11.1 Panic of 1873

The Panic of 1873 was a pivotal moment in American business history, exposing weaknesses in the post-Civil War economy. Triggered by railroad overexpansion and financial speculation, it led to widespread bank failures, deflation, and a prolonged economic downturn known as the Long Depression.

This crisis reshaped American capitalism, spurring industrial consolidation and new financial regulations. It also fueled political debates on monetary policy and labor rights, setting the stage for populist movements and increased government economic intervention in the decades that followed.

Causes of the panic

• Panic of 1873 marked a significant turning point in American business history, highlighting vulnerabilities in the rapidly expanding economy
• Economic instability following the Civil War created a fragile financial environment, setting the stage for the panic
• Overreliance on speculative investments, particularly in railroads, contributed to the economic bubble that ultimately burst

Overexpansion of railroads

Top images from around the web for Overexpansion of railroads

• 

  Western Economic Expansion: Railroads and Cattle | US History II (American Yawp) View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Panic of 1873 - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Panic of 1873 - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Western Economic Expansion: Railroads and Cattle | US History II (American Yawp) View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Panic of 1873 - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Overexpansion of railroads

• 

  Western Economic Expansion: Railroads and Cattle | US History II (American Yawp) View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Panic of 1873 - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Panic of 1873 - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Western Economic Expansion: Railroads and Cattle | US History II (American Yawp) View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Panic of 1873 - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Rapid construction of railroads outpaced actual demand, leading to overcapacity
• Speculative investments in railroad bonds created a financial bubble
• Railroad companies took on excessive debt to fund expansion projects
• Land grants and government subsidies encouraged overbuilding of rail lines

Post-Civil War economic instability

• Reconstruction efforts strained government resources and created economic uncertainty
• Inflated wartime currency led to price instability and speculation
• Uneven economic recovery across different regions of the country
• Transition from wartime to peacetime economy caused disruptions in production and employment

Demonetization of silver

• Coinage Act of 1873 removed silver as legal tender, shifting to a gold standard
• Reduced money supply led to deflation and economic contraction
• Farmers and debtors faced increased financial pressure due to stronger currency
• Controversy over "Crime of '73" fueled political debates on monetary policy

European financial crisis

• Vienna Stock Exchange crash in May 1873 triggered a global financial panic
• European investors withdrew funds from American markets, causing liquidity shortages
• Interconnected global financial system spread economic instability across borders
• Decline in European demand for American exports exacerbated economic downturn

Key events and timeline

• Panic of 1873 unfolded as a series of cascading financial failures, revealing weaknesses in the American banking system
• Events of the panic highlighted the interconnectedness of financial institutions and the broader economy
• Timeline of the crisis demonstrates how quickly economic instability can spread and intensify

Jay Cooke & Company failure

• September 18, 1873: Jay Cooke & Company, a major investment bank, declares bankruptcy
• Failure triggered by overextension in railroad investments, particularly Northern Pacific Railway
• Collapse of Cooke's firm shook investor confidence and led to a chain reaction of bank failures
• Symbolized the end of the post-Civil War economic boom and speculative frenzy

New York Stock Exchange closure

• September 20, 1873: New York Stock Exchange suspends trading for 10 days
• Unprecedented closure aimed to prevent further panic selling and market collapse
• Shutdown highlighted the severity of the financial crisis and its impact on Wall Street
• Reopening on September 30 saw continued market volatility and economic uncertainty

Bank runs and failures

• Depositors rushed to withdraw funds, causing liquidity crises for many banks
• Trust companies and savings banks particularly vulnerable to runs due to long-term investments
• Suspension of cash payments by some banks further eroded public confidence
• Wave of bank failures spread from New York to other major cities across the country

Railroad bankruptcies

• 89 railroads declared bankruptcy between 1873 and 1875
• Northern Pacific Railway, a major project of Jay Cooke, suspended operations
• Bankruptcies led to widespread unemployment among railroad workers
• Collapse of railroad stocks and bonds affected investors and financial institutions nationwide

Economic impacts

• Panic of 1873 ushered in a prolonged period of economic stagnation known as the Long Depression
• Effects of the crisis reshaped American business practices and economic policies
• Panic exposed structural weaknesses in the American economy and financial system

Long-term depression

• Economic contraction lasted from 1873 to 1879, with effects felt into the 1890s
• Gross National Product declined by 5.5% between 1873 and 1874
• Slow recovery characterized by periods of growth followed by recessions
• Persistent deflationary pressures hindered economic recovery and growth

Deflation and price collapse

• General price level fell by 30% between 1873 and 1896
• Deflation increased real debt burdens for farmers and businesses
• Agricultural commodity prices plummeted, leading to rural economic distress
• Falling prices discouraged investment and consumer spending, prolonging the depression

Unemployment and wage reductions

• Unemployment rate reached 14% by 1876, highest in U.S. history up to that point
• Wage cuts across industries, with some workers experiencing 25-50% reductions
• Long-term unemployment led to social unrest and increased labor activism
• Migration of unemployed workers to urban areas exacerbated social problems

Business failures and consolidations

• Over 18,000 businesses failed between 1873 and 1875
• Wave of bankruptcies led to industrial consolidation and formation of trusts
• Surviving companies gained market share, leading to increased economic concentration
• Shift towards vertical integration and economies of scale in American industry

Political consequences

• Panic of 1873 had far-reaching effects on American politics and policy-making
• Economic crisis fueled debates over monetary policy, labor rights, and government's role in the economy
• Political landscape shifted as new movements emerged in response to economic hardships

Labor unrest and strikes

• Great Railroad Strike of 1877 marked first major nationwide labor action in U.S. history
• Increased union activity and demands for better working conditions and wages
• Violent clashes between workers and authorities in several cities
• Rise of Knights of Labor and other labor organizations in response to economic conditions

Rise of populist movements

• Farmers' alliances formed to address agricultural economic distress
• Greenback Party advocated for inflation to relieve debt burdens
• Populist Party (People's Party) emerged in 1890s, calling for monetary and economic reforms
• Increased support for silver coinage and bimetallism as solution to economic woes

Shift in monetary policy

• Debates over gold standard versus bimetallism intensified
• Bland-Allison Act of 1878 required limited silver purchases by the government
• Sherman Silver Purchase Act of 1890 increased government silver purchases
• Ongoing controversy over monetary policy culminated in William Jennings Bryan's "Cross of Gold" speech in 1896

Government economic intervention

• Increased calls for government regulation of railroads and other industries
• Interstate Commerce Act of 1887 established federal regulation of railroads
• Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890 aimed to curb monopolistic practices
• Gradual shift towards more active government role in managing economic crises

International repercussions

• Panic of 1873 demonstrated the interconnectedness of global financial markets
• Crisis had significant impacts on international trade and investment patterns
• Event influenced economic policies and development strategies in multiple countries

Global trade disruptions

• Decline in American imports and exports affected trading partners worldwide
• Reduced demand for raw materials impacted commodity-exporting countries
• Protectionist policies implemented by some nations in response to economic downturn
• Shift in global trade patterns as countries sought new markets and economic strategies

European market reactions

• Vienna Stock Exchange crash in May 1873 preceded and contributed to American panic
• British and German investors suffered losses from American railroad bond defaults
• European banks tightened credit, exacerbating global economic contraction
• Crisis led to reassessment of international investment strategies and risk management

Impact on foreign investments

• Reduced flow of European capital to American markets for several years
• Increased scrutiny of foreign investments, particularly in railroad and infrastructure projects
• Shift in investment patterns towards more established and stable industries
• Some foreign investors benefited from acquiring distressed American assets at low prices

Recovery and reforms

• Gradual economic recovery process involved various policy measures and market adjustments
• Crisis led to significant changes in banking practices and industrial organization
• Recovery period set the stage for the Gilded Age of American capitalism

Resumption Act of 1875

• Mandated return to gold standard and redemption of greenbacks for gold by 1879
• Aimed to restore confidence in U.S. currency and stabilize monetary system
• Contributed to deflationary pressures but increased international confidence in U.S. economy
• Sparked ongoing debates over monetary policy and its effects on different economic sectors

Banking system changes

• Increased emphasis on maintaining adequate reserves and liquidity
• Development of clearinghouse loan certificates to provide emergency liquidity
• Gradual consolidation of banking sector, with stronger institutions absorbing weaker ones
• Calls for banking reform eventually led to the Federal Reserve Act of 1913

Industrial consolidation trends

• Formation of trusts and holding companies to achieve economies of scale
• Vertical integration strategies adopted by major corporations (Standard Oil, Carnegie Steel)
• Increased market concentration in key industries (railroads, steel, oil)
• Emergence of modern corporate management structures and practices

Economic diversification efforts

• Expansion of manufacturing sector to reduce reliance on agriculture and raw materials
• Development of new industries (electrical equipment, chemicals) spurred by technological innovations
• Increased focus on domestic market development and import substitution
• Regional economic diversification, particularly in the American West and South

Legacy and historical significance

• Panic of 1873 left a lasting imprint on American economic and business history
• Event shaped economic policies, business practices, and public attitudes towards capitalism
• Crisis provided important lessons for understanding and managing future economic downturns

Long Depression vs Great Depression

• Similarities in causes (speculation, overexpansion) and effects (deflation, unemployment)
• Differences in government response and policy interventions
• Long Depression's global nature prefigured interconnectedness of modern economic crises
• Debate over which crisis had more severe or long-lasting economic impacts

Evolution of financial regulations

• Panic highlighted need for better oversight of banking and financial markets
• Contributed to gradual development of federal regulatory framework for economy
• Influenced later reforms such as the Federal Reserve System and Securities and Exchange Commission
• Shaped debates over government's role in preventing and managing economic crises

Lessons for future economic crises

• Importance of maintaining stable monetary policy and financial system
• Dangers of speculative bubbles and overleveraged investments
• Need for diversified economic base to withstand sector-specific shocks
• Value of international cooperation in addressing global economic challenges

Impact on American capitalism

• Accelerated trend towards industrial consolidation and corporate capitalism
• Influenced development of American school of economics and business practices
• Shaped public perceptions of free market system and its vulnerabilities
• Contributed to ongoing debates over balancing economic growth with financial stability

Key figures and institutions

• Panic of 1873 involved numerous influential individuals and organizations
• Actions and decisions of key players had significant impacts on the course of the crisis
• Understanding these figures provides insight into the economic and political dynamics of the era

Jay Cooke

• Prominent investment banker known as the "financier of the Civil War"
• Failure of his firm, Jay Cooke & Company, triggered the Panic of 1873
• Overextended investments in Northern Pacific Railway led to bankruptcy
• Career exemplified the speculative nature of post-Civil War finance and its risks

President Ulysses S. Grant

• Served as U.S. President during the Panic of 1873 and its immediate aftermath
• Administration's response to crisis criticized as inadequate by some historians
• Vetoed "inflation bill" in 1874, maintaining commitment to hard money policies
• Presidency marked by economic turmoil and corruption scandals (Credit Mobilier)

New York Stock Exchange

• Central institution in American financial markets, deeply affected by the panic
• Unprecedented 10-day closure in September 1873 highlighted severity of crisis
• Actions during and after panic influenced development of stock market regulations
• Served as barometer of economic conditions and investor sentiment throughout crisis

Major railroad companies

• Central focus of speculative investment leading up to the panic
• Companies like Northern Pacific Railway and Union Pacific faced bankruptcies or financial distress
• Railroad failures had ripple effects throughout economy, affecting workers, investors, and related industries
• Crisis led to consolidation and reorganization of American railroad industry

Theoretical perspectives

• Panic of 1873 and subsequent Long Depression sparked debates among economists and policymakers
• Event challenged existing economic theories and contributed to development of new approaches
• Understanding different theoretical perspectives helps contextualize policy responses and economic debates

Classical economics vs Keynesian views

• Classical economists emphasized market self-correction and limited government intervention
• Keynesian approach (developed later) would have advocated for more active government response
• Debate over causes of prolonged depression: supply-side factors vs demand deficiency
• Crisis influenced later development of macroeconomic theories and policy prescriptions

Monetary policy debates

• Controversy over gold standard vs bimetallism as basis for monetary system
• Quantity theory of money applied to understand deflationary pressures
• Debates over role of money supply in causing and prolonging economic downturns
• Influenced later development of monetarist school of economic thought

Business cycle theories

• Panic of 1873 contributed to understanding of boom-bust cycles in capitalist economies
• Theories of overproduction and underconsumption developed to explain economic fluctuations
• Influence on later business cycle theories (Kondratiev waves, Schumpeterian creative destruction)
• Debates over exogenous vs endogenous factors in causing economic crises

Historiographical debates

• Historians and economists continue to debate various aspects of the Panic of 1873
• Differing interpretations reflect broader debates in economic history and theory
• Ongoing research provides new insights into the causes, effects, and significance of the crisis

Causes: domestic vs international

• Debate over relative importance of domestic factors (railroad overexpansion, monetary policy) vs international factors (European financial crisis)
• Role of globalization and international capital flows in transmitting economic shocks
• Significance of Coinage Act of 1873 ("Crime of '73") in precipitating the crisis
• Influence of post-Civil War economic conditions on vulnerability to financial panic

Severity and duration controversies

• Disagreements over extent and length of economic contraction following 1873
• Debates over accuracy and reliability of 19th-century economic data
• Comparisons with other major economic crises (Panic of 1893, Great Depression)
• Regional variations in severity and duration of economic downturn

Long-term economic effects

• Debates over impact of Panic of 1873 on long-term U.S. economic growth trajectory
• Role of crisis in shaping American industrial development and corporate capitalism
• Effects on income distribution and social mobility in late 19th century America
• Influence on development of American economic institutions and policies