2.1 Primary and secondary sources in journalism

Journalists rely on primary and secondary sources to gather information and tell compelling stories. Primary sources provide direct evidence, like interviews and official records, while secondary sources offer analysis and context.

Understanding the strengths of each source type is crucial for effective reporting. Primary sources offer unfiltered insights, while secondary sources synthesize information and identify trends. Journalists must carefully evaluate sources to ensure accuracy and credibility in their work.

Primary vs Secondary Sources

Defining Primary and Secondary Sources

Top images from around the web for Defining Primary and Secondary Sources

• 

  Primary and Secondary Sources: Fact Sheet | OERTX View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Evaluating Information & Citing Sources - First Year Writing (General) - James P. Adams Library ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Primary and Secondary Sources: Fact Sheet | OERTX View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Evaluating Information & Citing Sources - First Year Writing (General) - James P. Adams Library ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 2

Top images from around the web for Defining Primary and Secondary Sources

• 

  Primary and Secondary Sources: Fact Sheet | OERTX View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Evaluating Information & Citing Sources - First Year Writing (General) - James P. Adams Library ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Primary and Secondary Sources: Fact Sheet | OERTX View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Evaluating Information & Citing Sources - First Year Writing (General) - James P. Adams Library ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 2

• Primary sources are original materials that provide direct evidence or first-hand accounts of an event
  • Examples of primary sources include interviews, photographs, letters, diaries, speeches, and official records
• Secondary sources interpret, analyze, or summarize information from primary sources
  • Examples of secondary sources include news articles, books, documentaries, and scholarly journals
• Primary sources are created by individuals directly involved in or witnessing an event, while secondary sources are produced by individuals who were not directly involved but have researched the event

Using Primary and Secondary Sources in Journalism

• Breaking news stories often rely heavily on primary sources to provide immediate and accurate information
  • Primary sources in breaking news may include eyewitness accounts, official statements, and live footage from the scene
• Investigative reporting and long-form journalism may require a combination of primary and secondary sources to uncover new information, provide context, and build a compelling narrative
  • Investigative journalists may use primary sources such as leaked documents, insider interviews, and undercover footage, while also consulting secondary sources like academic research and historical records
• Stories about historical events or complex issues may rely more on secondary sources to provide a comprehensive overview and analysis of the topic
  • A documentary about the Civil Rights Movement, for example, would likely draw on secondary sources like scholarly books, archival footage, and expert interviews to provide a broad perspective on the era

Advantages of Primary Sources

Direct and Unfiltered Information

• Primary sources provide direct, unfiltered information about an event or issue
  • An interview with a witness to a crime, for example, offers a firsthand account of what happened without any intermediary interpretation or analysis
• Primary sources allow journalists to draw their own conclusions based on raw data and evidence
  • A journalist reviewing official government documents can analyze the information directly rather than relying on someone else's summary or interpretation

Unique Perspectives and Insights

• Primary sources offer unique perspectives and insights that may not be available through secondary sources
  • A personal diary from a historical figure can provide intimate details and reflections that are not captured in broader historical accounts
• Journalists can uncover new information and angles by seeking out primary sources with diverse experiences and viewpoints
  • Interviewing multiple eyewitnesses to an event can reveal different aspects of what happened and help piece together a more comprehensive picture

Credibility and Verification

• Primary sources can help journalists verify existing claims and add credibility to their reporting
  • A journalist investigating a company's alleged wrongdoing can use primary sources like financial records and internal emails to corroborate or refute the claims
• Using primary sources demonstrates a commitment to thorough and accurate reporting, as it shows that the journalist has gone directly to the source rather than relying solely on secondhand information
  • A news article that includes quotes from multiple primary sources, such as interviews with key stakeholders and official statements, is likely to be seen as more credible than one that only cites secondary sources

Secondary Sources for Context

Synthesizing Information and Providing Context

• Secondary sources offer a broader understanding of an event or issue by synthesizing information from multiple primary sources
  • A scholarly article on a political movement may draw on dozens of primary sources, such as speeches, manifestos, and eyewitness accounts, to provide a comprehensive overview of the movement's goals, tactics, and impact
• Secondary sources provide historical, social, and cultural context that can help situate a story within a larger framework of understanding
  • A book about the history of a particular region can help a journalist understand the long-term factors and trends that have shaped current events in that area

Identifying Themes, Trends, and Patterns

• Journalists use secondary sources to identify key themes, trends, and patterns related to their story
  • A reporter covering a public health crisis may consult academic studies and government reports to identify common risk factors, vulnerable populations, and potential solutions
• Secondary sources can help journalists see the bigger picture and make connections between seemingly disparate events or issues
  • A documentary about climate change may draw on scientific research, policy analysis, and case studies from around the world to illustrate the global scope and interconnected impacts of the problem

Building on Existing Research and Reporting

• Secondary sources can help journalists identify potential sources, verify information, and avoid duplication of effort by building on existing research and reporting
  • A journalist investigating a local corruption scandal may start by reviewing previous news articles and court records to identify key players, timeline of events, and potential leads for further investigation
• Scholarly articles, books, and documentaries are examples of secondary sources that can provide in-depth analysis and expert commentary on complex topics
  • A reporter covering a breakthrough in artificial intelligence may consult academic journals and expert interviews to better understand the technical details and potential implications of the development

Choosing Primary or Secondary Sources

Evaluating Credibility, Reliability, and Relevance

• Journalists must carefully evaluate the credibility, reliability, and relevance of both primary and secondary sources
  • When using a primary source like an eyewitness account, journalists should consider factors like the witness's proximity to the event, potential biases or motivations, and consistency with other available evidence
  • When using a secondary source like a research study, journalists should assess the author's qualifications, the publication's reputation, the methodology used, and the timeliness of the information
• Journalists should use sources appropriately to support their reporting while avoiding over-reliance on any single source
  • A well-rounded news article will typically include a mix of primary and secondary sources, such as quotes from interviews, references to official documents, and citations of relevant research or analysis

Considering the Goals and Requirements of the Story

• The choice between primary and secondary sources ultimately depends on the specific goals and requirements of the story, as well as the availability and accessibility of relevant sources
  • A breaking news story about a natural disaster may rely primarily on primary sources like eyewitness accounts and official statements, as there may not yet be any secondary sources available
  • A feature story about a long-term social trend may draw more heavily on secondary sources like academic research and expert analysis, as these can provide a broader and more longitudinal perspective on the issue
• Journalists should consider what kind of information and perspectives are needed to tell the story accurately, comprehensively, and compellingly, and seek out the sources that best meet those needs
  • If a story requires a detailed understanding of a complex technical issue, journalists may prioritize scholarly articles and expert interviews over more general news coverage or public opinion
  • If a story aims to capture the human impact of an event or policy, journalists may focus on collecting firsthand accounts and personal stories from those directly affected