11.1 History of Native American Voting Rights

Native Americans faced a long struggle for voting rights, from colonial exclusion to citizenship in 1924. Even then, many states denied them the vote until mid-20th century, using tactics like literacy tests and poll taxes to disenfranchise Native populations.

The Voting Rights Act of 1965 provided crucial protections, but challenges persist. Today, Native Americans still face barriers like voter ID laws, redistricting issues, and limited polling access on reservations. The fight for full political participation continues.

Native American Voting Rights: A Historical Journey

Colonial Exclusion to Citizenship

Top images from around the web for Colonial Exclusion to Citizenship

• 

  Indians Muskogee - Oklahoma 3 June 1933 | Indians Muskogee, … | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Indian Citizenship Act – Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  530919_Shoshone_Indians_Ft_Washakie_Wyoming_Indian_Reserva… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Indians Muskogee - Oklahoma 3 June 1933 | Indians Muskogee, … | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Indian Citizenship Act – Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Colonial Exclusion to Citizenship

• 

  Indians Muskogee - Oklahoma 3 June 1933 | Indians Muskogee, … | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Indian Citizenship Act – Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  530919_Shoshone_Indians_Ft_Washakie_Wyoming_Indian_Reserva… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Indians Muskogee - Oklahoma 3 June 1933 | Indians Muskogee, … | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Indian Citizenship Act – Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Native Americans excluded from voting and citizenship rights during colonial period and early United States years
  • Considered members of separate sovereign nations
  • Denied basic political rights and representation
• Indian Citizenship Act of 1924 granted U.S. citizenship to all Native Americans born in the United States
  • Did not automatically confer voting rights
  • Created a complex legal status for Native Americans
• Many states continued to deny Native Americans voting rights until mid-20th century
  • Used various legal and extralegal means (literacy tests, poll taxes)
  • Resulted in widespread disenfranchisement of Native American populations

Civil Rights Era and Beyond

• Voting Rights Act of 1965 provided significant protections for Native American voting rights
  • Prohibited discriminatory voting practices (gerrymandering, voter intimidation)
  • Required federal oversight in certain jurisdictions with history of discrimination
• Shelby County v. Holder decision in 2013 weakened some protections of the Voting Rights Act
  • Struck down formula used to determine which jurisdictions required federal preclearance
  • Potentially impacted Native American voting rights by removing federal oversight
• Contemporary issues in Native American voting rights persist
  • Voter ID laws (requiring specific forms of identification)
  • Redistricting (diluting Native American voting power)
  • Accessibility of polling places on reservations (long distances, limited transportation)

Federal Laws and Native American Suffrage

Legislative Milestones

• Dawes Act of 1887 tied U.S. citizenship for Native Americans to land ownership and assimilation
  • Created complex and inconsistent system of citizenship rights
  • Aimed to break up tribal lands and promote individual land ownership
• Indian Reorganization Act of 1934 encouraged tribal self-government
  • Increased Native American political participation within tribal structures
  • Reversed some of the damaging effects of the Dawes Act
• Civil Rights Act of 1960 established federal inspection of local voter registration polls
  • Helped protect Native American voting rights
  • Provided mechanism for oversight and enforcement
• Native American Voting Rights Act of 2019 proposed to address contemporary challenges
  • Aims to improve voting access and representation
  • Includes provisions for language assistance and polling place accessibility

Landmark Court Decisions

• Trujillo v. Garley (1948) in New Mexico ruled against denying voting rights based on reservation residence
  • Challenged the notion that living on a reservation precluded U.S. citizenship rights
  • Set important precedent for Native American voting rights
• Oregon v. Mitchell (1970) upheld Congress's power to ban literacy tests in state and federal elections
  • Removed significant barrier to Native American voting
  • Recognized federal authority in protecting voting rights across states

Factors Influencing Native American Voting Rights

Cultural and Socioeconomic Barriers

• Concept of tribal sovereignty complicated application of U.S. citizenship and voting rights
  • Created tension between tribal governance and U.S. electoral system
  • Led to debates over dual citizenship and political allegiance
• Cultural and linguistic differences created barriers to political participation
  • Language barriers in voter education and ballot materials
  • Differing cultural concepts of governance and representation
• Economic disparities impacted voter turnout and political engagement
  • Limited access to transportation to polling places
  • Reduced resources for political organizing and campaigning

Historical and Demographic Shifts

• Racial discrimination and stereotypes influenced policies toward Native American suffrage
  • Perpetuated myths about Native Americans' capacity for self-governance
  • Led to exclusionary practices in voting and citizenship rights
• Relocation and urbanization of Native Americans in mid-20th century affected political organization
  • Changed traditional community structures and voting patterns
  • Created new challenges for political representation in urban areas
• Civil Rights Movement of the 1960s provided momentum for Native American voting rights advocacy
  • Offered strategies and alliances for political organizing
  • Raised national awareness of minority voting rights issues

Effectiveness of Legal and Advocacy Efforts

Organizational and Grassroots Initiatives

• Formation of pan-Indian organizations crucial for national-level advocacy
  • National Congress of American Indians founded in 1944
  • Provided unified voice for Native American political interests
• Grassroots organizing and voter registration drives increased political participation
  • Focused on educating communities about voting rights and processes
  • Mobilized Native American voters to increase turnout
• Collaboration between Native American groups and other civil rights organizations strengthened efforts
  • Shared resources and strategies (legal expertise, funding)
  • Created broader coalition for voting rights protection

Legal Strategies and Ongoing Challenges

• Litigation strategies effective in challenging discriminatory voting practices
  • Test cases and class action lawsuits established legal precedents
  • Addressed issues like redistricting and voter identification requirements
• Use of Section 203 of Voting Rights Act secured language assistance for Native American voters
  • Improved access to electoral process in many communities
  • Required bilingual voting materials and interpreters at polling places
• Persistent challenges demonstrate ongoing nature of voting rights struggle
  • Voter suppression tactics (closure of polling places, strict ID laws)
  • Need for continual legal vigilance to protect and expand voting rights