2.4 Dialogue and subtext

Dialogue and subtext are key elements in theater, shaping characters and advancing plots. They work together to create depth, revealing hidden meanings and emotions beneath the surface of spoken words.

Playwrights use various types of dialogue to craft compelling stories. From direct to indirect, inner to spoken, and realistic to stylized, each serves a unique purpose in bringing characters to life and engaging audiences.

Types of dialogue

• Dialogue is a crucial element in theater that conveys information, reveals character, and advances the plot
• Different types of dialogue serve various purposes and create distinct effects on stage

Direct vs indirect dialogue

Top images from around the web for Direct vs indirect dialogue

• 

  Text and Subtext – Writeskaya from Samarskaya & Partners – Medium View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  SubText Discussion Example | www.subtext.com/ | By: Wesley Fryer | Flickr - Photo Sharing! View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Text and Subtext – Writeskaya from Samarskaya & Partners – Medium View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Text and Subtext – Writeskaya from Samarskaya & Partners – Medium View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  SubText Discussion Example | www.subtext.com/ | By: Wesley Fryer | Flickr - Photo Sharing! View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Direct vs indirect dialogue

• 

  Text and Subtext – Writeskaya from Samarskaya & Partners – Medium View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  SubText Discussion Example | www.subtext.com/ | By: Wesley Fryer | Flickr - Photo Sharing! View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Text and Subtext – Writeskaya from Samarskaya & Partners – Medium View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Text and Subtext – Writeskaya from Samarskaya & Partners – Medium View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  SubText Discussion Example | www.subtext.com/ | By: Wesley Fryer | Flickr - Photo Sharing! View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Direct dialogue explicitly states a character's thoughts, feelings, or intentions through their spoken words
• Indirect dialogue implies meaning through subtext, tone, or context without directly stating it
• Direct dialogue provides clarity and immediacy (e.g., "I love you"), while indirect dialogue adds depth and nuance (e.g., "I can't imagine my life without you")
• Playwrights often use a combination of direct and indirect dialogue to create a balanced and engaging script

Inner vs spoken dialogue

• Inner dialogue refers to a character's unspoken thoughts, monologues, or soliloquies that reveal their inner world
• Spoken dialogue is the verbal exchange between characters that the audience can hear
• Inner dialogue provides insight into a character's motivations, conflicts, and desires (e.g., Hamlet's "To be, or not to be" soliloquy)
• Spoken dialogue drives the action, develops relationships, and conveys information to the audience

Realistic vs stylized dialogue

• Realistic dialogue aims to mimic everyday speech patterns, rhythms, and idioms to create a sense of authenticity
• Stylized dialogue departs from naturalism and employs heightened language, poetic devices, or exaggerated speech patterns for artistic effect
• Realistic dialogue is often used in contemporary plays or naturalistic styles (e.g., August Wilson's works)
• Stylized dialogue is common in classical plays, musicals, or experimental theater (e.g., Shakespeare's iambic pentameter or Brecht's epic theater)

Functions of dialogue

• Dialogue serves multiple functions in theater, from character development to thematic exploration
• Playwrights use dialogue strategically to engage the audience and create a compelling dramatic experience

Revealing character

• Dialogue exposes a character's personality, background, values, and motivations through their word choice, syntax, and tone
• Characters' speech patterns, vocabulary, and idiosyncrasies help distinguish them from one another and create a sense of individuality
• Dialogue can reveal character growth or change over the course of the play (e.g., Eliza Doolittle's language transformation in "Pygmalion")
• Subtext in dialogue can expose a character's true intentions or feelings beneath the surface

Advancing plot

• Dialogue propels the story forward by introducing conflicts, complications, and turning points
• Characters' verbal interactions can create suspense, tension, or anticipation for the audience
• Dialogue can provide exposition, revealing backstory or crucial information necessary for understanding the plot
• Key dialogues or confrontations often mark pivotal moments in the dramatic structure (e.g., the climactic argument in "Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?")

Establishing tone and mood

• The style, language, and delivery of dialogue contribute to the overall atmosphere and emotional resonance of a scene or play
• Comedic dialogue uses wit, irony, or absurdity to create a light-hearted or humorous tone (e.g., Oscar Wilde's clever repartee)
• Dramatic dialogue employs intense, serious, or emotionally charged language to establish a somber or heavy mood (e.g., the tense exchanges in "A Streetcar Named Desire")
• Dialogue can also create a sense of realism, fantasy, or surrealism depending on the playwright's stylistic choices

Conveying theme and meaning

• Dialogue can express the central ideas, messages, or philosophical questions explored in the play
• Characters' conversations can debate or grapple with thematic issues, inviting the audience to reflect on broader human experiences
• Recurring motifs, symbols, or metaphors in dialogue can underscore the play's deeper meanings (e.g., the references to dreams in "Death of a Salesman")
• The subtext of dialogue can implicitly communicate the playwright's intended themes or social commentary

Crafting effective dialogue

• Writing compelling dialogue requires a keen understanding of language, character, and dramatic structure
• Playwrights employ various techniques to create dialogue that engages the audience and serves the play's artistic vision

Natural flow and pacing

• Effective dialogue mimics the rhythms and cadences of real speech while maintaining a sense of purposefulness and economy
• Varying the length and structure of characters' lines can create a dynamic and engaging flow (e.g., short, rapid-fire exchanges or long, contemplative monologues)
• Pacing dialogue involves balancing moments of intensity or revelation with pauses, silences, or more mundane interactions
• Playwrights often read their dialogue aloud to ensure it sounds natural and believable when performed

Distinctive character voices

• Each character should have a unique voice that reflects their personality, background, and role in the story
• Differentiating characters' speech patterns, vocabulary, and mannerisms helps create a sense of individuality and depth
• Consistency in a character's voice is crucial for maintaining believability and coherence throughout the play
• Playwrights may draw inspiration from real people, archetypes, or their own imagination to craft distinct character voices

Brevity and efficiency

• Effective dialogue is concise and purposeful, avoiding unnecessary exposition or redundancy
• Playwrights often trim or refine their dialogue through multiple drafts to ensure every line serves a clear function
• Brevity in dialogue maintains a sense of momentum and keeps the audience engaged in the unfolding action
• Efficient dialogue conveys essential information or character insights without excessive explanation or elaboration

Subtext and implication

• Subtext refers to the underlying meanings, emotions, or intentions beneath the surface of the spoken words
• Effective dialogue often relies on implication and inference, allowing the audience to read between the lines
• Subtext can create dramatic irony, tension, or ambiguity by revealing discrepancies between what characters say and what they truly mean
• Playwrights use various techniques to convey subtext, such as tone, body language, or strategic omissions in the dialogue

Subtext in dialogue

• Subtext is a fundamental aspect of effective dialogue that adds depth, nuance, and complexity to the characters' interactions
• Understanding and interpreting subtext is crucial for actors, directors, and audiences alike

Definition and purpose

• Subtext refers to the unspoken thoughts, feelings, desires, or motivations that underlie the characters' spoken words
• The purpose of subtext is to create a richer, more layered dramatic experience that engages the audience's imagination and empathy
• Subtext adds depth to characters by revealing their inner lives, conflicts, and relationships beyond the surface-level dialogue
• Interpreting subtext allows actors to make dynamic, nuanced choices in their performance that bring the characters to life

Verbal vs nonverbal subtext

• Verbal subtext involves the strategic use of language, tone, or phrasing to imply meanings beyond the literal words spoken
• Nonverbal subtext includes facial expressions, body language, gestures, or physical actions that convey unspoken meanings
• Verbal subtext may involve irony, sarcasm, understatement, or double entendres that hint at deeper intentions or emotions
• Nonverbal subtext can reinforce, contradict, or complicate the spoken dialogue, creating a more complex and engaging dramatic experience

Techniques for conveying subtext

• Playwrights use various literary devices and strategies to embed subtext within the dialogue, such as:
  • Metaphors or symbolic language that suggests deeper meanings or associations
  • Repetition or echoing of key phrases that accumulate significance throughout the play
  • Pauses, silences, or interruptions that create tension or imply unspoken thoughts or feelings
  • Contradictions or discrepancies between characters' words and actions that hint at hidden motivations
• Actors and directors also play a crucial role in conveying subtext through their interpretive choices, such as:
  • Inflection, tone, or emphasis that suggests underlying emotions or intentions
  • Blocking or staging that positions characters in meaningful or revealing ways
  • Facial expressions or gestures that communicate unspoken reactions or desires

Interpreting subtext as an actor

• Actors must thoroughly analyze the script to identify and interpret the subtext beneath their characters' lines
• Understanding the character's objectives, obstacles, and relationships is crucial for making choices that effectively convey subtext
• Actors may ask questions or make inferences about their character's inner life, backstory, or unspoken thoughts to inform their performance
• Rehearsals provide an opportunity for actors to experiment with different subtextual choices and refine their interpretation in collaboration with the director and other cast members

Dialogue formatting

• Proper formatting is essential for clearly communicating the playwright's intentions and facilitating the script's interpretation by actors, directors, and designers
• Consistent and standardized formatting conventions ensure that the script is readable, accessible, and easily translatable to the stage

Stage directions and parentheticals

• Stage directions are written instructions that describe the characters' actions, movements, or physical descriptions, usually italicized or enclosed in brackets
• Parentheticals are brief notes placed within the dialogue that indicate how a line should be delivered or what action accompanies the speech, often enclosed in parentheses
• Stage directions and parentheticals provide crucial guidance for actors and directors in interpreting the script and bringing the story to life
• Playwrights must use stage directions and parentheticals judiciously, finding a balance between necessary guidance and allowing room for artistic interpretation

Punctuation and capitalization

• Punctuation in dialogue helps convey the rhythm, pacing, and tone of the characters' speech
• Dashes (--) indicate interruptions or abrupt shifts in thought, while ellipses (...) suggest trailing off or unfinished sentences
• Question marks (?) and exclamation points (!) convey the intensity or intonation of the character's speech
• Capitalization is used for character names, sound effects (e.g., BOOM!), or emphatic words or phrases
• Consistent and deliberate use of punctuation and capitalization helps actors and directors interpret the script's intended meaning and emotional resonance

Monologues vs conversations

• Monologues are extended speeches delivered by a single character, often revealing their inner thoughts, feelings, or motivations
• Conversations involve the verbal exchange between two or more characters, building relationships, advancing the plot, or exploring conflicts
• Formatting for monologues and conversations differs in terms of line spacing, indentation, and attribution of speeches to characters
• Playwrights must consider the dramatic function and pacing of monologues and conversations within the overall structure of the play

Interruptions and overlapping dialogue

• Interruptions occur when one character cuts off another's speech, often indicated by a dash (--) at the end of the interrupted line and the beginning of the interrupting line
• Overlapping dialogue happens when two or more characters speak simultaneously, usually indicated by slashes (/) or vertical alignment of the lines
• Interruptions and overlapping dialogue can create a sense of realistic conversation, heighten dramatic tension, or reveal power dynamics between characters
• Playwrights must use these techniques purposefully to enhance the dramatic effect and avoid confusion or clutter on the page

Dialogue in different genres

• The style, tone, and function of dialogue vary across different theatrical genres and traditions
• Understanding the conventions and expectations of each genre helps playwrights craft effective dialogue that resonates with the intended audience and artistic vision

Comedy vs drama

• Comedic dialogue often relies on wit, irony, wordplay, or absurdity to create humorous situations or characters (e.g., the banter in Oscar Wilde's "The Importance of Being Earnest")
• Dramatic dialogue tends to be more serious, intense, or emotionally charged, exploring complex themes or conflicts (e.g., the confrontations in Arthur Miller's "Death of a Salesman")
• The pacing, rhythm, and tone of dialogue differ between comedy and drama, with comedic dialogue often featuring rapid-fire exchanges and dramatic dialogue allowing for more pauses and gravitas
• Playwrights must consider the intended emotional response and thematic resonance when crafting dialogue for comedic or dramatic purposes

Realism vs absurdism

• Realistic dialogue aims to mimic everyday speech patterns, idioms, and vernacular to create a sense of authenticity and believability (e.g., the natural conversations in August Wilson's "Fences")
• Absurdist dialogue often defies logical or conventional communication, using non sequiturs, repetition, or nonsensical language to convey the absurdity or meaninglessness of human existence (e.g., the circular exchanges in Samuel Beckett's "Waiting for Godot")
• The style and structure of dialogue in realism and absurdism reflect the underlying philosophical or artistic intentions of the playwright
• Playwrights must consider the thematic implications and audience expectations when choosing between realistic or absurdist approaches to dialogue

Period-specific dialogue

• Period plays set in specific historical eras require dialogue that accurately reflects the language, idioms, and social norms of the time (e.g., the Elizabethan English in Shakespeare's plays)
• Playwrights must research the linguistic and cultural context of the period to ensure the dialogue is authentic and believable
• Period-specific dialogue can also serve as a stylistic or thematic device, evoking a particular atmosphere or commenting on the social dynamics of the era
• Balancing historical accuracy with contemporary accessibility is a challenge when crafting period-specific dialogue

Verse and poetic dialogue

• Some theatrical traditions, such as classical Greek drama or Elizabethan theater, employ verse or poetic language in their dialogue
• Verse dialogue follows a specific metrical pattern or rhyme scheme, such as iambic pentameter in Shakespeare's plays
• Poetic dialogue uses heightened language, metaphors, or other literary devices to create a sense of elegance, formality, or emotional intensity
• Playwrights must consider the dramatic function and thematic resonance of verse or poetic dialogue within the overall structure and style of the play
• Actors and directors face unique challenges in interpreting and delivering verse or poetic dialogue, requiring a keen understanding of rhythm, meter, and language

Challenges in writing dialogue

• Crafting effective dialogue requires skill, practice, and a deep understanding of character, structure, and dramatic purpose
• Playwrights face various challenges in writing dialogue that engages the audience, serves the story, and translates effectively to the stage

Avoiding exposition and info-dumping

• Exposition refers to the necessary background information or context that the audience needs to understand the story or characters
• Info-dumping occurs when characters unnaturally convey large amounts of exposition or explain things that they would realistically already know
• Playwrights must find ways to weave exposition naturally into the dialogue, avoiding clunky or artificial-sounding speeches
• Techniques for avoiding info-dumping include revealing information gradually, using subtext or implication, or finding organic moments for characters to discuss necessary details

Balancing dialogue with action

• Effective plays balance dialogue with physical action, visual storytelling, and non-verbal communication
• Overreliance on dialogue can lead to static or "talky" scenes that fail to engage the audience or advance the plot
• Playwrights must consider when dialogue is necessary and when action or silence might be more effective in conveying meaning or emotion
• Integrating dialogue with stage directions, blocking, or other visual elements can create a more dynamic and engaging theatrical experience

Maintaining consistency and believability

• Ensuring that dialogue remains consistent with each character's established voice, personality, and background is crucial for maintaining believability
• Inconsistencies or sudden shifts in a character's speech patterns or vocabulary can undermine the audience's suspension of disbelief
• Playwrights must also ensure that dialogue is consistent with the play's overall style, tone, and genre
• Continuously reviewing and refining dialogue through multiple drafts can help maintain consistency and believability throughout the script

Adapting dialogue for performance

• Dialogue that reads well on the page may not always translate effectively to the stage
• Playwrights must consider the practical realities of performance, such as actors' interpretations, staging limitations, or audience reception
• Collaborating with actors, directors, and other members of the creative team during the development process can help refine the dialogue for optimal performance
• Being open to feedback, revisions, and adaptations during rehearsals and productions can help ensure that the dialogue achieves its intended dramatic impact

Analyzing dialogue in scripts

• Analyzing the dialogue in existing scripts is a valuable exercise for playwrights, actors, directors, and scholars alike
• Close reading and interpretation of dialogue can reveal insights into character, theme, structure, and the playwright's artistic intentions

Identifying character objectives

• Analyzing dialogue can help identify each character's objectives, or what they want to achieve in a given scene or throughout the play
• Examining the subtext, word choice, and rhetorical strategies employed by characters can reveal their underlying motivations, desires, or fears
• Understanding character objectives is crucial for actors in making performance choices and for directors in guiding the overall interpretation of the script

Examining power dynamics

• Dialogue often reflects the power dynamics between characters, revealing who holds authority, influence, or control in a given relationship or situation
• Analyzing the use of interruptions, silences, or dominant speaking patterns can expose the underlying power structures at play
• Examining power dynamics can provide insight into the characters' social roles, hierarchies, or conflicts and how they shape the dramatic action

Tracking character development

• Analyzing dialogue throughout the script can reveal how characters evolve, change, or grow over the course of the play
• Examining shifts in a character's language, tone, or speaking style can indicate internal transformations or responses to external events
• Tracking character development through dialogue can help actors and directors make choices that effectively convey the characters' journeys and arcs

Assessing overall effectiveness and impact

• Analyzing the cumulative effect of dialogue in a script can provide insight into the playwright's overall artistic vision and thematic intentions
• Examining