14.4 The Role of States in Addressing National and Global Issues

States are taking on bigger roles in national and global issues like climate change and immigration. They're implementing renewable energy standards, joining regional climate initiatives, and creating state-level immigration policies. This shift is reshaping how states and the federal government interact.

State initiatives serve as policy laboratories, testing innovative solutions that can spread to other states or inspire federal action. However, they face limitations in addressing complex challenges due to resource constraints and coordination difficulties among states with diverse interests and needs.

The Growing Role of States in National and Global Issues

States and global challenges

Top images from around the web for States and global challenges

• 

  The cost of climate (in)action | Pursuit by The University of Melbourne View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Carbon risk disclosure: The risk for Australian companies | Pursuit by The University of Melbourne View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Carbon tax v cap-and-trade: which is better? | Environment | The Guardian View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The cost of climate (in)action | Pursuit by The University of Melbourne View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Carbon risk disclosure: The risk for Australian companies | Pursuit by The University of Melbourne View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for States and global challenges

• 

  The cost of climate (in)action | Pursuit by The University of Melbourne View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Carbon risk disclosure: The risk for Australian companies | Pursuit by The University of Melbourne View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Carbon tax v cap-and-trade: which is better? | Environment | The Guardian View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The cost of climate (in)action | Pursuit by The University of Melbourne View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Carbon risk disclosure: The risk for Australian companies | Pursuit by The University of Melbourne View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• States increasingly take action on issues transcending state boundaries with national or global implications
  • Climate change
    • Implement renewable energy standards requiring a certain percentage of energy to come from renewable sources (solar, wind)
    • Establish cap-and-trade programs setting limits on greenhouse gas emissions and allowing companies to trade emission allowances
    • Join regional climate initiatives to coordinate efforts and share resources (Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative)
  • Immigration
    • Enact state-level immigration policies addressing issues such as employment verification, law enforcement cooperation, and access to public benefits
    • Cooperate with or resist federal immigration enforcement efforts, such as participating in or opting out of programs like Secure Communities
    • Provide services and benefits to immigrant communities, including education, healthcare, and legal assistance

Effectiveness of state initiatives

• State-level initiatives serve as laboratories of democracy, testing innovative solutions to complex problems
  • Successful state policies can be adopted by other states or the federal government, spreading effective solutions (Massachusetts health care reform inspiring the Affordable Care Act)
  • State initiatives may be more responsive to local needs and preferences, tailoring policies to the unique circumstances of each state
• State-level initiatives face limitations in addressing complex, cross-jurisdictional challenges
  • Lack of uniformity across states creates challenges for businesses and individuals operating in multiple jurisdictions
  • Resource constraints limit the scope and impact of state actions, as states have smaller budgets and less capacity than the federal government
  • Coordination and collaboration among states can be difficult to achieve due to political, economic, and cultural differences

State Collaboration and the Future of American Federalism

State collaboration for policy

• Interstate compacts and agreements facilitate cooperation on regional issues
  • Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative: Cap-and-trade program among northeastern states to reduce greenhouse gas emissions
  • Great Lakes Compact: Agreement among eight states and two Canadian provinces to manage and protect the Great Lakes basin
• National associations of state officials promote information sharing and best practices
  • National Governors Association fosters cooperation and advocates for state interests at the federal level
  • National Conference of State Legislatures supports state lawmakers and staff through research, training, and networking opportunities
• State collaboration faces challenges
  • Political and ideological differences among states hinder consensus-building and joint action
  • Competition for resources and economic development incentivizes states to pursue individual interests rather than collective goals
  • Concerns about state sovereignty and autonomy make some states reluctant to cede power to interstate or national organizations

Implications for American federalism

• Increased state activism may lead to a rebalancing of power between the federal government and the states
  • States may assert greater autonomy and resist federal intervention in areas traditionally reserved for state control (education, land use)
  • The federal government may seek to preempt or constrain state actions that conflict with national priorities or constitutional principles
• State involvement in national and global issues reshapes traditional understandings of federalism
  • Blurring of lines between state and federal responsibilities creates a more complex and interdependent system of governance
  • Emergence of new forms of cooperative or coercive federalism, where states and the federal government collaborate or compete in policymaking and implementation
• Increased tension and conflict between states and the federal government
  • Disputes over the appropriate roles and powers of each level of government, such as debates over immigration enforcement and environmental regulation
  • Legal challenges to state actions on constitutional grounds, such as claims of federal preemption or violations of individual rights