumer trends demand flexible product development processes
• Advancements in technology enabled real-time data analysis and decision-making, facilitating improvisational practices
  • Big data analytics allow for instant market insights and rapid strategy shifts
  • Cloud computing enables distributed teams to collaborate and improvise in real-time
• Rise of knowledge-based economies emphasized importance of creativity and innovation
  • Shift from manufacturing to service-based economies requires more adaptive problem-solving
  • Increased value of intellectual property drives need for continuous innovation

Organizational and Cultural Shifts

• Globalization and increased competition driven organizations to seek more agile management strategies
  • Cross-cultural collaborations require flexible communication and decision-making processes
  • Global supply chains demand improvisation to handle disruptions (natural disasters, political instability)
• Shift from hierarchical to flatter organizational structures created environments conducive to improvisational practices
  • Reduced bureaucracy allows for quicker decision-making and experimentation
  • Empowered employees at all levels can contribute to improvisational problem-solving
• Cultural changes in workplace led to increased emphasis on adaptability and creative problem-solving
  • Millennials and Gen Z workers value autonomy and opportunity for creative input
  • Remote work trends require improvisation in communication and project management

Historical Influences on Strategic Improvisation

Economic and Technological Events

• Dot-com boom and bust of late 1990s and early 2000s highlighted need for adaptability in business strategies
  • Rapid rise and fall of internet companies demonstrated importance of quick pivoting
  • Survivors like Amazon showcased successful improvisation in business models
• 2008 financial crisis demonstrated limitations of traditional planning methods
  • Banks and financial institutions had to improvise new risk management strategies
  • Companies across industries learned to operate with reduced resources and uncertain futures
• Disruptive innovations forced established companies to adopt more improvisational strategies
  • Smartphone revolution upended industries (photography, music, navigation)
  • Companies like Kodak and Nokia struggled due to inability to improvise and adapt

Global Challenges and Societal Shifts

• COVID-19 pandemic accelerated adoption of improvisational practices
  • Businesses rapidly shifted to remote work models
  • Companies like distilleries improvised to produce hand sanitizer
• Increasing frequency of "black swan" events emphasized importance of organizational improvisation
  • Natural disasters (hurricanes, earthquakes) require quick supply chain adaptations
  • Geopolitical events (trade wars, Brexit) demand improvisational policy responses
• Shift towards sustainability and corporate social responsibility required businesses to improvise new solutions
  • Companies developing circular economy models (Patagonia, Interface)
  • Tech firms improvising to reduce carbon footprints (Google's AI-powered data centers)