14.3 Governance in the Developing World

Governance in developing nations faces unique challenges due to colonial legacies, weak institutions, and limited resources. These countries grapple with balancing central authority and local autonomy while navigating external pressures from international actors and aid agencies.

International aid significantly influences governance, attaching conditions that can promote reforms but may infringe on sovereignty. Meanwhile, ethnic and religious diversity impacts stability, requiring careful management to prevent conflict and foster inclusive political institutions that support development.

Challenges of State-Building

Legacies and Limitations

Top images from around the web for Legacies and Limitations

• 

  History of colonialism - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Colonialism.jpg - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Colonialism - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  History of colonialism - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Colonialism.jpg - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Legacies and Limitations

• 

  History of colonialism - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Colonialism.jpg - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Colonialism - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  History of colonialism - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Colonialism.jpg - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Developing countries often face challenges in establishing effective state institutions and governance structures due to legacies of colonialism (British rule in India), weak economic foundations, and limited resources
• Weak state capacity can lead to issues such as corruption, lack of rule of law, and inability to provide basic services (healthcare, education), which undermine governance and development efforts

Balancing Authority and Autonomy

• Developing countries may struggle with balancing the need for centralized authority to maintain stability and the desire for decentralization and local autonomy
• The presence of informal institutions, such as traditional leadership structures (village councils) or patronage networks, can complicate efforts to establish formal governance systems
• Developing countries often face external pressures and interventions from international actors (United Nations), which can impact their ability to pursue independent state-building and governance strategies

International Aid's Influence

Conditions and Consequences

• International aid and development agencies, such as the World Bank, International Monetary Fund (IMF), and United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), play a significant role in providing financial assistance, technical expertise, and policy guidance to developing countries
• These agencies often attach conditions to their aid, such as requirements for economic reforms (trade liberalization), good governance practices, or adherence to human rights standards, which can influence political decision-making in recipient countries
• Aid conditionality can be used as a tool to promote political and economic liberalization, but it can also be seen as an infringement on national sovereignty and a form of external interference

Effectiveness and Ownership

• The effectiveness of aid in promoting development and political stability is debated, with some arguing that it can create dependency, distort local markets (agricultural subsidies), and undermine local ownership of development processes
• Aid allocation decisions can be influenced by the strategic interests of donor countries, leading to uneven distribution of resources and potential neglect of countries with less geopolitical significance
• Development agencies increasingly emphasize the importance of local ownership, participatory approaches (community-driven development), and alignment with national development strategies to enhance the effectiveness and sustainability of aid interventions
• The rise of new donors, such as China and other emerging economies, is changing the landscape of international aid and creating new dynamics in the relationship between aid providers and recipients

Diversity's Impact on Stability

Identity-Based Politics

• Many developing countries are characterized by high levels of ethnic and religious diversity, which can have both positive and negative implications for political stability
• Ethnic and religious identities often form the basis for political mobilization and competition, leading to the formation of identity-based political parties (ethnic parties in Nigeria) and movements
• In some cases, ethnic and religious diversity can lead to conflict and instability, particularly when there are perceptions of inequality, discrimination, or marginalization among certain groups (Hutu and Tutsi in Rwanda)

Managing Diversity

• The management of ethnic and religious diversity through inclusive political institutions, power-sharing arrangements (consociationalism in Lebanon), and minority rights protections can help to mitigate conflict and promote stability
• Conversely, the politicization of ethnic and religious identities and the use of divisive rhetoric can exacerbate tensions and undermine social cohesion
• The presence of ethnic or religious-based armed groups or militias (Hezbollah in Lebanon) can pose challenges to state authority and contribute to cycles of violence and instability
• Developing countries with a history of ethnic or religious conflict may face difficulties in building trust and reconciliation among different communities, which can hinder efforts to promote political stability and development

Political Systems for Development

Institutional Design and Context

• Developing countries have experimented with a range of political systems, including presidential and parliamentary systems, federal and unitary structures, and various forms of authoritarianism and democracy
• The effectiveness of different political systems in addressing development challenges depends on factors such as institutional design, leadership, and the specific socio-economic and cultural context of each country
• Parliamentary systems are often seen as more conducive to coalition-building and compromise, which can be important in managing ethnic and religious diversity and promoting political stability
• Presidential systems can provide strong executive leadership and decision-making, but they may also be more prone to personalization of power (strongman rule) and conflict between branches of government

Governance Quality and Adaptability

• Federal systems can allow for greater regional autonomy and representation of diverse interests, but they may also create challenges in terms of coordination and resource distribution between national and sub-national levels (resource-rich regions in Nigeria)
• Democratic systems, while not a panacea, are generally seen as more effective in promoting accountability, transparency, and responsiveness to citizen needs, which can support development outcomes
• Authoritarian systems may be able to achieve rapid economic growth and maintain stability in the short term (China's economic reforms), but they often face challenges in terms of long-term sustainability, legitimacy, and human rights
• The effectiveness of any political system in addressing development challenges ultimately depends on the quality of governance, the strength of institutions, and the ability to adapt to changing circumstances and demands