2.3 Comparing the Virtue Ethics of East and West

Virtue ethics, rooted in ancient Greek and Eastern philosophies, focuses on cultivating moral character and virtues to guide ethical behavior. It emphasizes traits like courage, justice, and wisdom in the West, while Eastern traditions prioritize relationships, social harmony, and collective good.

In business, virtue ethics shapes practices differently across cultures. East Asian businesses prioritize long-term relationships and group harmony, while Western approaches emphasize individual responsibility and fairness. Developing a global ethical framework faces challenges due to cultural differences but offers opportunities for finding common ground.

Core Principles and Cultural Influence of Virtue Ethics

Core principles of virtue ethics

Top images from around the web for Core principles of virtue ethics

• 

  Core Values and Ethics | via www.slideshare.net/discursives/… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Comparing the Virtue Ethics of East and West – Business Ethics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Glossary of ethical principles, terms and values (L. Hammo… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Core Values and Ethics | via www.slideshare.net/discursives/… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Comparing the Virtue Ethics of East and West – Business Ethics View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Core principles of virtue ethics

• 

  Core Values and Ethics | via www.slideshare.net/discursives/… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Comparing the Virtue Ethics of East and West – Business Ethics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Glossary of ethical principles, terms and values (L. Hammo… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Core Values and Ethics | via www.slideshare.net/discursives/… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Comparing the Virtue Ethics of East and West – Business Ethics View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Western virtue ethics
  • Originated with ancient Greek philosophers (Aristotle, Plato)
  • Focuses on individual character traits and moral virtues such as courage, temperance, justice, and practical wisdom
  • Emphasizes the cultivation of good habits and practical reason to guide moral behavior
  • Aims to develop individuals who consistently make ethical choices based on their virtuous character
• Eastern virtue ethics
  • Rooted in philosophical traditions (Confucianism, Buddhism, Taoism)
  • Emphasizes the importance of relationships, social roles, and harmony within society
  • Key virtues include filial piety, loyalty, benevolence, and righteousness
  • Stresses the cultivation of moral character through self-reflection and adherence to social norms and expectations
  • Prioritizes the collective good and the fulfillment of one's duties within social hierarchies
• Similarities between Eastern and Western virtue ethics
  • Both emphasize the importance of moral character development as the foundation for ethical behavior
  • Both view virtues as essential for living a good life and contributing positively to society
  • Both recognize the role of practical wisdom in guiding moral decision-making in complex situations
  • Both aim to cultivate individuals who embody and exemplify moral virtues in their actions and relationships
  • Both traditions value moral exemplars as sources of inspiration and guidance for ethical conduct

Cultural impact on business practices

• Influence of Confucian virtue ethics in East Asian business practices
  • Emphasis on building long-term relationships and trust (guanxi) rather than short-term transactions
  • Prioritization of collective interests and group harmony over individual gains or personal achievement
  • Respect for hierarchy and authority in business organizations, with deference to senior leaders and managers
  • Expectation of loyalty and reciprocity in business dealings, with a focus on mutual obligations and benefits
  • Importance of face-saving and avoiding direct confrontation or criticism in business communications
  • Strong emphasis on social harmony as a guiding principle for business interactions and decision-making
• Impact of Aristotelian virtue ethics on Western business practices
  • Focus on individual responsibility and accountability for ethical conduct in business settings
  • Emphasis on fairness, honesty, and integrity in business transactions and relationships
  • Encouragement of philanthropy and corporate social responsibility as expressions of virtuous character
  • Promotion of professional excellence and continuous improvement as means of developing practical wisdom
  • Valuing of autonomy and individual judgment in making ethical decisions within business contexts

Global Framework for Business Ethics

Evaluate the potential for developing a globally applicable framework for business ethics

• Challenges in developing a universal framework
  • Cultural differences in moral values, priorities, and conceptions of the good life across societies
  • Varying legal and institutional contexts across countries, with different regulations and enforcement mechanisms
  • Potential for cultural imperialism or imposing Western values and norms on other societies without sufficient adaptation
  • Difficulty in reaching consensus on specific virtues and their application in diverse business and cultural settings
  • Risk of moral relativism when attempting to accommodate diverse ethical perspectives
• Opportunities for finding common ground
  • Shared human values such as respect for human dignity, fairness, honesty, and concern for others' wellbeing
  • Growing global interconnectedness and the need for cross-cultural cooperation to address shared challenges (climate change)
  • Potential for dialogue and mutual learning between different ethical traditions to enrich moral understanding
  • Emergence of international initiatives and standards to promote responsible business conduct (UN Global Compact, ISO 26000)
• Considerations for a globally applicable framework
  • Focus on broad principles rather than specific rules or virtues to allow for cultural variation and interpretation
  • Allowance for local adaptation and contextualization based on cultural norms, values, and institutional realities
  • Emphasis on shared responsibility and stakeholder engagement in developing and implementing ethical standards
  • Continuous refinement through ongoing dialogue, collaboration, and learning across cultures and regions
  • Recognition of the dynamic nature of global business ethics and the need for flexibility and responsiveness over time

Alternative Ethical Frameworks

• Utilitarianism: Focuses on maximizing overall well-being or happiness for the greatest number of people
• Deontology: Emphasizes adherence to moral rules or duties, regardless of consequences
• Virtue ethics: Concentrates on developing moral character and virtues as the basis for ethical behavior
• Ethical pluralism: Recognizes the validity of multiple ethical frameworks and encourages their integration in decision-making
• Virtue cultivation: Emphasizes the importance of developing and nurturing moral virtues through practice and reflection