18.1 Legal frameworks and international conventions

Legal frameworks shape how archaeologists protect and manage cultural heritage in the Holy Land. International conventions like UNESCO's World Heritage Convention provide guidelines for preserving sites of universal value, while national laws regulate excavations and artifact handling.

Challenges arise from the region's complex political landscape and divided jurisdiction over archaeological resources. Ethical considerations, including repatriation of artifacts and combating looting, are crucial in safeguarding the Holy Land's rich cultural heritage for future generations.

International Conventions and Organizations

UNESCO World Heritage Convention

Top images from around the web for UNESCO World Heritage Convention

• 

  World Heritage List - RASHID International View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  AWOL - The Ancient World Online: Petra, the Rose-Red City: Google Sreetview Tour View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Travellers' Guide To UNESCO World Heritage List - Wiki Travel Guide - Travellerspoint View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  World Heritage List - RASHID International View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  AWOL - The Ancient World Online: Petra, the Rose-Red City: Google Sreetview Tour View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for UNESCO World Heritage Convention

• 

  World Heritage List - RASHID International View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  AWOL - The Ancient World Online: Petra, the Rose-Red City: Google Sreetview Tour View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Travellers' Guide To UNESCO World Heritage List - Wiki Travel Guide - Travellerspoint View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  World Heritage List - RASHID International View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  AWOL - The Ancient World Online: Petra, the Rose-Red City: Google Sreetview Tour View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• International treaty adopted in 1972 to protect natural and cultural heritage sites of outstanding universal value
• Establishes the World Heritage List of sites considered to have exceptional significance to humanity
• Provides a framework for international cooperation in the conservation and protection of these sites
• State parties commit to identifying, protecting, conserving, and transmitting cultural and natural heritage to future generations
• Currently includes over 1,100 properties in 167 countries (Petra in Jordan, Old City of Jerusalem)

International Councils and Conventions for Cultural Heritage

• Hague Convention for the Protection of Cultural Property in the Event of Armed Conflict (1954) was the first international treaty focused on protecting cultural heritage during wartime
• ICOMOS (International Council on Monuments and Sites) is a non-governmental professional organization that promotes the conservation, protection, and enhancement of monuments and sites
• Serves as an advisory body to the World Heritage Committee in evaluating nominations to the World Heritage List
• Develops charters, principles and guidelines on conservation practices (Venice Charter, Nara Document on Authenticity)
• International Council of Museums (ICOM) is a membership association and non-governmental organization representing museums and museum professionals
• Establishes international standards and code of ethics for museums, covering issues like acquisition policies, public trust, and professional conduct

National Legislation and Authorities

Antiquities Law and Authorities in Israel/Palestine

• Israel's Antiquities Law (1978) is the main legislation governing archaeological heritage, replacing the British Mandate Antiquities Ordinance of 1929
• Defines antiquities, regulates excavation and conservation, and prohibits unauthorized removal of artifacts
• Israel Antiquities Authority (IAA) is the government agency responsible for enforcing the Antiquities Law, overseeing archaeological excavations, conservation and site management
• Palestinian Department of Antiquities and Cultural Heritage is the equivalent authority in areas under Palestinian control
• Responsible for protection and management of cultural heritage sites, museums, and archaeological stores in the West Bank and Gaza
• Challenges arise from the political complexities and divided jurisdiction over the region's rich archaeological heritage

Cultural Heritage Protection

Key Concepts in Safeguarding Cultural Heritage

• Cultural property refers to movable objects like artifacts, works of art, manuscripts, and archives that are considered part of a culture's heritage
• Cultural heritage encompasses both tangible assets (monuments, archaeological sites, cultural landscapes) and intangible attributes (oral traditions, performing arts, rituals) inherited from the past
• Cultural heritage management involves the processes of identification, interpretation, maintenance, and preservation of significant cultural sites and objects
• Aims to ensure cultural continuity between past, present and future through conservation, documentation, and sustainable use of heritage assets
• Archaeological ethics are the moral principles that guide the professional conduct of archaeologists in their roles as stewards of the archaeological record
• Key principles include stewardship, accountability, public outreach, intellectual property, public reporting and publication, records and preservation

Preservation and Conservation Practices

• Preservation refers to protecting cultural property from deterioration or damage and maintaining it in its original state as much as possible
• Involves controlling the environment (temperature, humidity, light), proper handling, storage, and security of artifacts and collections
• Conservation includes the physical intervention to ensure the stability and integrity of cultural objects
• Covers techniques like cleaning, repair, consolidation, and restoration, guided by respect for the aesthetic, historic and physical integrity of the object
• Digital preservation uses technology to protect and ensure ongoing access to digital materials (3D models, photographs, databases) over time

Threats to Cultural Heritage

Contested Ownership and Repatriation Issues

• Repatriation refers to the return of cultural objects to their country or community of origin, often in cases where the objects were removed during colonial rule, looting, or illicit trafficking
• Raises complex legal and ethical questions about the rightful ownership of artifacts, the circumstances of acquisition, and the responsibilities of museums
• Examples include the Elgin Marbles dispute between Greece and the British Museum, and the return of stolen artifacts to Iraq in the aftermath of the 2003 war

Looting and Illicit Trafficking of Antiquities

• Looting is the illegal removal of artifacts from archaeological sites, monuments, or cultural repositories like museums and libraries
• Often motivated by the lucrative international market for antiquities, with objects sold to private collectors or institutions
• Illicit trafficking networks facilitate the smuggling and sale of looted antiquities across borders, often with links to organized crime and terrorism financing
• The unprovenanced nature of looted artifacts erases their cultural context and scientific value, compromising the integrity of archaeological heritage
• High-profile cases include the looting of the Baghdad Museum during the Iraq War in 2003, and ongoing looting at sites in Syria and Iraq during conflicts