12.3 Northrop Frye's archetypal criticism

Northrop Frye's archetypal criticism revolutionized literary analysis by identifying recurring patterns and symbols across diverse works. His theory connects ancient myths to modern literature, revealing universal themes that resonate across cultures and time periods.

Frye's approach, outlined in his seminal work "Anatomy of Criticism," provides a systematic framework for understanding literature. By categorizing narratives into mythic modes and seasonal cycles, Frye offers a tool for exploring the deeper structures and meanings within literary works.

Origins of archetypal criticism

• Archetypal criticism emerged as a method of literary analysis focusing on recurring patterns and symbols in literature
• Draws connections between mythological narratives and modern literary works to reveal universal themes
• Provides a framework for understanding how stories across cultures share fundamental structures and motifs

Frye's literary background

Top images from around the web for Frye's literary background

• 

  File:William Blake 003.jpg - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Northrop Frye - Wikiquote View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Harold Innis - Wikipedia, la enciclopedia libre View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:William Blake 003.jpg - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Northrop Frye - Wikiquote View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Frye's literary background

• 

  File:William Blake 003.jpg - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Northrop Frye - Wikiquote View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Harold Innis - Wikipedia, la enciclopedia libre View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:William Blake 003.jpg - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Northrop Frye - Wikiquote View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Studied at University of Toronto under mentorship of renowned critic Harold Innis
• Developed interest in William Blake's poetry and mythological symbolism
• Published groundbreaking work "Fearful Symmetry" (1947) analyzing Blake's symbolic system
• Taught English literature at Victoria College, University of Toronto for over 40 years

Influence of Jung's archetypes

• Carl Jung's concept of collective unconscious shaped Frye's understanding of universal symbols
• Adapted Jung's psychological archetypes to literary analysis
• Expanded archetypal theory beyond individual psyche to encompass cultural and literary traditions
• Identified recurring character types (hero, trickster, wise old man) across diverse mythologies

Key concepts in Frye's theory

• Frye's theory proposes a systematic approach to understanding literature through archetypal patterns
• Emphasizes the cyclical nature of narratives and their connection to natural cycles
• Establishes a framework for categorizing literary works based on their mythic structures

Modes of fictional narratives

• Mythic mode depicts gods and supernatural beings (Greek mythology)
• Romantic mode features idealized heroes and extraordinary events (Arthurian legends)
• High mimetic mode portrays leaders and nobility (Shakespearean tragedies)
• Low mimetic mode focuses on ordinary people and realistic situations (19th-century novels)
• Ironic mode presents anti-heroes and absurdist scenarios (modernist literature)

Mythoi and seasonal cycles

• Comedy associated with spring represents rebirth and reconciliation
• Romance linked to summer symbolizes adventure and fulfillment
• Tragedy connected to autumn signifies downfall and separation
• Satire/Irony related to winter embodies disillusionment and chaos
• Each mythos corresponds to a phase in the hero's journey

Archetypal symbols and imagery

• Water symbolizes rebirth, purification, and the unconscious (baptism, flood myths)
• Tree represents knowledge, growth, and interconnectedness (Tree of Life, family trees)
• Sun signifies enlightenment, vitality, and divine power (Apollo, Ra)
• Descent into underworld symbolizes transformation and confrontation with the shadow self (Orpheus, Inanna)
• Archetypes transcend cultural boundaries and appear in various literary traditions

Anatomy of Criticism

• Frye's magnum opus published in 1957 revolutionized literary criticism
• Presents a comprehensive system for analyzing literature based on archetypal patterns
• Aims to establish literary criticism as a systematic and scientific discipline

Structure and organization

• Divided into four interconnected essays exploring different aspects of literary criticism
• Employs a polemic style challenging prevailing critical approaches
• Integrates examples from diverse literary traditions to support theoretical arguments
• Concludes with a "tentative conclusion" emphasizing the ongoing nature of critical inquiry

Four essays overview

• "Historical Criticism: Theory of Modes" examines narrative categories and their historical development
• "Ethical Criticism: Theory of Symbols" explores levels of meaning in literary works
• "Archetypal Criticism: Theory of Myths" analyzes recurring narrative patterns and symbols
• "Rhetorical Criticism: Theory of Genres" investigates the relationship between form and content in literature
• Each essay builds upon the previous, creating a comprehensive framework for literary analysis

Archetypal patterns in literature

• Frye identifies recurring narrative structures and character types across diverse literary traditions
• Argues that these patterns reflect fundamental human experiences and psychological processes
• Provides a framework for comparative analysis of literature from different cultures and time periods

Quest narrative archetype

• Central plot structure in myths, epics, and modern literature
• Protagonist embarks on a journey to obtain an object or achieve a goal
• Faces obstacles, undergoes trials, and experiences personal transformation
• Examples include Gilgamesh's search for immortality and Frodo's mission in "The Lord of the Rings"
• Quest narratives often reflect societal values and cultural ideals

Hero's journey structure

• Concept popularized by Joseph Campbell, aligns with Frye's archetypal patterns
• Consists of stages including the call to adventure, crossing the threshold, and return with elixir
• Hero undergoes separation, initiation, and return mirroring psychological growth
• Found in diverse narratives from ancient myths (Odysseus) to modern films (Luke Skywalker)
• Reflects universal human experiences of challenge, growth, and self-discovery

Recurring character types

• Wise old man/woman serves as mentor and guide (Gandalf, Dumbledore)
• Trickster figure introduces chaos and transformation (Loki, Coyote)
• Shadow represents the protagonist's dark side or internal conflict (Mr. Hyde, Gollum)
• Shapeshifter embodies change and uncertainty (Circe, werewolves)
• These character archetypes appear across cultures with variations in specific attributes

Frye's theory of myths

• Frye categorizes literary narratives into four mythoi corresponding to seasonal cycles
• Each mythos represents a distinct worldview and narrative structure
• Argues that all literature can be understood as variations or combinations of these basic mythic patterns

Comedy vs tragedy

• Comedy moves from confusion to harmony, often ending in marriage or reconciliation
• Involves overcoming obstacles, mistaken identities, and social integration
• Tragedy portrays the fall of a protagonist, often due to hubris or fate
• Explores themes of isolation, sacrifice, and the limitations of human agency
• Both forms reflect different aspects of the human experience and social order

Romance vs irony

• Romance narratives focus on idealized worlds, quests, and wish-fulfillment
• Often features supernatural elements, chivalric ideals, and the triumph of good over evil
• Irony presents a skeptical or cynical view of human nature and society
• Subverts expectations, exposes hypocrisy, and challenges conventional narratives
• These contrasting mythoi reflect different cultural attitudes and literary traditions

Mythic displacement

• Process by which mythic elements are adapted and transformed in literature
• Undisplaced myth appears in its original form (creation myths, religious texts)
• Romantic displacement adapts mythic elements to human scale (fairy tales, legends)
• Realistic displacement integrates mythic patterns into everyday settings (modern novels)
• Ironic displacement subverts or parodies traditional mythic structures (postmodern literature)
• Allows for the evolution and reinterpretation of archetypal patterns across literary history

Criticism of Frye's approach

• Frye's theory faced various challenges and critiques from other literary scholars
• Debates centered on the universality of archetypes and the rigidity of Frye's system
• Criticisms reflect broader shifts in literary theory and cultural studies

Universalism vs cultural specificity

• Critics argue Frye's theory overlooks cultural differences in favor of universal patterns
• Postcolonial scholars emphasize the importance of local contexts and traditions
• Debate over whether archetypes truly transcend cultural boundaries or reflect Western bias
• Questions arise about the applicability of Frye's system to non-Western literatures
• Tension between recognizing common human experiences and respecting cultural diversity

Structural rigidity concerns

• Some scholars find Frye's categorization system too rigid and prescriptive
• Argue that it may oversimplify complex literary works to fit predetermined patterns
• Concerns about forcing diverse texts into a limited number of archetypal categories
• Questions whether Frye's approach can adequately address experimental or avant-garde literature
• Debate over the balance between systematic analysis and interpretive flexibility

Post-structuralist challenges

• Deconstructionist critics challenge the idea of fixed meanings and stable archetypes
• Emphasize the instability of language and the multiplicity of interpretations
• Question the validity of grand narratives and universal structures in literature
• Argue for more fluid and context-dependent approaches to literary analysis
• Reflect broader shifts in literary theory towards reader-response and cultural studies

Impact on literary studies

• Frye's work significantly influenced the field of literary criticism and analysis
• Provided a systematic framework for understanding literature across cultures and time periods
• Continues to be debated and adapted in contemporary literary scholarship

Influence on genre theory

• Frye's categorization of literary modes contributed to the development of genre studies
• Helped establish connections between ancient myths and modern literary forms
• Influenced scholars in defining and analyzing genre conventions (fantasy, science fiction)
• Provided a framework for understanding how genres evolve and interact over time
• Sparked debates about the boundaries and definitions of literary genres

Applications in comparative literature

• Frye's archetypal approach facilitated cross-cultural literary comparisons
• Enabled scholars to identify common themes and structures across diverse traditions
• Influenced the development of world literature as a field of study
• Provided tools for analyzing how different cultures adapt and transform universal motifs
• Contributed to understanding cultural exchange and literary influence across borders

Legacy in myth criticism

• Frye's work revitalized the study of mythology in literary analysis
• Influenced subsequent scholars in exploring the relationship between myth and literature
• Contributed to the development of mythopoeic criticism in fantasy literature studies
• Sparked ongoing debates about the role of myth in contemporary culture and media
• Continues to inform approaches to analyzing mythic elements in modern narratives

Frye's archetypal categories

• Frye developed a system of archetypal categories to classify imagery and symbols in literature
• These categories provide a framework for understanding the symbolic language of literature
• Reflect different levels of human experience and perception of reality

Apocalyptic imagery

• Represents ideal or desirable states of existence
• Associated with paradise, heaven, and utopian visions
• Includes symbols of light, order, and harmony (celestial city, garden of Eden)
• Often appears in religious texts, romantic poetry, and idealistic literature
• Contrasts with demonic imagery to create symbolic tension in narratives

Demonic imagery

• Depicts undesirable or nightmarish states of existence
• Associated with hell, chaos, and dystopian scenarios
• Includes symbols of darkness, disorder, and destruction (wasteland, inferno)
• Appears in horror literature, dystopian fiction, and works exploring human suffering
• Serves as a counterpoint to apocalyptic imagery in literary symbolism

Analogical imagery

• Represents the human world and everyday experience
• Bridges the gap between apocalyptic and demonic imagery
• Includes symbols of nature, society, and human artifacts (cities, forests, machines)
• Appears in realistic fiction, social commentary, and works exploring human relationships
• Allows for the exploration of how ideal and demonic elements manifest in ordinary life

Practical applications

• Frye's archetypal criticism provides tools for analyzing and interpreting literary works
• Offers methods for uncovering deeper meanings and connections in texts
• Facilitates comparative analysis across different literary traditions and cultures

Textual analysis techniques

• Identify recurring symbols and motifs within a text (water, journey, transformation)
• Analyze narrative structure in relation to archetypal patterns (quest, initiation, return)
• Examine character roles and their alignment with archetypal figures (hero, mentor, trickster)
• Explore the use of mythic allusions and their significance in the work
• Consider how the text relates to broader literary traditions and mythic cycles

Interpretation of symbols

• Recognize universal symbols and their potential meanings (tree of life, sacred mountain)
• Analyze how symbols function within the specific context of the work
• Consider cultural and historical factors influencing symbolic interpretations
• Examine how authors adapt or subvert traditional symbolic meanings
• Explore the interplay between personal, cultural, and universal symbolism in literature

Cross-cultural comparisons

• Identify common themes and motifs across different cultural traditions
• Analyze how similar archetypal patterns manifest in diverse literary contexts
• Explore the adaptation and transformation of myths across cultures
• Compare the treatment of universal themes (love, death, rebirth) in various literatures
• Examine how cultural differences influence the expression of archetypal elements

Contemporary relevance

• Frye's archetypal criticism continues to influence literary and cultural studies
• Adapted and reinterpreted in light of new theoretical approaches and cultural contexts
• Provides tools for analyzing modern media and diverse forms of storytelling

Archetypal criticism in modern media

• Application of Frye's concepts to film analysis and television studies
• Exploration of archetypal patterns in video game narratives and interactive storytelling
• Analysis of recurring themes and character types in graphic novels and comics
• Examination of how social media and digital platforms create new mythic structures
• Investigation of archetypal elements in transmedia storytelling and franchise narratives

Adaptations for diverse literatures

• Application of archetypal criticism to postcolonial and world literatures
• Exploration of how marginalized voices reinterpret and subvert traditional archetypes
• Analysis of hybrid mythologies in multicultural and diasporic literatures
• Examination of gender and queer perspectives on archetypal patterns
• Investigation of how digital literature and hypertext narratives engage with archetypal structures

Frye's theory vs postmodern approaches

• Debates over the relevance of universal structures in fragmented postmodern narratives
• Exploration of how postmodern literature plays with and subverts archetypal patterns
• Analysis of the tension between grand narratives and local, situated knowledge
• Examination of how digital culture and globalization impact archetypal criticism
• Investigation of potential synthesis between archetypal theory and postmodern approaches