10.2 Maternal effects

Maternal effects shape offspring development and fitness beyond inherited genes. These influences can be genetic or environmental, arising from the mother's condition and experiences. They play a crucial role in adapting offspring to their environment.

Maternal effects manifest through various mechanisms like egg size, oviposition site selection, and maternal care. They can be adaptive or non-adaptive, influencing offspring survival, growth, and behavior. Understanding these effects is key to predicting their ecological and evolutionary consequences.

Defining maternal effects

• Maternal effects are the influence of the mother's phenotype on the phenotype of her offspring, beyond the direct effects of inherited genes
• These effects can be mediated through various mechanisms, including the provisioning of resources, hormones, and epigenetic modifications
• Maternal effects play a significant role in shaping offspring development, behavior, and fitness in a wide range of animal species

Genetic vs environmental factors

Top images from around the web for Genetic vs environmental factors

• 

  Frontiers | The differential view of genotype–phenotype relationships View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Parental Effects on Epigenetic Programming in Gametes and Embryos of Dairy Cows View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Genetic variation in offspring indirectly influences the quality of maternal behaviour in mice ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | The differential view of genotype–phenotype relationships View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Parental Effects on Epigenetic Programming in Gametes and Embryos of Dairy Cows View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Genetic vs environmental factors

• 

  Frontiers | The differential view of genotype–phenotype relationships View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Parental Effects on Epigenetic Programming in Gametes and Embryos of Dairy Cows View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Genetic variation in offspring indirectly influences the quality of maternal behaviour in mice ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | The differential view of genotype–phenotype relationships View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Parental Effects on Epigenetic Programming in Gametes and Embryos of Dairy Cows View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Maternal effects can arise from both genetic and environmental factors
• Genetic maternal effects involve the transmission of maternal alleles that influence offspring phenotype (mitochondrial DNA)
• Environmental maternal effects result from the mother's experience and condition, such as her nutritional status or exposure to stressors
• The relative importance of genetic and environmental maternal effects can vary across species and contexts

Adaptive vs non-adaptive effects

• Maternal effects can be adaptive, enhancing offspring fitness in specific environments
• Adaptive maternal effects allow mothers to adjust offspring phenotype in response to environmental cues (maternal provisioning in unpredictable environments)
• Non-adaptive maternal effects may arise as byproducts of maternal condition or constraints
• Some maternal effects can be maladaptive, reducing offspring fitness (maternal stress leading to reduced offspring size)

Types of maternal effects

• Maternal effects can manifest through various mechanisms, each with distinct implications for offspring development and fitness
• The type and magnitude of maternal effects can vary depending on the species, environment, and life history strategy
• Understanding the diversity of maternal effects is crucial for predicting their ecological and evolutionary consequences

Egg size and composition

• Egg size is a common form of maternal effect, with larger eggs providing more resources for embryonic development
• Variation in egg composition, such as yolk hormones or carotenoids, can influence offspring growth, immunity, and behavior (androgen levels in bird eggs affecting aggression)
• Egg size and composition can be influenced by maternal age, condition, and environmental factors

Oviposition site selection

• Maternal choice of oviposition site can determine the environmental conditions experienced by offspring during development
• Oviposition site selection can affect offspring exposure to predators, parasites, and resource availability (butterfly mothers preferring host plants with lower predation risk)
• Adaptive oviposition site selection can enhance offspring survival and performance in specific environments

Maternal care and provisioning

• Maternal care, such as lactation in mammals or provisioning in birds, can have profound effects on offspring growth and development
• The quality and quantity of maternal care can be influenced by maternal condition, experience, and environmental factors (increased provisioning in response to food availability)
• Maternal care can buffer offspring against environmental stressors and promote social learning and skill acquisition

Mechanisms of maternal effects

• Maternal effects can be mediated through various physiological and molecular mechanisms
• Understanding the underlying mechanisms of maternal effects is essential for elucidating their proximate causes and potential constraints
• Advances in molecular and developmental biology have provided new insights into the mechanisms of maternal effects

Epigenetic modifications

• Epigenetic modifications, such as DNA methylation and histone modifications, can be influenced by maternal condition and experience
• Maternal epigenetic effects can alter gene expression in offspring, leading to changes in phenotype and behavior (maternal stress altering offspring stress responsiveness)
• Epigenetic maternal effects can be transgenerational, persisting across multiple generations

Hormonal influences

• Maternal hormones, such as testosterone, cortisol, and thyroid hormones, can be transferred to offspring through eggs or during gestation
• Maternal hormones can influence offspring growth, metabolism, and behavior (elevated maternal cortisol leading to increased anxiety in offspring)
• Hormonal maternal effects can be adaptive, preparing offspring for specific environmental conditions

Resource allocation

• Maternal resource allocation, such as the provisioning of nutrients, antibodies, and microbiota, can shape offspring development and fitness
• The quantity and quality of maternal resources can be influenced by maternal condition, diet, and environmental factors (maternal malnutrition affecting offspring growth and immunity)
• Differential resource allocation among offspring can lead to variation in offspring size and competitive ability

Evolutionary significance

• Maternal effects can have important evolutionary consequences by influencing offspring fitness and population dynamics
• The adaptive value of maternal effects depends on the match between maternal environment and offspring environment
• Maternal effects can contribute to the maintenance of phenotypic variation and facilitate rapid adaptation to changing environments

Maternal effects on offspring fitness

• Maternal effects can directly influence offspring survival, growth, and reproduction
• Adaptive maternal effects can enhance offspring fitness in specific environments (larger egg size improving offspring survival in resource-poor conditions)
• Maladaptive maternal effects can reduce offspring fitness, potentially leading to population declines

Role in phenotypic plasticity

• Maternal effects can contribute to phenotypic plasticity, allowing offspring to adjust their phenotype in response to environmental cues
• Maternal effects can facilitate the transmission of environmental information across generations (maternal temperature exposure influencing offspring thermal tolerance)
• Phenotypic plasticity mediated by maternal effects can enable rapid adaptation to changing environments

Influence on population dynamics

• Maternal effects can influence population dynamics by altering offspring recruitment, survival, and dispersal
• Positive maternal effects can lead to increased population growth and stability (maternal provisioning enhancing offspring survival)
• Negative maternal effects can contribute to population fluctuations and declines (maternal stress reducing offspring fitness)

Examples across taxa

• Maternal effects have been documented in a wide range of animal taxa, from invertebrates to mammals
• The prevalence and magnitude of maternal effects can vary across species, reflecting differences in life history strategies and environmental pressures
• Comparative studies of maternal effects across taxa can provide insights into their ecological and evolutionary significance

Insects and other invertebrates

• Maternal effects are common in insects, often mediated through egg size, composition, and oviposition site selection
• In butterflies, maternal choice of host plant can influence offspring growth and survival (monarch butterflies preferring milkweed with lower cardenolide levels)
• Maternal effects in insects can be influenced by factors such as maternal age, diet, and parasite load

Fish and amphibians

• Maternal effects in fish and amphibians can be mediated through egg size, yolk composition, and parental care
• In some fish species, maternal provisioning of carotenoids can enhance offspring coloration and immunity (guppies allocating more carotenoids to offspring in high-predation environments)
• Maternal exposure to predator cues can induce adaptive changes in offspring morphology and behavior (tadpoles developing deeper tails in response to maternal predator exposure)

Reptiles and birds

• Maternal effects in reptiles and birds can be mediated through egg size, composition, and incubation conditions
• In lizards, maternal basking behavior can influence offspring sex ratios and performance (higher incubation temperatures producing more male offspring)
• In birds, maternal allocation of androgens to eggs can affect offspring growth, begging behavior, and aggression (higher androgen levels in eggs of subordinate females)

Mammals

• Maternal effects in mammals can be mediated through gestation, lactation, and maternal care
• Maternal nutrition during gestation can influence offspring growth, metabolism, and health (maternal obesity increasing offspring risk of metabolic disorders)
• Maternal care, such as licking and grooming in rodents, can influence offspring stress responsiveness and social behavior (high-licking mothers producing offspring with lower stress reactivity)

Interactions with other factors

• Maternal effects can interact with other factors, such as paternal effects, environmental conditions, and offspring life stage
• Considering these interactions is essential for understanding the complex dynamics of maternal effects in natural populations
• Integrative studies that incorporate multiple factors can provide a more comprehensive understanding of maternal effects

Maternal effects and paternal effects

• Maternal effects can interact with paternal effects, such as paternal provisioning or genetic influences
• The relative importance of maternal and paternal effects can vary across species and contexts (maternal effects more important in species with high maternal investment)
• Studies that consider both maternal and paternal effects can provide insights into the evolution of parental care strategies

Environmental context and variability

• The expression and adaptive value of maternal effects can depend on the environmental context
• Maternal effects that are adaptive in one environment may be maladaptive in another (larger offspring size advantageous in resource-poor environments but not in resource-rich environments)
• Environmental variability can influence the evolution of maternal effects, with greater variability favoring more flexible maternal strategies

Maternal effects across life stages

• The impact of maternal effects can vary across offspring life stages, from embryonic development to adulthood
• Early-life maternal effects can have persistent consequences for offspring phenotype and fitness (maternal stress during gestation affecting offspring behavior in adulthood)
• Maternal effects can also interact with offspring experiences and environmental conditions later in life

Methods for studying maternal effects

• Various experimental and analytical approaches can be used to study maternal effects in animal populations
• The choice of method depends on the research question, study system, and available resources
• Combining multiple approaches can provide a more comprehensive understanding of maternal effects

Experimental manipulation

• Experimental manipulations can be used to isolate the effects of specific maternal factors on offspring phenotype
• Common manipulations include altering maternal diet, stress levels, or hormone exposure (supplementing maternal diet with carotenoids)
• Cross-fostering experiments can be used to separate maternal effects from genetic effects (exchanging offspring between mothers)

Cross-fostering designs

• Cross-fostering involves transferring offspring between mothers or nests to separate maternal effects from genetic effects
• Full cross-fostering designs involve reciprocal exchanges of offspring between mothers (exchanging entire clutches between nests)
• Partial cross-fostering designs involve exchanging a subset of offspring between mothers (fostering half of the offspring from each nest)
• Cross-fostering experiments can be used to quantify the relative importance of maternal effects and genetic effects on offspring phenotype

Quantitative genetic approaches

• Quantitative genetic methods can be used to partition the variance in offspring traits into maternal, paternal, and genetic components
• These methods involve measuring traits in parents and offspring and estimating heritability and maternal effect coefficients (using animal models)
• Quantitative genetic approaches can be used to study the evolution of maternal effects and their genetic basis

Applications and implications

• Understanding maternal effects has important applications in conservation, animal breeding, and human health
• Maternal effects can influence population viability, productivity, and resilience to environmental change
• Considering maternal effects can inform management strategies and improve outcomes in various applied contexts

Conservation and management

• Maternal effects can influence population dynamics and viability in wild populations
• Conservation strategies that account for maternal effects can be more effective in promoting population recovery (managing maternal nutrition in endangered species)
• Maternal effects can also influence the success of captive breeding and reintroduction programs (providing appropriate maternal care in captivity)

Livestock and animal breeding

• Maternal effects can influence production traits and efficiency in livestock and aquaculture
• Selective breeding programs that consider maternal effects can improve offspring performance and welfare (selecting for maternal care in pigs)
• Optimizing maternal nutrition and management can enhance offspring growth and health in animal production systems

Human health and development

• Maternal effects can have important implications for human health and development
• Maternal nutrition, stress, and exposure to toxins during pregnancy can influence offspring health outcomes (maternal obesity increasing offspring risk of metabolic disorders)
• Understanding the mechanisms of maternal effects can inform interventions to promote healthy development and prevent disease (providing maternal micronutrient supplementation)
• Studies of maternal effects in animal models can provide insights into the role of early-life experiences in shaping human health and behavior