14.1 Exterior penalty methods

Exterior penalty methods transform constrained optimization problems into unconstrained ones by adding penalty terms to the objective function. These methods start with infeasible solutions and gradually move towards feasibility, making them useful for problems with complex constraints or when finding initial feasible points is challenging.

The key components include penalty terms for constraint violations, a penalty parameter controlling their importance, and an unconstrained formulation. As the penalty parameter increases, solutions converge to the original constrained problem's solution. Careful selection of penalty functions and update strategies is crucial for method performance.

Exterior Penalty Methods for Optimization

Concept and Purpose

Top images from around the web for Concept and Purpose

• 

  A Smoothing Penalty Function Method for the Constrained Optimization Problem View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  A Smoothing Penalty Function Method for the Constrained Optimization Problem View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  A Smoothing Penalty Function Method for the Constrained Optimization Problem View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  A Smoothing Penalty Function Method for the Constrained Optimization Problem View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 2

Top images from around the web for Concept and Purpose

• 

  A Smoothing Penalty Function Method for the Constrained Optimization Problem View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  A Smoothing Penalty Function Method for the Constrained Optimization Problem View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  A Smoothing Penalty Function Method for the Constrained Optimization Problem View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  A Smoothing Penalty Function Method for the Constrained Optimization Problem View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 2

• Transform constrained optimization problems into unconstrained problems by adding penalty terms to the objective function
• Discourage solutions violating constraints by imposing increasingly severe penalties as constraint violation increases
• Start with an infeasible solution and gradually move towards feasibility during optimization
• Utilize continuous and differentiable penalty functions allowing use of standard unconstrained optimization algorithms
• Prove particularly useful for problems with complex constraint structures (nonlinear constraints)
• Allow comprehensive exploration of potential solutions by balancing search space exploration and constraint satisfaction
• Enable solving problems where finding an initial feasible point presents challenges (highly constrained problems)

Key Components and Formulation

• Add penalty terms to objective function for each constraint violation
• Construct penalty function combining original objective function and sum of penalty terms
• Use quadratic functions of constraint violations as penalty terms ensuring continuous differentiability
• Introduce penalty parameter (μ or ρ) controlling relative importance of penalty terms
• Formulate unconstrained problem as $\min f(x) + \mu * P(x)$
  • f(x) represents original objective function
  • μ denotes penalty parameter
  • P(x) signifies sum of penalty terms
• Increase penalty parameter progressively causing solutions to converge to original constrained problem solution
• Select penalty function and parameter update strategy carefully to influence method performance (quadratic penalty, adaptive penalty parameter)

Penalty Terms in Optimization

Types and Characteristics

• Employ quadratic penalty terms for inequality constraints $P_i(x) = \max(0, g_i(x))^2$
• Utilize squared penalty terms for equality constraints $P_j(x) = h_j(x)^2$
• Ensure penalty terms remain continuously differentiable to maintain smoothness
• Design penalty terms to increase rapidly as constraints become violated (steep gradients near constraint boundaries)
• Incorporate problem-specific knowledge into penalty term design (logarithmic barriers for positivity constraints)
• Balance penalty term magnitude with original objective function to prevent domination
• Consider alternative penalty functions for specific problem types (absolute value penalty, exponential penalty)

Penalty Parameter Strategies

• Start with relatively small initial penalty parameter value to explore search space
• Increase penalty parameter systematically between optimization iterations (multiply by constant factor)
• Implement adaptive penalty parameter update strategies based on constraint violation progress
• Consider problem-specific penalty parameter update schemes (faster increase for equality constraints)
• Balance penalty parameter growth rate with optimization algorithm stability
• Monitor penalty parameter values to detect potential numerical issues (very large values)
• Experiment with different update strategies to find optimal performance for specific problem classes

Convergence of Exterior Penalty Methods

Asymptotic Convergence Properties

• Exhibit asymptotic convergence approaching optimal solution as penalty parameter approaches infinity
• Experience slower convergence rate compared to interior point methods, especially near constraint boundaries
• Encounter potential ill-conditioning of Hessian matrix as penalty parameter increases leading to numerical instability
• Face challenges with equality constraints requiring infinite penalty for exact satisfaction
• Demonstrate sensitivity to initial penalty parameter choice and update strategy
• Produce sequence of infeasible solutions potentially problematic for applications requiring feasible intermediates
• Experience trade-off between constraint satisfaction and objective function minimization causing slow final convergence

Convergence Analysis and Improvements

• Analyze convergence rate theoretically using KKT conditions and penalty function properties
• Implement adaptive penalty parameter update schemes to improve convergence speed (based on constraint violation)
• Utilize hybrid approaches combining exterior penalty methods with other techniques (augmented Lagrangian methods)
• Employ preconditioning techniques to address ill-conditioning issues in later iterations
• Implement constraint relaxation strategies to handle equality constraints more effectively
• Develop problem-specific convergence criteria balancing constraint satisfaction and objective improvement
• Explore advanced penalty function designs to enhance convergence properties (non-quadratic penalties)

Applying Exterior Penalty Methods

Implementation Steps

• Select appropriate penalty function based on problem characteristics (quadratic for general constraints)
• Choose initial penalty parameter value considering problem scale and constraint types
• Implement unconstrained optimization algorithm (gradient descent, Newton's method, BFGS)
• Develop systematic penalty parameter increase strategy (multiplicative factor, adaptive scheme)
• Define stopping criteria (constraint violation tolerance, objective function change, iteration limit)
• Analyze solution sensitivity to penalty parameter choices ensuring method robustness
• Apply method to diverse constrained optimization problems (inequality, equality, mixed constraints)

Practical Considerations and Enhancements

• Implement constraint scaling to balance different constraint types and magnitudes
• Utilize warm-starting techniques leveraging previous iteration solutions to speed up convergence
• Incorporate problem-specific knowledge into penalty function design (logarithmic barriers for positivity)
• Develop hybrid approaches combining exterior penalty methods with other techniques (sequential quadratic programming)
• Implement parallel computing strategies for large-scale problems (distributed penalty evaluation)
• Employ advanced numerical techniques to address ill-conditioning issues (regularization, preconditioning)
• Evaluate solution quality through constraint satisfaction checks and comparison to known bounds or solutions