11.2 Feminist critiques of conservatism and nationalism

Feminist critiques of conservatism and nationalism challenge traditional gender roles and power structures. These ideologies often prioritize nuclear families, reinforce patriarchal norms, and use gendered language to promote national identity, limiting individual autonomy and perpetuating inequalities.

Conservative and nationalist views impact women's rights, LGBTQ+ acceptance, and cultural diversity. Feminists argue these ideologies restrict progress towards gender equality by emphasizing traditional values, invoking idealized womanhood, and intersecting with religious beliefs that entrench gendered expectations.

Gender and Ideology

Gendered Implications of Conservative and Nationalist Ideologies

Top images from around the web for Gendered Implications of Conservative and Nationalist Ideologies

• 

  She wants the destruction of the patriarchy | Women's March … | Sasha Kimel | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  19th Century Feminist Movements | Introduction to Women Gender Sexuality Studies View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Women across the world demand end to gender-based violence : Peoples Dispatch View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  She wants the destruction of the patriarchy | Women's March … | Sasha Kimel | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  19th Century Feminist Movements | Introduction to Women Gender Sexuality Studies View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Gendered Implications of Conservative and Nationalist Ideologies

• 

  She wants the destruction of the patriarchy | Women's March … | Sasha Kimel | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  19th Century Feminist Movements | Introduction to Women Gender Sexuality Studies View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Women across the world demand end to gender-based violence : Peoples Dispatch View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  She wants the destruction of the patriarchy | Women's March … | Sasha Kimel | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  19th Century Feminist Movements | Introduction to Women Gender Sexuality Studies View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Conservative and nationalist ideologies prioritize traditional gender roles and hierarchies reinforcing patriarchal power structures in society and politics
• Emphasize nuclear family unit with distinct roles for men and women limiting individual autonomy and perpetuating gender inequalities
• Employ gendered language and symbolism utilizing concepts of masculinity and femininity to reinforce political messages and national identity (e.g. "motherland", "founding fathers")
• Promote traditional values leading to marginalization of LGBTQ+ individuals and suppression of diverse gender expressions
• Invoke idealized notions of womanhood as symbols of national purity and cultural preservation (e.g. "Mother India", "Marianne" in France)
  • Potentially limits women's agency
  • Reduces women to symbolic roles
• Impact women's reproductive rights, bodily autonomy, and access to healthcare
  • Reflect broader ideological stances on gender and sexuality
  • Examples: restrictions on abortion, limited access to contraception
• Intersect with religious beliefs and cultural traditions further entrenching gendered expectations
  • Limit progress towards gender equality
  • Examples: religious views on women's roles in the home, cultural practices of arranged marriages

Conservative Politics and Gender Roles

Traditional Family Structures in Conservative Thought

• Emphasizes nuclear family as fundamental unit of society promoting heteronormative relationships
• Reinforces traditional division of labor within households
  • Mothers typically cast as primary caregivers
  • Fathers viewed as breadwinners
• Concept of "family values" reinforces gendered expectations for parenting
• Prioritizes marriage and childbearing potentially disadvantaging:
  • Single individuals
  • Same-sex couples
  • Those who choose not to have children
• Economic policies often oppose universal childcare or paid family leave
  • Makes it difficult for women to fully participate in workforce
  • Examples: lack of support for public childcare programs, opposition to mandated parental leave

Conservative Rhetoric and Gender Essentialism

• Frames challenges to traditional gender roles as threats to social stability and moral values
• Creates resistance to progressive gender policies (e.g. gender-neutral bathrooms, LGBTQ+ inclusive education)
• Emphasizes personal responsibility leading to lack of support for policies addressing structural inequalities
  • Disproportionately affects women and marginalized groups
  • Examples: opposition to affirmative action, resistance to gender pay gap legislation
• Promotes gender essentialism believing men and women have inherently different characteristics and roles
  • Justifies and perpetuates gender-based discrimination
  • Examples: arguments against women in combat roles, stereotypes about women's leadership abilities

Nationalism, Gender, and Sexuality

Gendered National Narratives

• Construct idealized versions of masculinity and femininity representing national strength, purity, and cultural authenticity
• Concept of "national reproduction" places pressure on women to bear children for the nation
  • Potentially limits reproductive autonomy
  • Examples: pro-natalist policies in countries with declining birth rates
• Portray LGBTQ+ identities as foreign or threatening to national culture
  • Leads to increased discrimination and violence against sexual minorities
  • Examples: "gay propaganda" laws, denial of LGBTQ+ rights as "Western influence"
• Employ masculine imagery and language in patriotic symbolism and rhetoric
  • Potentially marginalizes women's contributions to national identity and citizenship
  • Examples: military-focused national holidays, male-dominated national sports teams

Nationalism and Gender Roles

• Romanticize traditional gender roles as part of a "golden age" of national culture
• Resist progress in gender equality as a form of cultural preservation
• Intersection of nationalism and militarism glorifies masculine aggression and dominance
  • Casts women in supportive or symbolic roles
  • Examples: emphasis on male military service, women as "mothers of the nation"
• Restrict immigration or citizenship rights based on gendered and sexualized notions of national belonging
  • Disproportionately affects women and LGBTQ+ individuals
  • Examples: gendered citizenship laws, discrimination against same-sex partners in immigration policies

Feminist Responses to Exclusionary Politics

Feminist Critiques of Conservative and Nationalist Ideologies

• Challenge essentialist views of gender arguing for understanding of gender as socially constructed and fluid
• Employ intersectional approaches highlighting disproportionate effects on:
  • Women of color
  • Working-class women
  • Other marginalized groups
• Challenge limited definition of family advocating for recognition and rights for diverse family structures
  • Examples: single-parent families, same-sex partnerships, chosen families
• Critique use of women's bodies and sexuality in nationalist discourses
  • Expose how these narratives objectify and control women
  • Examples: analysis of "women as bearers of culture" tropes, critique of sexualized national symbols

Feminist Strategies and Alternative Perspectives

• Develop transnational feminist perspectives critiquing how nationalism reinforces borders and exclusions
• Call for solidarity across national boundaries
  • Examples: global women's marches, international campaigns for reproductive rights
• Employ queer feminist approaches challenging heteronormativity in conservative and nationalist ideologies
• Advocate for LGBTQ+ rights and recognition
  • Examples: pushing for inclusive sex education, campaigning for same-sex marriage rights
• Create strategies to resist and subvert conservative and nationalist politics including:
  • Grassroots organizing
  • Consciousness-raising
  • Creation of alternative political spaces and discourses
  • Examples: feminist book clubs, women's health collectives, online feminist communities