10.5 Painting and ledger art

Ledger art emerged in the late 19th century as Native Americans adapted their artistic traditions to new materials. This unique art form shifted from hide paintings to paper, allowing tribes to document their changing lives and preserve their culture during a time of intense upheaval.

Ledger artists used pencils, ink, and crayons to depict warrior exploits, daily life, and spiritual practices. The art served as both cultural preservation and resistance against forced assimilation, evolving over time to include contemporary themes and techniques.

Origins of ledger art

• Ledger art emerged as a unique form of Native American artistic expression during the late 19th century
• Represents a significant shift in traditional Plains Indian art forms, adapting to new materials and circumstances
• Reflects the cultural resilience and adaptability of Native American tribes during a period of intense change

Pre-reservation art forms

Top images from around the web for Pre-reservation art forms

• 

  Rock Art-59 | The ancient Chumash people drew pictographs of… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:NEWSPAPER ROCK IS A LARGE CLIFF MURAL OF ANCIENT INDIAN PETROGLYPHS AND PICTOGRAPHS ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Native American Petroglyphs | Fremont Culture petroglyphs, l… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Rock Art-59 | The ancient Chumash people drew pictographs of… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:NEWSPAPER ROCK IS A LARGE CLIFF MURAL OF ANCIENT INDIAN PETROGLYPHS AND PICTOGRAPHS ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Pre-reservation art forms

• 

  Rock Art-59 | The ancient Chumash people drew pictographs of… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:NEWSPAPER ROCK IS A LARGE CLIFF MURAL OF ANCIENT INDIAN PETROGLYPHS AND PICTOGRAPHS ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Native American Petroglyphs | Fremont Culture petroglyphs, l… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Rock Art-59 | The ancient Chumash people drew pictographs of… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:NEWSPAPER ROCK IS A LARGE CLIFF MURAL OF ANCIENT INDIAN PETROGLYPHS AND PICTOGRAPHS ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Rock art and petroglyphs served as early visual storytelling methods
• Hide paintings on buffalo robes and tipi covers depicted important events and personal achievements
• Pictographs on animal skins used natural pigments to record tribal histories and individual accomplishments
• Winter counts chronicled yearly events through symbolic imagery on animal hides

Transition to paper medium

• Introduction of ledger books and other paper materials by European traders and military personnel
• Shift from natural materials to readily available paper and new drawing tools (pencils, ink, crayons)
• Adaptation of traditional artistic styles to fit the rectangular format of ledger pages
• Smaller scale of paper allowed for more detailed and intimate depictions of scenes

Influence of reservation life

• Confinement to reservations limited access to traditional art materials and subjects
• Ledger art provided a means to document and preserve cultural practices and histories
• Reflected changing lifestyles and experiences of Native Americans on reservations
• Served as a form of resistance and cultural continuity in the face of forced assimilation policies

Materials and techniques

Traditional pigments and tools

• Natural pigments derived from mineral sources (ochre, hematite, clay)
• Plant-based dyes extracted from roots, berries, and bark
• Animal-based pigments (blood, bile)
• Application tools included bone brushes, sticks, and fingers
• Techniques involved grinding pigments and mixing with binders (animal fat, plant sap)

Adaptation to new materials

• Transition to commercially produced paper (ledger books, sketchbooks, loose sheets)
• Adoption of graphite pencils, colored pencils, and ink pens
• Experimentation with watercolors and crayons introduced by traders and government agents
• Integration of new color palettes beyond traditional earth tones
• Development of techniques to work with thinner, more delicate paper surfaces

Symbolism in ledger art

• Use of specific colors to represent spiritual or cultural significance (red for war, blue for peace)
• Depiction of shield designs and personal medicine symbols to indicate warrior status
• Representation of coup counts through specific imagery (horse tracks, handprints)
• Inclusion of traditional tribal patterns and motifs within figurative scenes
• Symbolic use of space and composition to convey narrative elements

Themes and subjects

Warrior exploits

• Depictions of battle scenes and individual combat encounters
• Representations of horse raids and the capture of enemy horses
• Illustrations of war honors and achievements (counting coup, capturing weapons)
• Portrayal of war parties and preparation for battle
• Documentation of specific historical conflicts and skirmishes

Daily life scenes

• Illustrations of hunting practices and techniques
• Depictions of camp life and domestic activities
• Representations of courtship and social interactions
• Portrayals of traditional games and sports
• Documentation of trade encounters and intertribal gatherings

Spiritual and ceremonial depictions

• Illustrations of vision quests and spiritual experiences
• Representations of important tribal ceremonies (Sun Dance, Ghost Dance)
• Depictions of medicine men and healing practices
• Portrayals of sacred objects and their use in rituals
• Documentation of creation stories and mythological figures

Notable ledger artists

Howling Wolf

• Southern Cheyenne artist known for his detailed battle scenes
• Created works while imprisoned at Fort Marion in St. Augustine, Florida
• Distinctive style characterized by dynamic figures and vivid color use
• Documented both traditional Cheyenne life and new experiences of confinement
• Works provide valuable insights into Cheyenne culture and history

Black Hawk

• Sans Arc Lakota artist renowned for his spiritual and visionary drawings
• Produced a significant body of work in the late 19th century
• Depicted complex spiritual concepts and experiences in his ledger art
• Unique style incorporated both realistic and abstract elements
• Works offer rare glimpses into Lakota cosmology and religious practices

Fort Marion artists

• Group of Native American prisoners held at Fort Marion from 1875-1878
• Included members of various Plains tribes (Cheyenne, Kiowa, Comanche, Arapaho)
• Encouraged to create ledger art by their captor, Captain Richard Henry Pratt
• Developed distinctive styles influenced by their confinement and new surroundings
• Works document the transition from traditional life to imprisonment and forced assimilation

Cultural significance

Preservation of tribal history

• Ledger art serves as a visual record of important events and cultural practices
• Documents traditional ways of life that were rapidly changing or disappearing
• Preserves stories and legends that might otherwise have been lost
• Provides indigenous perspectives on historical events often absent from written records
• Aids in the intergenerational transmission of cultural knowledge and values

Resistance through art

• Creation of ledger art as an act of cultural persistence in the face of assimilation policies
• Use of art to maintain and assert tribal identity under oppressive conditions
• Depiction of traditional practices and beliefs as a form of silent protest
• Incorporation of coded messages and symbols to communicate within the community
• Ledger art as a means of psychological and emotional survival during confinement

Identity expression

• Ledger art as a medium for individual and collective self-representation
• Depiction of personal achievements and status within tribal society
• Expression of cultural pride through the portrayal of traditional customs and dress
• Exploration of changing identities in the context of forced cultural transitions
• Use of art to negotiate between traditional values and new realities of reservation life

Evolution of ledger art

19th century vs 20th century

• Shift from primarily male artists to inclusion of female artists
• Expansion of themes beyond warrior exploits to broader cultural representations
• Incorporation of contemporary issues and experiences in later works
• Evolution of artistic styles, blending traditional elements with modern techniques
• Increased recognition of ledger art as a significant form of Native American expression

Contemporary ledger artists

• Modern artists reviving and reinterpreting the ledger art tradition
• Use of antique ledger books and documents as a connection to the past
• Incorporation of contemporary themes and social commentary in ledger-style works
• Experimentation with mixed media and digital techniques
• Exploration of identity, cultural reclamation, and historical trauma through ledger art

Influence on modern Native art

• Ledger art techniques and aesthetics inspiring contemporary Native American painters
• Integration of ledger art elements in mixed media and installation works
• Influence on graphic design and illustration in Native American contexts
• Ledger art as a foundation for exploring themes of cultural continuity and change
• Inspiration for new forms of visual storytelling in Native American communities

Collecting and preservation

Early collectors and anthropologists

• 19th-century military personnel and traders as initial collectors of ledger art
• Anthropologists recognizing the cultural and historical value of ledger drawings
• Early museum acquisitions establishing important collections of ledger art
• Role of collectors in preserving works that might otherwise have been lost
• Debates over the ethics of collecting and removing art from tribal communities

Museum collections

• Major institutions housing significant ledger art collections (Smithsonian, Denver Art Museum)
• Challenges in properly attributing and contextualizing ledger art pieces
• Development of specialized conservation techniques for fragile ledger materials
• Efforts to make collections more accessible to Native communities and researchers
• Collaborations between museums and tribal representatives for interpretation and display

Conservation challenges

• Fragility of paper and pigments used in ledger art
• Issues of fading and deterioration due to light exposure and environmental factors
• Challenges in preserving the integrity of bound ledger books
• Development of specialized storage and display methods to protect works
• Balancing preservation needs with accessibility for study and exhibition

Ledger art in education

Teaching tribal histories

• Use of ledger art as primary sources in Native American history curricula
• Integration of ledger art analysis in social studies and cultural education programs
• Development of educational resources and lesson plans centered on ledger art
• Collaboration between educators and tribal representatives to ensure accurate interpretation
• Ledger art as a tool for teaching visual literacy and historical thinking skills

Art therapy applications

• Adaptation of ledger art techniques in therapeutic settings for Native American clients
• Use of ledger art creation as a means of processing historical trauma and cultural loss
• Integration of traditional symbolism and storytelling in art therapy practices
• Development of culturally responsive art therapy programs in Native communities
• Research on the healing potential of ledger art-inspired activities

Cultural revitalization efforts

• Ledger art workshops and classes in tribal communities to revive traditional practices
• Use of ledger art in language preservation efforts, combining visual and verbal storytelling
• Integration of ledger art techniques in youth education programs to strengthen cultural identity
• Community art projects inspired by ledger art to promote intergenerational connections
• Digital archiving and sharing of historical ledger art to inspire new generations of artists

Ledger art market

Authenticity and attribution

• Challenges in verifying the authenticity of historical ledger art pieces
• Development of expertise in identifying individual artists' styles and techniques
• Use of provenance research to establish the origins and history of ledger art works
• Collaboration between art historians, anthropologists, and tribal experts in attribution efforts
• Ethical considerations in the authentication and sale of culturally significant artworks

Valuation and collecting trends

• Increasing recognition of ledger art as a significant form of Native American fine art
• Growth in market value for both historical and contemporary ledger art pieces
• Emergence of specialized galleries and auction houses focusing on ledger art
• Influence of major museum exhibitions on collector interest and market trends
• Debates over the commodification of cultural heritage through art market transactions

Ethical considerations

• Issues surrounding the ownership and repatriation of historical ledger art
• Concerns about the appropriation of ledger art styles by non-Native artists
• Debates over the representation and interpretation of ledger art in commercial contexts
• Efforts to ensure fair compensation and recognition for contemporary Native ledger artists
• Development of ethical guidelines for the collection, display, and sale of ledger art