2.2 Backward design and essential questions

Backward design is a game-changer for social studies teachers. It flips the script on lesson planning by starting with the end goals. This approach ensures that every activity and assessment aligns with what students should know and be able to do by the unit's end.

Essential questions are the heart of backward design in social studies. These open-ended, thought-provoking queries guide student exploration of big ideas and themes. They spark deep thinking and help students connect historical concepts to their own lives and the world around them.

Backward design overview

• Backward design is an instructional design approach that focuses on identifying desired learning outcomes before planning lessons and activities
• This approach ensures that all instructional activities are aligned with the intended learning goals and assessments
• Backward design is particularly relevant in social studies education as it helps teachers develop coherent and purposeful units that promote deep understanding of complex concepts and skills

Key principles of backward design

Top images from around the web for Key principles of backward design

• 

  Before the Semester – The Teaching and Learning Center View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Course Planning – UF Instructor Guide View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Backward design:learning with a Purpose LARC 1/29/11 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Before the Semester – The Teaching and Learning Center View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Course Planning – UF Instructor Guide View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Key principles of backward design

• 

  Before the Semester – The Teaching and Learning Center View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Course Planning – UF Instructor Guide View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Backward design:learning with a Purpose LARC 1/29/11 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Before the Semester – The Teaching and Learning Center View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Course Planning – UF Instructor Guide View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Identify desired results first by determining what students should know, understand, and be able to do by the end of the unit
• Design assessments that provide evidence of student understanding and mastery of the desired results
• Plan learning experiences and instruction that enable students to achieve the desired results and perform well on assessments
• Ensure alignment between desired results, assessments, and learning activities throughout the planning process

Backward design vs traditional planning

• Traditional planning often starts with selecting activities and materials before considering learning objectives and assessments
• Backward design prioritizes the identification of learning goals and the design of assessments before planning instructional activities
• Backward design helps avoid the "coverage trap" where teachers focus on covering content rather than ensuring student understanding
• Traditional planning may lead to disconnected activities and assessments that do not effectively support learning goals

Benefits of backward design

• Promotes intentional and purposeful instructional planning that aligns with desired learning outcomes
• Encourages teachers to focus on essential understandings and skills rather than simply covering content
• Helps students understand the relevance and importance of what they are learning by connecting activities to clear learning goals
• Facilitates the design of authentic assessments that measure student understanding and application of knowledge and skills
• Supports differentiation by allowing teachers to plan multiple pathways for students to achieve the desired results

Essential questions in backward design

• Essential questions are open-ended, thought-provoking inquiries that guide student learning and exploration throughout a unit
• These questions are a key component of backward design as they help frame the desired understandings and skills students should develop
• Essential questions in social studies often address big ideas, themes, and issues that are relevant across time and cultures

Characteristics of essential questions

• Open-ended and cannot be answered with a simple yes or no or a single fact
• Provoke deep thinking, discussion, and inquiry that leads to enduring understandings
• Relevant and meaningful to students' lives and the world beyond the classroom
• Recurring and can be revisited throughout the unit or course to deepen understanding
• Interdisciplinary and connect to other subject areas and real-world issues

Examples of essential questions

• How do power and privilege shape social, political, and economic systems? (Social Studies)
• What factors influence the rise and fall of civilizations? (World History)
• How do individuals and groups create change in their communities? (Civics)
• What is the relationship between geography and human development? (Geography)
• How do economic systems impact the distribution of wealth and resources? (Economics)

Developing effective essential questions

• Start with the desired understandings and skills identified in Stage 1 of backward design
• Craft questions that are open-ended, thought-provoking, and relevant to students' lives
• Ensure that the questions are aligned with content standards and learning objectives
• Refine the questions to be clear, concise, and engaging for students
• Consider how the questions will guide inquiry and assessment throughout the unit

Stages of backward design

• Backward design consists of three main stages that guide the instructional planning process
• Each stage builds upon the previous one to ensure alignment and coherence throughout the unit
• The stages are iterative and may be revisited and refined as needed during the planning process

Stage 1: Identifying desired results

• Determine the knowledge, understandings, and skills students should acquire by the end of the unit
• Identify essential questions that will guide student inquiry and exploration
• Align desired results with relevant content standards and learning objectives
• Prioritize enduring understandings and transferable skills over discrete facts and information

Stage 2: Determining acceptable evidence

• Design assessments that provide evidence of student understanding and mastery of the desired results
• Develop performance tasks, projects, and other authentic assessments that require students to apply their knowledge and skills
• Create rubrics or criteria that clearly define expectations for student performance on assessments
• Plan for both formative and summative assessments throughout the unit to monitor student progress and adjust instruction as needed

Stage 3: Planning learning experiences

• Design learning activities and instructional strategies that enable students to achieve the desired results and perform well on assessments
• Sequence learning experiences in a logical and coherent manner that builds towards the desired understandings and skills
• Incorporate a variety of instructional methods and resources to engage students and support diverse learning needs
• Plan for differentiation and scaffolding to ensure that all students can access and succeed in the learning experiences

Applying backward design in social studies

• Backward design is particularly relevant in social studies education due to the complexity and depth of the content and skills involved
• Social studies teachers can use backward design to develop units that promote critical thinking, inquiry, and civic engagement
• Applying backward design in social studies requires careful alignment of standards, essential questions, assessments, and learning experiences

Aligning standards with essential questions

• Identify relevant content standards and learning objectives for the social studies unit
• Craft essential questions that address the key concepts, themes, and skills outlined in the standards
• Ensure that the essential questions are open-ended, thought-provoking, and relevant to students' lives and the world beyond the classroom
• Use the essential questions to guide the development of assessments and learning experiences that align with the standards

Authentic assessments in social studies

• Design assessments that require students to apply their knowledge and skills to real-world situations and problems
• Develop performance tasks, projects, and simulations that engage students in authentic social studies practices (debates, research, civic action)
• Create rubrics or criteria that clearly define expectations for student performance on assessments and align with the desired results
• Use formative assessments throughout the unit to monitor student progress and provide feedback for improvement

Inquiry-based learning and backward design

• Inquiry-based learning is a student-centered approach that aligns well with backward design in social studies
• Develop inquiry units that are guided by essential questions and allow students to explore topics in-depth
• Provide resources and support for students to engage in research, analysis, and problem-solving related to the inquiry questions
• Use formative assessments and feedback to guide students' inquiry process and help them refine their understanding and skills
• Incorporate opportunities for student reflection and self-assessment to promote metacognition and ownership of learning

Challenges of backward design

• While backward design offers many benefits for instructional planning, it also presents some challenges for teachers and schools
• Addressing these challenges requires time, resources, and support for professional development and collaboration
• Overcoming the challenges of backward design can lead to more effective and meaningful learning experiences for students

Time-intensive planning process

• Backward design requires significant time and effort to identify desired results, design assessments, and plan learning experiences
• Teachers may need additional planning time and support to effectively implement backward design in their classrooms
• Collaboration with colleagues can help share the workload and generate ideas for assessments and learning activities

Shifting from content-driven instruction

• Backward design challenges the traditional approach of covering content in a linear fashion without deep understanding
• Teachers may need to adjust their mindset and practices to focus on essential understandings and skills rather than simply delivering information
• Professional development and coaching can support teachers in making this shift and designing more meaningful learning experiences

Overcoming teacher resistance

• Some teachers may be resistant to changing their instructional practices and adopting backward design
• Providing evidence of the benefits of backward design and sharing success stories can help build buy-in and motivation
• Offering ongoing support, resources, and opportunities for collaboration can help teachers feel more confident and committed to implementing backward design

Evaluating backward design effectiveness

• Evaluating the effectiveness of backward design is essential for ensuring that it is meeting the intended goals and supporting student learning
• Multiple sources of data and feedback should be used to assess the impact of backward design on student achievement and engagement
• The evaluation process should be ongoing and inform continuous improvement of instructional practices and unit design

Formative and summative assessments

• Use formative assessments throughout the unit to monitor student progress and provide feedback for improvement
• Analyze summative assessment data to determine whether students have achieved the desired results and mastered the essential skills
• Compare assessment results across different units and years to identify trends and areas for improvement in backward design implementation

Student engagement and understanding

• Observe student engagement and participation in learning activities and assessments
• Use student surveys, interviews, or focus groups to gather feedback on their understanding and perceptions of the unit
• Analyze student work samples and performance tasks to assess the depth and quality of their understanding and application of knowledge and skills

Teacher reflection and refinement

• Encourage teachers to reflect on their experience with backward design and identify successes, challenges, and areas for improvement
• Provide opportunities for teachers to share their reflections and collaborate with colleagues to refine their unit designs and instructional practices
• Use teacher feedback and observation data to identify common challenges and provide targeted support and professional development
• Continuously refine and update backward design units based on evaluation data and changing student needs and contexts