12.5 Behavioral Approaches to Leadership

Leadership behaviors shape organizational success. Effective leaders balance task-oriented actions with people-focused approaches. They adapt their style to meet situational demands, fostering productivity and employee satisfaction.

The Leadership Grid illustrates five leadership styles based on concern for results and people. While team management (high concern for both) is often ideal, situational factors may necessitate different approaches for optimal effectiveness.

Behavioral Approaches to Leadership

Behavioral perspectives on leadership

Top images from around the web for Behavioral perspectives on leadership

• 

  Requisite leader behavioural competencies for sustainable organisational performance View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  4 Situational Leadership Styles View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Behavioral Approach | Organizational Behavior and Human Relations View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Requisite leader behavioural competencies for sustainable organisational performance View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  4 Situational Leadership Styles View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Behavioral perspectives on leadership

• 

  Requisite leader behavioural competencies for sustainable organisational performance View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  4 Situational Leadership Styles View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Behavioral Approach | Organizational Behavior and Human Relations View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Requisite leader behavioural competencies for sustainable organisational performance View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  4 Situational Leadership Styles View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Focus on actions and behaviors of effective leaders rather than traits or characteristics
• Two key behavioral dimensions of leadership:
  • Consideration involves people-oriented behaviors showing concern for subordinates' well-being, respect, and appreciation
    • Builds rapport and trust with followers through two-way communication (active listening, empathy)
  • Initiating structure involves task-oriented behaviors defining and organizing work roles
    • Establishes clear expectations and performance standards (deadlines, quality metrics)
    • Coordinates subordinates' activities to achieve goals (assigning tasks, monitoring progress)
• Research findings on effectiveness of consideration and initiating structure have been mixed and inconclusive
  • Suggests optimal leadership behavior may depend on situational factors (organizational culture, follower characteristics)

Job-centered vs employee-centered leadership

• Job-centered leadership behaviors prioritize task accomplishment and performance outcomes
  • Provide clear direction, set goals, and monitor progress to ensure efficiency and productivity
    • May use performance metrics (KPIs, quotas) and adhere strictly to standards and procedures
  • Can lead to higher short-term performance but may lower employee satisfaction and motivation
    • Employees may feel micromanaged or unvalued beyond their immediate work output
• Employee-centered leadership behaviors prioritize subordinates' needs and well-being
  • Show concern for employees' feelings, opinions, and personal development
    • Seek input and feedback, provide coaching and growth opportunities (training, mentoring)
  • Emphasize building positive relationships, providing support, and empowering employees
    • Foster psychological safety and trust, delegate authority and decision-making
  • Can lead to higher employee satisfaction, commitment, and long-term performance
    • Employees feel valued as individuals and are intrinsically motivated to contribute their best
• Most effective leaders often exhibit a combination of job-centered and employee-centered behaviors
  • Adapt style depending on situation (crisis vs stability) and followers' needs (skill level, autonomy)

Leadership Grid analysis

• Leadership Grid by Blake and Mouton identifies five leadership styles based on concern for results (production) and concern for people
  1. Impoverished management (1,1) shows low concern for both results and people
     • Minimal effort and involvement, avoidance of responsibility, apathetic leadership
  2. Country club management (1,9) has high concern for people but low concern for results
     • Prioritizes harmony and positive relationships over performance (lax standards, generous rewards)
  3. Authority-compliance management (9,1) has high concern for results but low concern for people
     • Emphasizes task accomplishment through control and obedience (strict rules, punishment)
  4. Middle-of-the-road management (5,5) has moderate concern for both results and people
     • Seeks balance and compromise but may not excel in either dimension (mediocre outcomes)
  5. Team management (9,9) demonstrates high concern for both results and people
     • Fosters collaboration, trust, and commitment to achieve goals while meeting employees' needs
       • Involves team in decision-making, provides resources and support, recognizes achievements
• Leadership Grid suggests team management style (9,9) is most effective for long-term organizational success
  • Integrates task-oriented and people-oriented behaviors to optimize performance and employee satisfaction
  • Example: CEO who sets ambitious targets and invests heavily in employee development and engagement
• However, effectiveness of each style may depend on specific situation, goals, and characteristics of followers and organization
  • Authority-compliance may be necessary in high-risk industries (aviation, healthcare) or crises requiring decisive action
  • Country club may be appropriate for creative fields (advertising, design) where employee morale drives innovation

Leadership Behavior and Effectiveness

• Leadership behavior refers to the specific actions and conduct exhibited by leaders in their roles
  • Includes both task orientation (focus on goal achievement and productivity) and relationship orientation (focus on interpersonal connections and employee well-being)
• Leadership effectiveness is determined by how well a leader's behavior contributes to achieving organizational goals and maintaining team cohesion
  • Influenced by the leader's ability to balance task and relationship orientations based on situational demands
• Situational factors play a crucial role in determining the most appropriate leadership behavior
  • May include organizational culture, team composition, task complexity, and external pressures