2.7 Network access control

Network access control (NAC) is a crucial security approach that regulates access to network resources. It authenticates devices and users, ensures compliance with security policies, and segments networks based on roles and device types. NAC is essential for maintaining confidentiality, integrity, and availability of network assets.

Key components of NAC include policy servers, network enforcement points, client agents, and directory services. Different models exist, such as agent-based vs agentless and pre-admission vs post-admission control. NAC relies on protocols like 802.1X, RADIUS, and TACACS+ to enforce access policies and manage network security.

Network access control fundamentals

• Network access control (NAC) is a security approach that regulates access to network resources based on the identity and security posture of devices and users
• NAC helps prevent unauthorized access, contain the spread of malware, and enforce security policies across wired and wireless networks
• Implementing NAC is crucial for maintaining the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of network assets in modern enterprise environments

Goals of network access control

Top images from around the web for Goals of network access control

• 

  Secure Network Life-Cycle | IINS 210-260 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  IoT Security Model View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Information Security Principles View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Secure Network Life-Cycle | IINS 210-260 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  IoT Security Model View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Goals of network access control

• 

  Secure Network Life-Cycle | IINS 210-260 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  IoT Security Model View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Information Security Principles View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Secure Network Life-Cycle | IINS 210-260 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  IoT Security Model View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Authenticate and authorize devices and users before granting network access
• Ensure that connected devices comply with security policies (antivirus, patches)
• Segment the network to limit access to sensitive resources based on user roles and device types
• Provide visibility into the devices and users accessing the network for security monitoring and incident response

Key components of NAC

• Policy server: Central management console for defining and enforcing NAC policies
• Network enforcement points: Switches, routers, and wireless controllers that enforce NAC policies
• Client agents: Software installed on endpoints to assess their security posture and communicate with the policy server
• Directory services: Integration with user directories (Active Directory) for authentication and role-based access control

Network access control models

Agent-based vs agentless NAC

• Agent-based NAC requires software installed on endpoints for posture assessment and policy enforcement
  • Provides more granular control and continuous monitoring of endpoint security state
  • Suitable for managed devices (corporate-owned laptops, desktops)
• Agentless NAC relies on network-based methods (SNMP, DHCP, 802.1X) to assess device security posture
  • Easier to deploy and manage, as no agent installation is required
  • Suitable for unmanaged devices (BYOD, IoT) and guest access scenarios

Pre-admission vs post-admission control

• Pre-admission control evaluates devices before granting network access
  • Checks device identity, security posture, and user credentials
  • Quarantines or denies access to non-compliant devices
• Post-admission control continuously monitors devices after they are granted access
  • Detects changes in device security posture and user behavior
  • Can dynamically adjust access privileges or isolate devices if security risks are detected

Inline vs out-of-band enforcement

• Inline enforcement places NAC devices (appliances, switches) directly in the path of network traffic
  • Enables real-time blocking of unauthorized access attempts
  • Suitable for high-security environments (government, finance)
• Out-of-band enforcement uses a separate management network for NAC communication
  • Minimizes impact on network performance and availability
  • Suitable for large, distributed networks with diverse device types

Network access control protocols

802.1X authentication

• IEEE standard for port-based network access control
• Provides a framework for authenticating devices and users before granting network access
• Uses EAP (Extensible Authentication Protocol) for secure communication between the client (supplicant), authenticator (switch), and authentication server (RADIUS)
• Supports various authentication methods (passwords, certificates, tokens)

RADIUS for centralized authentication

• Remote Authentication Dial-In User Service (RADIUS) is a protocol for centralized authentication, authorization, and accounting (AAA)
• RADIUS server acts as the backend authentication server for 802.1X and other NAC implementations
• Supports a wide range of authentication methods and can integrate with existing user directories (Active Directory)
• Provides scalability and redundancy for large-scale NAC deployments

TACACS+ for device administration

• Terminal Access Controller Access-Control System Plus (TACACS+) is a protocol for centralized authentication and authorization of network devices
• TACACS+ server provides granular control over administrative access to switches, routers, and other network infrastructure
• Supports command-level authorization and accounting for enhanced security and auditing
• Complements RADIUS by focusing on device administration while RADIUS handles user authentication

Network access control policies

User identity and role-based policies

• Define network access policies based on user identity and role information from directory services (Active Directory)
• Assign different levels of access to network resources based on user job function, department, or security clearance
• Implement least privilege access, granting users only the permissions they need to perform their tasks
• Regularly review and update user roles and access policies to ensure they remain aligned with business requirements

Device health and compliance checks

• Establish security baselines for devices connecting to the network (antivirus, patches, firewall)
• Use NAC agents or agentless methods to assess device security posture before and after granting access
• Define granular policies for different device types (Windows, Mac, iOS, Android) and ownership (corporate, BYOD)
• Integrate with patch management and endpoint security solutions for automated compliance checks and remediation

Remediation and quarantine procedures

• Automatically quarantine or restrict access for devices that fail compliance checks
• Provide users with self-service remediation options (install updates, run scans) to regain full network access
• Implement captive portals for guest devices to enforce acceptable use policies and limit access to internal resources
• Establish escalation procedures for handling non-compliant devices and users that pose a high risk to the network

Network access control solutions

NAC appliances and servers

• Dedicated hardware appliances or virtual machines that provide centralized NAC policy management and enforcement
• Offer pre-built integrations with network infrastructure, directory services, and security solutions
• Provide a single pane of glass for monitoring and controlling network access across wired, wireless, and VPN connections
• Examples: Cisco ISE, Forescout CounterACT, Aruba ClearPass

Integration with network infrastructure

• NAC solutions must integrate with existing network switches, routers, and wireless controllers to enforce access policies
• Use standard protocols (802.1X, RADIUS, SNMP) for communication between NAC components and network devices
• Leverage vendor-specific APIs and partnerships for deeper integration and automation capabilities
• Ensure compatibility with different network vendors and models to avoid interoperability issues

Comparison of leading NAC vendors

• Evaluate NAC solutions based on features, scalability, ease of deployment, and integration capabilities
• Consider vendor track record, customer support, and alignment with existing network and security investments
• Leading NAC vendors include Cisco, Forescout, Aruba, Bradford Networks, and Pulse Secure
• Conduct proof-of-concept trials and reference customer case studies to select the best fit for your organization's needs

Network access control best practices

Planning and design considerations

• Identify business drivers and regulatory requirements for NAC implementation
• Define use cases and success criteria for different user and device populations
• Assess current network infrastructure and security posture to identify gaps and integration points
• Develop a phased deployment plan that minimizes disruption to business operations

Phased deployment strategies

• Start with a small, controlled pilot to validate NAC policies and workflows
• Gradually expand NAC coverage to different network segments and user groups
• Prioritize high-risk areas (executive offices, R&D labs) and new initiatives (BYOD, IoT)
• Continuously monitor and refine NAC policies based on feedback and lessons learned

Ongoing monitoring and management

• Establish a dedicated NAC operations team responsible for policy management, troubleshooting, and reporting
• Integrate NAC with SIEM and other security monitoring tools for real-time threat detection and response
• Regularly review NAC logs and access reports to identify anomalies and improve security posture
• Conduct periodic audits and penetration tests to validate the effectiveness of NAC controls

Network access control challenges

Compatibility with legacy systems

• Older network devices and endpoints may not support NAC protocols (802.1X) or agents
• Develop a migration plan to upgrade or replace legacy systems over time
• Implement compensating controls (MAC authentication bypass) for devices that cannot be fully integrated with NAC
• Use agentless NAC methods (SNMP, DHCP) to provide basic access control for legacy systems

Handling guest and BYOD devices

• Establish clear policies and procedures for onboarding and securing guest and BYOD devices
• Implement captive portals and self-registration workflows to streamline guest access
• Use device profiling and posture assessment to identify and classify BYOD devices
• Provide differentiated access levels and network segments for guest and BYOD devices to limit their exposure to internal resources

Balancing security and usability

• Overly restrictive NAC policies can hinder productivity and frustrate users
• Involve business stakeholders and end-users in the NAC planning and testing process
• Provide clear communication and training on NAC policies and procedures
• Implement self-service portals and automated remediation workflows to minimize user disruption
• Continuously monitor user feedback and adjust NAC policies to strike the right balance between security and usability

Network access control future trends

Cloud-based NAC services

• NAC delivered as a cloud service, eliminating the need for on-premises infrastructure
• Provides scalability, flexibility, and reduced management overhead
• Enables secure access for remote workers and cloud-based resources
• Examples: Cisco Meraki, Portnox CLEAR, Pulse Policy Secure

Adaptive and risk-based approaches

• Use machine learning and behavioral analytics to dynamically adjust NAC policies based on user and device risk profiles
• Integrate with threat intelligence feeds and vulnerability scanners to identify and isolate high-risk devices
• Implement continuous authentication and authorization to detect and respond to changes in user and device context
• Enable automated threat response actions (quarantine, block) based on predefined risk thresholds

Integration with zero trust frameworks

• NAC as a foundational component of a broader zero trust security strategy
• Enforce least privilege access and continuous trust verification across users, devices, and applications
• Integrate NAC with identity and access management (IAM), multi-factor authentication (MFA), and software-defined perimeter (SDP) solutions
• Use micro-segmentation and granular access policies to limit lateral movement and contain breaches