11.6 Ethical standards in archaeological research

Archaeological ethics are crucial for responsible research and cultural preservation. They guide interactions with communities, artifact treatment, and research dissemination. Key principles include respecting heritage, minimizing site disturbance, proper documentation, and community collaboration.

Ethical challenges in archaeology include combating looting, balancing research with preservation, and addressing ownership disputes. Professional codes of ethics, like those from SAA and WAC, provide guidelines. Fieldwork ethics involve obtaining permits, using responsible techniques, and respecting human remains.

Importance of ethics in archaeology

• Ethics play a crucial role in archaeology by ensuring that research is conducted responsibly, respectfully, and in a way that preserves cultural heritage for future generations
• Ethical principles guide archaeologists in their interactions with local communities, treatment of artifacts and sites, and dissemination of research findings
• Adhering to ethical standards helps maintain the integrity of the discipline and fosters trust between archaeologists and the public

Key ethical principles

Respect for cultural heritage

Top images from around the web for Respect for cultural heritage

• 

  Using Persistent Identifiers (PIDs) to ensure Indigenous Knowledge and Cultural Heritage ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Preserving cultural heritage through state-of-the-art technology | UCT News View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Egyptian Artifacts. National Archaeological Museum, Athens, Greece (3210678336).jpg ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Using Persistent Identifiers (PIDs) to ensure Indigenous Knowledge and Cultural Heritage ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Preserving cultural heritage through state-of-the-art technology | UCT News View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Respect for cultural heritage

• 

  Using Persistent Identifiers (PIDs) to ensure Indigenous Knowledge and Cultural Heritage ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Preserving cultural heritage through state-of-the-art technology | UCT News View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Egyptian Artifacts. National Archaeological Museum, Athens, Greece (3210678336).jpg ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Using Persistent Identifiers (PIDs) to ensure Indigenous Knowledge and Cultural Heritage ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Preserving cultural heritage through state-of-the-art technology | UCT News View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Archaeologists must recognize the inherent value and significance of cultural heritage to descendant communities and humanity as a whole
• Respect involves treating artifacts, sites, and human remains with dignity and sensitivity
• Archaeologists should strive to minimize damage or alteration to cultural heritage during research and prioritize its long-term preservation

Minimizing site disturbance

• Excavation is an inherently destructive process, so archaeologists must carefully plan and execute their work to minimize unnecessary disturbance
• Non-invasive techniques (remote sensing, ground-penetrating radar) should be used whenever possible to gather data without physically impacting sites
• When excavation is necessary, archaeologists should use precise, targeted methods and thoroughly document all findings and site contexts

Proper documentation and reporting

• Accurate, detailed documentation is essential for preserving information about archaeological sites and artifacts for future study
• Archaeologists must maintain clear, organized records of their fieldwork, lab analyses, and interpretations
• Research findings should be promptly reported through peer-reviewed publications, conference presentations, and public outreach to share knowledge and invite scholarly critique

Collaboration with local communities

• Archaeologists have an ethical obligation to engage with and involve local communities in the research process, especially descendant groups with cultural ties to the sites being studied
• Collaboration can take many forms, such as consultation on research design, employment of local workers, and incorporation of traditional knowledge into interpretations
• Archaeologists should strive to build long-term, mutually beneficial relationships with local communities based on trust, respect, and open communication

Ethical challenges

Looting and illegal antiquities trade

• The illicit excavation and sale of artifacts on the black market is a major ethical challenge facing archaeology
• Looting destroys archaeological context, hampering our ability to understand the past, and often funds organized crime or terrorism
• Archaeologists must work to combat looting through public education, supporting law enforcement efforts, and refusing to study or publish on looted artifacts

Balancing research vs preservation

• Archaeologists often face difficult decisions about whether to prioritize research goals or site preservation
• In some cases, excavation may be necessary to gather critical data before a site is threatened by development or natural disasters
• However, archaeologists must carefully weigh the potential benefits of excavation against the irreversible impacts on the site and consider alternative approaches

Ownership and repatriation disputes

• Determining rightful ownership of archaeological artifacts and human remains can be a complex ethical issue, particularly in post-colonial contexts
• Indigenous communities may have legal and moral claims to cultural heritage held in museums or private collections
• Archaeologists must navigate these disputes with sensitivity and work towards fair, culturally appropriate solutions (repatriation, co-management agreements)

Impacts of colonialism on archaeology

• Archaeology has historically been intertwined with colonialism, as Western nations used the discipline to assert control over colonized territories and peoples
• This legacy continues to shape power dynamics and ethical challenges in archaeology today
• Archaeologists must critically examine and work to dismantle colonial structures within the discipline, centering the perspectives and rights of Indigenous and descendant communities

Professional codes of ethics

Society for American Archaeology (SAA)

• The SAA is a major professional organization for archaeologists working in the Americas
• Its Principles of Archaeological Ethics, adopted in 1996, outline eight key responsibilities for archaeologists, including stewardship, accountability, and public education
• The SAA Ethics Committee investigates alleged violations of the code and can impose sanctions (censure, expulsion) on members

World Archaeological Congress (WAC)

• WAC is a global organization that promotes the development of archaeology in underrepresented regions and fosters collaboration between archaeologists and Indigenous communities
• Its First Code of Ethics, adopted in 1990, emphasizes the rights of Indigenous peoples to control their own cultural heritage and participate in archaeological research
• WAC has played a leading role in advocating for repatriation and confronting the discipline's colonial legacies

Register of Professional Archaeologists (RPA)

• The RPA is a voluntary certification program that sets standards for professional conduct in archaeology
• To become registered, archaeologists must meet educational and experience requirements and agree to abide by the RPA Code of Conduct
• The code covers issues such as research integrity, public outreach, and respectful treatment of human remains
• RPA can investigate complaints against registered archaeologists and issue disciplinary actions (letter of admonishment, suspension, termination of registration)

Ethical considerations in fieldwork

Obtaining proper permits and permissions

• Before beginning fieldwork, archaeologists must secure all necessary permits and permissions from relevant government agencies and landowners
• In many countries, a national antiquities authority regulates archaeological research and issues excavation permits
• Archaeologists should also obtain informed consent from local communities, particularly Indigenous groups, before conducting fieldwork on their lands

Responsible excavation techniques

• Archaeologists have an ethical duty to use excavation methods that minimize damage to sites and maximize data recovery
• This may involve using smaller, targeted excavation units rather than large-scale trenches, and carefully documenting the location and context of all artifacts and features
• Archaeologists should also take steps to protect exposed features (walls, floors) from erosion and collapse during and after excavation

Treatment of human remains

• Human remains are a sensitive and sacred aspect of archaeological sites that require special ethical considerations
• Archaeologists should only excavate human remains when absolutely necessary for research purposes and with the consent of descendant communities
• Remains should be treated with the utmost respect and care, and reburied promptly in consultation with descendant groups
• In some cases, descendant communities may prefer that human remains be left undisturbed, and archaeologists must honor these wishes

Site conservation and restoration

• Archaeologists have an ongoing responsibility to protect and conserve sites after excavation is complete
• This may involve backfilling excavated areas, installing protective covers or shelters, and monitoring sites for erosion or damage
• In some cases, archaeologists may work with local communities to develop site management plans and train local stewards to help protect sites over the long term
• Where appropriate, archaeologists may also engage in site restoration projects to stabilize and interpret sites for public education and tourism

Ethical responsibilities in research

Accurate data collection and analysis

• Archaeologists have a fundamental ethical obligation to collect and analyze data accurately and objectively
• This requires using appropriate sampling strategies, recording methods, and analytical techniques, and being transparent about any limitations or uncertainties in the data
• Archaeologists must also be vigilant against bias or misinterpretation in their analyses, and be willing to revise their conclusions in light of new evidence

Peer review and publication standards

• Peer review is an essential ethical safeguard in archaeological research, ensuring that findings are scrutinized by expert colleagues before publication
• Archaeologists should submit their work to reputable, peer-reviewed journals and be open to constructive criticism and feedback
• They should also strive to publish their results in a timely manner, making data and interpretations available to the broader scientific community

Acknowledgment of contributors

• Archaeological research is often a collaborative endeavor, involving contributions from many individuals (field crews, lab assistants, local informants)
• Archaeologists have an ethical responsibility to properly acknowledge and credit all contributors to a project, whether through co-authorship, acknowledgments, or other forms of recognition
• This is particularly important for recognizing the contributions of students, early-career researchers, and members of local or descendant communities

Responsible use of research funds

• Archaeologists must use research funds ethically and efficiently, ensuring that grant money is spent on legitimate, approved expenses
• They should maintain clear financial records and be transparent with funders about how money is being used
• Archaeologists should also be mindful of the broader impacts of their research spending, such as hiring and training local workers or supporting community development projects

Ethical issues in public engagement

Respectful communication of findings

• Archaeologists have an ethical responsibility to communicate their findings to the public in a way that is accurate, accessible, and respectful of descendant communities
• This may involve working with museums, schools, or media outlets to develop exhibits, educational materials, or documentaries that present archaeological research in a responsible and engaging way
• Archaeologists should also be mindful of the potential impacts of their work on descendant communities and be willing to modify or withhold sensitive information if necessary

Addressing pseudoarchaeology claims

• Pseudoarchaeology refers to claims about the past that are not supported by scientific evidence, such as ancient alien theories or lost civilization myths
• Archaeologists have an ethical obligation to counter these claims with accurate information and critical thinking, while also being respectful of the beliefs and motivations of those who hold them
• This may involve writing popular articles, giving public lectures, or engaging in social media discussions to promote responsible, evidence-based understandings of the past

Promoting heritage site protection

• Archaeologists can play an important role in promoting the protection and preservation of heritage sites, both through their research and public outreach efforts
• This may involve working with government agencies, NGOs, or local communities to develop site management plans, nominate sites for protected status, or raise awareness about threats to cultural heritage
• Archaeologists should also be advocates for responsible tourism and development practices that minimize impacts on archaeological sites and respect the rights of local communities

Fostering community stewardship

• Ultimately, the long-term protection and preservation of archaeological sites depends on the active engagement and stewardship of local communities
• Archaeologists can help foster this sense of stewardship by involving communities in the research process, providing training and resources for site monitoring and management, and supporting local heritage education initiatives
• By building strong, collaborative relationships with descendant communities, archaeologists can help ensure that archaeological heritage is valued and protected for generations to come

Navigating ethical dilemmas

Weighing competing stakeholder interests

• Archaeological research often involves balancing the interests and needs of multiple stakeholders, including descendant communities, government agencies, funders, and the general public
• Archaeologists must navigate these competing interests with care and sensitivity, seeking to find solutions that respect the rights and concerns of all parties involved
• This may require difficult compromises or trade-offs, such as modifying research plans to accommodate community wishes or delaying publication to allow for consultation and review

Adapting to evolving ethical standards

• Ethical standards in archaeology are not static, but rather evolve over time in response to new social, political, and technological contexts
• Archaeologists must be willing to adapt their practices and perspectives to keep pace with these changes, even if it means challenging long-held assumptions or ways of doing things
• This requires ongoing reflection, dialogue, and learning, as well as a commitment to staying informed about developments in archaeological ethics and heritage management

Seeking guidance from professional organizations

• When faced with ethical dilemmas or uncertainties, archaeologists can turn to professional organizations like the SAA, WAC, and RPA for guidance and support
• These organizations provide resources, training, and advice on navigating ethical challenges, as well as a community of peers who can offer insights and perspectives based on their own experiences
• Archaeologists should familiarize themselves with the codes of ethics and grievance procedures of these organizations, and be willing to seek their assistance when needed

Ongoing reflection and improvement

• Ultimately, ethical practice in archaeology requires a commitment to ongoing reflection, learning, and improvement
• Archaeologists must be willing to critically examine their own assumptions, biases, and practices, and be open to feedback and critique from colleagues and community partners
• They should also strive to stay current with developments in archaeological theory, method, and ethics, and be willing to adapt their approaches as new insights emerge
• By embracing a culture of ongoing reflection and improvement, archaeologists can help ensure that their discipline remains a force for good in the world, contributing to our understanding of the past while also promoting justice, equity, and respect for all people in the present