10.4 Federal-Provincial Relations and Constitutional Debates

The Quiet Revolution sparked debates on federal-provincial relations and constitutional reform. Quebec's push for greater autonomy clashed with Ottawa's vision of a strong central government, leading to failed attempts at constitutional change like the Fulton-Favreau Formula and Victoria Charter.

These tensions highlighted the challenges of balancing provincial interests with national unity. Concepts like asymmetrical federalism emerged to address Quebec's distinct status, while bilingualism policies aimed to bridge the linguistic divide between English and French Canada.

Constitutional Reform Attempts

Proposed Amendments to the Constitution

Top images from around the web for Proposed Amendments to the Constitution

• 

  Constitution of Canada - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  History of Canada - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Labour rights, Socio-Economic Rights, and the Limitations of the Canadian Charter of Rights and ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Constitution of Canada - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  History of Canada - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Proposed Amendments to the Constitution

• 

  Constitution of Canada - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  History of Canada - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Labour rights, Socio-Economic Rights, and the Limitations of the Canadian Charter of Rights and ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Constitution of Canada - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  History of Canada - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Fulton-Favreau Formula proposed a complex amending formula requiring unanimous consent from all provinces for key parts of the constitution and a two-thirds majority for other sections
  • Failed to gain support due to concerns over provincial autonomy and the complexity of the formula
• Victoria Charter aimed to patriate the constitution, establish an amending formula, and enshrine language rights
  • Included a package of constitutional reforms that would have recognized Quebec as a distinct society within Canada
  • Ultimately failed when Quebec Premier Robert Bourassa withdrew his support, leading other provinces to follow suit

Challenges in Achieving Constitutional Reform

• Differing priorities and concerns among provinces made it difficult to reach consensus on constitutional changes
  • Western provinces sought greater control over natural resources and a stronger voice in national decision-making
  • Quebec sought recognition of its distinct status and more autonomy in areas such as immigration and social policy
• Federal government's attempts to assert its authority and drive the constitutional agenda often met with resistance from provinces
  • Provinces viewed some federal initiatives as encroaching on their jurisdiction and powers

Federal-Provincial Relations

Asymmetrical Federalism and Quebec's Distinct Status

• Asymmetrical federalism refers to the idea that provinces can have different powers and responsibilities within the federation
  • Recognizes that Quebec has a unique status due to its linguistic and cultural differences
  • Allows for flexibility in accommodating Quebec's demands for greater autonomy in certain areas
• Quebec's use of the "opting out" provision in federal-provincial agreements
  • Permitted Quebec to withdraw from federal programs and receive compensation to run its own programs in areas like pensions and health insurance

Tensions and Negotiations in Federal-Provincial Relations

• Federal government's efforts to assert national leadership and implement uniform policies across the country
  • Establishment of national programs like medicare and the Canada Pension Plan
  • Federal spending power used to influence provincial policies through conditional grants
• Provinces, particularly Quebec, sought to protect their autonomy and jurisdiction
  • Demanded greater control over areas like immigration, culture, and social policy
  • Negotiations and compromises were often necessary to maintain national unity and accommodate provincial interests

Language and Culture

Addressing Linguistic and Cultural Duality

• Bi-nationalism refers to the concept of Canada as a partnership between two founding nations: English-speaking Canada and French-speaking Quebec
  • Recognizes the distinct cultural identities and aspirations of both groups
  • Calls for the protection and promotion of both languages and cultures within the federation
• Royal Commission on Bilingualism and Biculturalism (Laurendeau-Dunton Commission) established to address growing tensions between English and French Canada
  • Recommended measures to promote bilingualism in the federal government and ensure equal opportunities for both language groups
  • Findings and recommendations laid the groundwork for official bilingualism policy

Legislation and Policies Promoting Bilingualism

• Official Languages Act of 1969 made English and French the official languages of Canada
  • Required federal government services to be available in both languages
  • Established the Office of the Commissioner of Official Languages to oversee implementation and handle complaints
• Federal funding for minority language education and cultural programs
  • Aimed to support the vitality of English and French-speaking communities across the country
• Promotion of bilingualism in the federal public service through language training and hiring practices