2.5 Personality and Organization: A Basic Conflict?

Personality and organizational structure often clash, creating tension between individual expression and workplace norms. Employees may feel stifled by rigid hierarchies, leading to frustration and reduced motivation. This conflict highlights the importance of finding a balance between personal authenticity and organizational expectations.

To cope, workers use strategies like compartmentalizing work and personal life, seeking compatible roles, or negotiating for more autonomy. Personality tests in hiring can help match candidates to jobs, but have limitations. Understanding these dynamics is key to fostering a positive work environment and maximizing employee potential.

Personality and Organizational Structure

Personality vs organizational structures

Top images from around the web for Personality vs organizational structures

• 

  Personality and Behavior in the Workplace | Organizational Behavior / Human Relations View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Conflict Management Styles | Organizational Behavior and Human Relations View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Personality and Behavior in the Workplace | Organizational Behavior / Human Relations View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Personality and Behavior in the Workplace | Organizational Behavior / Human Relations View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Conflict Management Styles | Organizational Behavior and Human Relations View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Personality vs organizational structures

• 

  Personality and Behavior in the Workplace | Organizational Behavior / Human Relations View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Conflict Management Styles | Organizational Behavior and Human Relations View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Personality and Behavior in the Workplace | Organizational Behavior / Human Relations View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Personality and Behavior in the Workplace | Organizational Behavior / Human Relations View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Conflict Management Styles | Organizational Behavior and Human Relations View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Personality development involves increased individuality and uniqueness
  • Individuals seek to express their distinct traits, values, and preferences (assertiveness, creativity)
  • Desire for autonomy and self-direction grows as personality develops (setting own goals, making decisions)
• Traditional organizational structures emphasize conformity and uniformity
  • Hierarchical structures with well-defined roles and responsibilities (top-down management, strict job descriptions)
  • Standardized procedures and rules to ensure consistency (dress codes, communication protocols)
  • Limited flexibility for individual expression and creativity (adherence to established norms, limited innovation)
• Conflicts arise when individual personality clashes with organizational expectations
  • Employees may feel stifled or restricted by rigid structures (lack of autonomy, micromanagement)
  • Unique talents and abilities may not be fully utilized or recognized (overlooked strengths, untapped potential)
  • Frustration and dissatisfaction can lead to reduced motivation and performance (disengagement, burnout)
  • Person-environment fit plays a crucial role in employee satisfaction and productivity

Coping strategies for workplace conflicts

• Compartmentalization: Separating work and personal life
  • Maintaining a distinct persona at work to fit organizational expectations (professional demeanor, adhering to norms)
  • Expressing individuality and authentic self outside of work (pursuing hobbies, personal interests)
  • Striving for work-life balance to manage competing demands
• Seeking out compatible roles or departments within the organization
  • Identifying positions that align with personal strengths and preferences (creative roles, autonomous teams)
  • Requesting transfers or applying for internal job openings (lateral moves, promotions)
• Negotiating with supervisors or management for increased autonomy
  • Proposing flexible work arrangements or alternative approaches (remote work, project-based assignments)
  • Demonstrating the benefits of allowing individual expression and creativity (increased innovation, employee satisfaction)
• Developing a network of supportive colleagues and allies
  • Building relationships with like-minded individuals within the organization (affinity groups, mentorship programs)
  • Seeking guidance and support from mentors or trusted coworkers (advice, emotional support)
• Engaging in job crafting to align work with personal interests and values
  • Proactively shaping job responsibilities and tasks to match individual strengths (taking on new projects, delegating tasks)
  • Finding ways to incorporate personal passions and goals into work activities (volunteering, skill development)

Personality tests in employee selection

• Personality tests can provide insights into candidate fit and potential performance
  • Assessing traits such as conscientiousness, extraversion, and emotional stability (Big Five personality traits)
  • Identifying candidates whose personalities align with job requirements and organizational culture (sales roles, team-oriented positions)
• However, personality tests have limitations and potential drawbacks
  • Validity and reliability of tests may vary, leading to inaccurate or inconsistent results (poorly designed tests, lack of standardization)
  • Tests may not capture the full complexity and context of an individual's personality (situational factors, adaptability)
  • Overreliance on test results can lead to biased or discriminatory hiring decisions (favoring certain personality types, overlooking qualifications)
• Legal considerations when using personality tests in employee selection
  • Tests must be job-related and consistent with business necessity (relevant to job duties, essential functions)
  • Disparate impact on protected classes must be avoided (race, gender, age, disability)
  • Reasonable accommodations must be provided for individuals with disabilities (alternative test formats, extended time)
  • Confidentiality and privacy of test results must be maintained (secure storage, limited access)
• Best practices for using personality tests in employee selection
  1. Use tests in conjunction with other selection methods (interviews, work samples, reference checks)
  2. Ensure tests are validated and relevant to the specific job requirements (industry-specific norms, job analysis)
  3. Provide clear instructions and explanations to candidates regarding test purpose and use (informed consent, transparency)
  4. Train hiring managers and decision-makers on proper interpretation and application of test results (avoiding bias, considering multiple factors)
  5. Regularly review and update tests to ensure ongoing legal compliance and effectiveness (staying current with research, monitoring outcomes)

Organizational Dynamics and Employee Experience

• Organizational culture shapes employee behavior and attitudes
• Workplace diversity influences team dynamics and decision-making processes
• Employee engagement is crucial for maintaining productivity and job satisfaction
• Organizational change can impact individual roles and responsibilities, requiring adaptability
• Organizational behavior studies help in understanding and managing these complex interactions