11.1 Common auction formats and their properties

Auctions come in various formats, each with unique rules and strategies. From open English auctions to sealed-bid Vickrey auctions, these mechanisms allocate goods and determine prices. Understanding these formats is crucial for both buyers and sellers.

Auction design involves key considerations like efficiency and revenue maximization. Factors such as reserve prices, information revelation, and the potential for winner's curse impact outcomes. These elements shape bidding behavior and auction results.

Auction Formats

Open Auctions

Top images from around the web for Open Auctions

• 

  Game theory - Simulace.info View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Auctioning risk: the all-pay auction under mean-variance preferences | Economic Theory View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Game theory - Simulace.info View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Auctioning risk: the all-pay auction under mean-variance preferences | Economic Theory View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 2

Top images from around the web for Open Auctions

• 

  Game theory - Simulace.info View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Auctioning risk: the all-pay auction under mean-variance preferences | Economic Theory View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Game theory - Simulace.info View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Auctioning risk: the all-pay auction under mean-variance preferences | Economic Theory View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 2

• English auction: bidders openly compete by placing increasingly higher bids until no participant is willing to bid further, with the highest bidder winning the item and paying their bid price (art auctions, real estate)
• Dutch auction: the auctioneer begins with a high price and lowers it incrementally until a bidder accepts the current price, winning the item at that price (flower auctions in the Netherlands, U.S. Treasury securities)
• All-pay auction: all bidders submit bids, but every participant pays their bid regardless of whether they win the item or not, with the highest bidder winning the item (lobbying, research and development races)

Sealed-Bid Auctions

• First-price sealed-bid auction: each bidder submits a single sealed bid without knowing others' bids, and the highest bidder wins, paying the amount of their own bid (government contracts, real estate)
• Second-price sealed-bid auction (Vickrey auction): bidders submit sealed bids, with the highest bidder winning but paying the second-highest bid price instead of their own, incentivizing truthful bidding (online advertising, some charity auctions)

Auction Types

Private Value Auctions

• Private value auctions occur when each bidder has a unique valuation for the item based on their own preferences and circumstances, which is independent of other bidders' valuations (personal goods, collectibles)
• In private value auctions, bidders have no incentive to change their valuation based on others' bids, as the item's worth to them remains constant regardless of other participants' valuations or actions

Common Value Auctions

• Common value auctions take place when the item has an objective, shared value for all bidders, but each bidder has incomplete information about this true value and must estimate it based on their own signals (oil drilling rights, spectrum licenses)
• In common value auctions, bidders' valuations are interdependent, as they are all attempting to estimate the same underlying value, and learning about other bidders' signals can cause individuals to update their own valuation

Winner's Curse

• Winner's curse refers to the phenomenon in common value auctions where the winning bidder often overpays relative to the item's true value, as they likely had the most optimistic estimate among all bidders
• To avoid the winner's curse, rational bidders should adjust their bids downward, taking into account the information revealed by winning the auction and the possibility that their initial estimate was overly optimistic (offshore oil leases, book publishing rights)

Auction Design Considerations

Reserve Prices and Efficiency

• A reserve price is a minimum acceptable bid set by the auctioneer, below which the item will not be sold, used to prevent the item from being sold at an unacceptably low price (eBay auctions, art sales)
• Setting a reserve price can increase the auctioneer's expected revenue but may reduce auction efficiency, as it can prevent the item from being allocated to the bidder with the highest valuation if their bid falls below the reserve
• Efficiency in auctions refers to the concept of allocating the item to the bidder who values it the most, maximizing social welfare by ensuring the item goes to the party that derives the greatest utility from it

Revenue Maximization Strategies

• Auctioneers often design auctions with the goal of maximizing their expected revenue, which can involve setting optimal reserve prices, choosing the most appropriate auction format, and strategically revealing information to bidders
• Revenue equivalence theorem states that under certain conditions (risk-neutral bidders, independent private values, symmetric bidders), different auction formats will yield the same expected revenue for the auctioneer (first-price vs. second-price auctions)
• Auctioneers may also employ tactics such as bundling multiple items together, using multi-unit auctions, or implementing dynamic pricing mechanisms to extract more revenue from bidders (spectrum auctions, online advertising)