12.1 Comparing and Contrasting Literary Works

Literary elements and techniques are the building blocks of great stories. They help authors create vivid worlds, complex characters, and powerful emotions. By understanding these tools, we can better appreciate the artistry behind our favorite books.

Themes, cultural approaches, and literary devices all work together to create meaningful narratives. Comparing how different authors use these elements reveals unique perspectives and storytelling styles. This analysis deepens our understanding of literature's power to reflect and shape our world.

Literary Elements

Themes across literary works

Top images from around the web for Themes across literary works

• 

  Three Terrific Coming of Age Novels for Young Adults | Paper Based Bookshop View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Thinking About Theme: Anchor Chart & Freebie - 3rd Grade Thoughts View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Good vs Evil By Vipada | CBrajkovich Ramblings View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Three Terrific Coming of Age Novels for Young Adults | Paper Based Bookshop View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Thinking About Theme: Anchor Chart & Freebie - 3rd Grade Thoughts View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Themes across literary works

• 

  Three Terrific Coming of Age Novels for Young Adults | Paper Based Bookshop View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Thinking About Theme: Anchor Chart & Freebie - 3rd Grade Thoughts View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Good vs Evil By Vipada | CBrajkovich Ramblings View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Three Terrific Coming of Age Novels for Young Adults | Paper Based Bookshop View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Thinking About Theme: Anchor Chart & Freebie - 3rd Grade Thoughts View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Identify common themes explored in various literary works
  • Love: romance, passion, and the complexities of relationships (Romeo and Juliet)
  • Loss: grief, mourning, and coping with the death of loved ones (The Fault in Our Stars)
  • Coming of age: growth, self-discovery, and the transition from childhood to adulthood (The Catcher in the Rye)
  • Good vs. evil: the struggle between righteousness and wickedness (The Lord of the Rings)
• Compare how different works explore similar themes
  • Analyze the ways in which authors approach and develop shared themes
  • Identify similarities in the portrayal of characters, settings, and conflicts related to the themes
• Contrast the unique ways each work approaches the shared themes
  • Examine the distinct perspectives, cultural contexts, and literary styles that shape the treatment of themes
  • Highlight the differences in how themes are resolved or left open-ended in various works

Cultural approaches to topics

• Consider the time period and culture in which each work was written
  • Investigate the historical, social, and political factors that influenced the authors and their works
  • Examine how cultural values, beliefs, and norms are reflected in the literary works (The Great Gatsby and the Roaring Twenties)
• Analyze how the historical and cultural context influences the author's approach to the topic or idea
  • Identify the ways in which authors challenge, critique, or reinforce prevailing cultural attitudes and practices
  • Assess the impact of cultural context on the reception and interpretation of literary works
• Identify the author's stance or message regarding the topic or idea
  • Examine the explicit and implicit messages conveyed through the characters, plot, and themes
  • Compare how different authors present similar topics or ideas based on their unique perspectives and experiences (Animal Farm and 1984 on totalitarianism)
• Identify the literary movement or genre each work belongs to
  • Classify works based on shared characteristics, styles, and themes (Romanticism, Realism, Modernism)
  • Analyze how the conventions and characteristics of the literary movement influence the author's approach to the topic or idea

Literary Techniques

Effectiveness of literary devices

• Identify examples of figurative language used in literary works
  • Metaphors: comparing two unlike things to suggest similarities ("All the world's a stage")
  • Similes: comparing two things using "like" or "as" ("My love is like a red, red rose")
  • Personification: giving human qualities to non-human objects or ideas ("The wind whispered secrets")
• Compare the use of figurative language across different works
  • Analyze how authors employ similar or contrasting figurative devices to convey meaning
  • Examine the frequency, intensity, and originality of figurative language in various works
• Analyze how figurative language enhances the meaning and emotional impact of each work
  • Assess the effectiveness of figurative devices in creating vivid imagery, evoking emotions, and conveying themes
  • Evaluate how figurative language contributes to the overall literary merit and reader engagement
• Identify symbols and their meanings in different works
  • Recognize objects, characters, or events that represent abstract ideas or concepts (The green light in The Great Gatsby representing hope and aspiration)
  • Compare the use of similar symbols across works and analyze their significance
• Evaluate the effectiveness of symbols in conveying deeper meanings and themes
  • Assess how symbols enrich the layers of meaning in literary works
  • Examine the subtlety or obviousness of symbols and their impact on reader interpretation
• Analyze the tone and mood created in each work
  • Identify the author's attitude towards the subject matter and characters (satirical, nostalgic, pessimistic)
  • Examine how the choice of words, imagery, and literary devices contributes to the emotional atmosphere (suspenseful, lighthearted, melancholic)
• Compare how different authors use language, imagery, and literary devices to create tone and mood
  • Assess the similarities and differences in the way authors establish and maintain tone and mood throughout their works
  • Evaluate the effectiveness of tone and mood in evoking emotions and engaging the reader

Strengths vs weaknesses in literature

• Develop a clear and arguable thesis statement that compares and contrasts the chosen literary works
  • Identify the main points of comparison and contrast that will be explored in the analysis
  • Ensure the thesis statement is specific, focused, and takes a stance on the relative merits of the works
• Select relevant evidence from each work to support the thesis statement
  • Choose specific examples, quotes, and passages that illustrate the points of comparison and contrast
  • Analyze the evidence to demonstrate the strengths and weaknesses of each work in relation to the thesis (The use of unreliable narrators in The Catcher in the Rye and Fight Club)
• Choose an appropriate organizational structure for the comparative analysis
  • Point-by-point: discussing one point of comparison or contrast at a time, alternating between the works
  • Text-by-text: discussing each work separately, focusing on their individual strengths and weaknesses before comparing and contrasting them
• Ensure the structure effectively conveys the main arguments and supports the thesis statement
  • Maintain a logical flow of ideas and a clear connection between the evidence and the thesis
  • Use transitional phrases and sentences to guide the reader through the analysis
• Summarize the main points of comparison and contrast in the conclusion
  • Reiterate the key similarities and differences between the literary works
  • Provide a final evaluation of the strengths and weaknesses of each work based on the analysis
• Reaffirm the thesis statement and the significance of the comparison and contrast
  • Emphasize the insights gained from comparing and contrasting the literary works
  • Discuss the broader implications of the analysis for understanding literature, culture, or the human experience