10.3 Framing effects and anchoring

Framing effects and anchoring are key concepts in behavioral economics. They show how our choices can be swayed by how information is presented, even when the facts don't change. This challenges the idea that we always make rational decisions based on pure logic.

These effects pop up everywhere, from how we shop to how we vote. Understanding them helps explain why people sometimes make choices that seem to go against their own interests. It's a crucial part of seeing how real-world decisions often differ from what traditional economic models predict.

Framing Effects on Decision-Making

Concept and Influence of Framing Effects

Top images from around the web for Concept and Influence of Framing Effects

• 

  What is the Prospect Theory? - The Upstream Boat View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Endowment effect - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Education and Decision-Making: An Experimental Study on the Framing Effect in China View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  What is the Prospect Theory? - The Upstream Boat View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Endowment effect - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Concept and Influence of Framing Effects

• 

  What is the Prospect Theory? - The Upstream Boat View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Endowment effect - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Education and Decision-Making: An Experimental Study on the Framing Effect in China View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  What is the Prospect Theory? - The Upstream Boat View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Endowment effect - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Framing effects occur when choices are influenced by information presentation, despite unchanged underlying facts
• Prospect theory explains how individuals evaluate potential losses and gains differently, leading to framing effects
• Positive framing emphasizes gains while negative framing emphasizes losses, significantly altering decision outcomes
• Asian disease problem demonstrates how framing affects risk preferences and decision-making
• Framing effects challenge rational decision-making assumptions in traditional economic theory
• Preferences become inconsistent and context-dependent due to framing effects
• Endowment effect manifests when people value owned items more highly, influencing willingness to trade or sell

Examples and Applications of Framing

• Restaurant menu design framing expensive items first to make other options seem more reasonable
• Health campaigns framing exercise as fun activity vs. necessary chore to increase participation
• Political rhetoric framing tax changes as relief vs. increase to sway public opinion
• Investment options presented as potential gains vs. potential losses to influence risk-taking behavior
• Product warranties framed as protection vs. additional cost to impact purchase decisions
• Environmental policies framed as preserving resources vs. restricting use to garner support

Anchoring Effect and Its Impact

Anchoring Mechanism and Influence

• Anchoring effect causes individuals to rely heavily on initial information (anchor) when making decisions or estimates
• Anchors can be relevant or irrelevant yet still influence judgments and numerical estimates
• First offer in negotiations often serves as anchor, significantly influencing final agreed-upon terms
• Anchoring leads to systematic errors in judgment, particularly for estimating probabilities, prices, or quantitative values
• Adjustment from anchor typically insufficient, even when individuals aware of anchoring effect
• Anchoring power demonstrated in judicial decisions, consumer behavior, and financial forecasting

Anchoring in Various Contexts

• Real estate pricing anchored by listing prices, influencing buyers' perceptions of property value
• Salary negotiations anchored by initial offer, affecting final compensation package
• Charitable donations influenced by suggested amounts on forms
• Product pricing strategies using higher-priced items to anchor consumer expectations
• Weather forecasts anchoring people's plans and decisions for upcoming days
• Historical stock prices anchoring investors' expectations for future performance

Framing and Anchoring in Economic Contexts

Strategic Use in Business and Marketing

• Businesses frame product value by presenting prices as discounts from higher reference price
• Decoy effect in marketing makes certain options more attractive by introducing strategic third option
• Anchoring employed in pricing strategies by setting high initial price to increase willingness to pay
• Analysts' forecasts serve as anchors in financial markets, influencing investor expectations
• Framing used in policy debates to garner support for economic initiatives by emphasizing gains or losses
• Initial offer and framing in labor negotiations significantly impact wage discussion outcomes

Consumer Behavior and Market Dynamics

• Framing effects lead to suboptimal consumer decisions (overconsumption or underutilization of resources)
• Anchoring in retail contexts causes price insensitivity among consumers, potentially reducing market efficiency
• Comparative pricing strategies leverage anchoring to influence perceived value (was $100, now$75)
• Framing of product attributes (95% fat-free vs. 5% fat) impacts consumer perception and choice
• Time-limited offers create urgency through framing, influencing purchasing decisions
• Bundling strategies use framing to make combined purchases seem more attractive

Implications of Framing and Anchoring

Policy Design and Public Perception

• Policy makers consider information presentation effects on public perception and policy support
• Default options in policy design (opt-out vs. opt-in systems for retirement savings) leverage framing effects
• Disclosure regulations and consumer protection laws account for framing effects for fair information presentation
• Framing and anchoring effects inform design of public health campaigns and environmental policies
• Ethical implications of intentionally using framing and anchoring in marketing and policy must be balanced with effectiveness, transparency, and fairness

Economic Decision-Making and Market Efficiency

• Framing effects challenge traditional economic models assuming stable preferences
• Anchoring in financial markets can lead to asset mispricing and market inefficiencies
• Understanding framing and anchoring crucial for designing effective economic policies and regulations
• Behavioral economics incorporates these effects to create more accurate models of human decision-making
• Education about framing and anchoring can improve individual decision-making and market outcomes