2.2 Street art and graffiti as forms of resistance

Street art and graffiti have emerged as powerful forms of resistance and social commentary. From their roots in marginalized communities to global recognition, these art forms challenge power structures and reclaim public spaces. They've become a voice for the voiceless, critiquing everything from corporate advertising to political leaders.

The legal and ethical implications of street art are complex. While some view it as vandalism, others see it as free speech. The commercialization of street art raises questions about authenticity and co-optation. Despite challenges, street art continues to transform neglected spaces and foster community engagement, sparking important conversations about urban life and social justice.

Street Art and Social Commentary

Emergence as a Form of Expression for Marginalized Communities

Top images from around the web for Emergence as a Form of Expression for Marginalized Communities

• 

  Street Art & Graffiti (Francis Street area Of Dublin) | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  La historia y origen del hip-hop surgió a finales de 1960, en la ciudad de Nueva York ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Bogota Street Art - Graffiti | Ashley Bayles | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Street Art & Graffiti (Francis Street area Of Dublin) | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  La historia y origen del hip-hop surgió a finales de 1960, en la ciudad de Nueva York ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Emergence as a Form of Expression for Marginalized Communities

• 

  Street Art & Graffiti (Francis Street area Of Dublin) | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  La historia y origen del hip-hop surgió a finales de 1960, en la ciudad de Nueva York ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Bogota Street Art - Graffiti | Ashley Bayles | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Street Art & Graffiti (Francis Street area Of Dublin) | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  La historia y origen del hip-hop surgió a finales de 1960, en la ciudad de Nueva York ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Street art and graffiti emerged as a way for marginalized communities to express themselves and claim public space, often in response to social and political issues
• Graffiti originated in the 1960s and 70s in New York City, particularly in African American and Latino communities, as a form of "tagging" or leaving one's mark on the urban landscape
  • Early graffiti writers used tags to assert their identity and presence in the face of marginalization and erasure
  • Tagging crews formed around shared styles and territories, creating a sense of community and belonging
• The rise of hip-hop culture and breakdancing in the 1980s further popularized graffiti as an art form and means of self-expression for urban youth
  • Graffiti became an integral part of hip-hop's visual identity, alongside rapping, DJing, and breakdancing
  • Graffiti writers often used their art to comment on social and political issues affecting their communities (poverty, racism, police brutality)

Evolution and Mainstream Recognition of Street Art

• Street art evolved in the 1980s and 90s to include more elaborate murals, stencils, and installations, often with explicit political messages or social commentary
  • Artists like Blek le Rat and Banksy popularized the use of stencils to create subversive and satirical images
  • Muralists like Lady Pink and Swoon used their art to celebrate community histories and address social issues (gender inequality, gentrification)
• Street artists like Jean-Michel Basquiat and Keith Haring gained mainstream recognition in the 1980s, blurring the lines between "high art" and "street art"
  • Basquiat's graffiti-inspired paintings critiqued racism, capitalism, and colonialism while commanding high prices in the art market
  • Haring's playful and accessible style brought attention to issues like AIDS, drug addiction, and environmental degradation
• The development of spray paint and other accessible materials allowed for the proliferation of street art and graffiti in cities around the world
  • The portability and quick-drying properties of spray paint made it easier for artists to work quickly and surreptitiously
  • The availability of cheap or recycled materials like stickers, posters, and found objects expanded the range of street art techniques
• The internet and social media have enabled street artists to share their work globally and organize around social and political causes
  • Online platforms like Instagram and Facebook allow artists to reach wider audiences and connect with like-minded activists
  • Social media has facilitated the organization of street art festivals, protests, and collaborations across borders

Street Art vs. Power Structures

Challenging Corporate Advertising and Privatization of Public Space

• Street art and graffiti often serve as a form of resistance against corporate advertising, gentrification, and the privatization of public space
  • Artists use tactics like culture jamming and subvertising to critique and parody corporate logos and slogans (Banksy's "Dismaland", Ron English's "POPaganda")
  • Graffiti can reclaim public space from corporate control and assert the right of communities to shape their own visual environment
• The ephemeral nature of street art and graffiti challenges the notion of art as a commodity and the gallery system as the primary means of art distribution
  • Street art is often created with the understanding that it may be temporary or destroyed, resisting the idea of art as a permanent, valuable object
  • By working outside of traditional art institutions, street artists challenge the gatekeeping and exclusivity of the gallery system

Critiquing Political Leaders and Institutions

• Artists use street art to critique political leaders, policies, and institutions, as seen in the work of Banksy, Shepard Fairey, and JR
  • Banksy's stencils often satirize political figures and comment on issues like war, surveillance, and consumerism
  • Fairey's "Hope" poster of Barack Obama became an iconic image of the 2008 US presidential campaign, while his "Obey" series critiques conformity and authoritarianism
  • JR's large-scale portraits and installations humanize marginalized communities and challenge stereotypes and prejudices
• Street art has been used to raise awareness about social issues like racism, poverty, climate change, and war
  • Murals and wheatpastes have been used to commemorate victims of police brutality and demand racial justice (portraits of George Floyd, Breonna Taylor)
  • Street art has been used to advocate for environmental causes and critique the fossil fuel industry (Banksy's "I Don't Believe in Global Warming" mural, Blu's "Shark Fin" mural)

Asserting Presence and Counter-Narratives

• Graffiti can be a way for marginalized communities to assert their presence and identity in the face of erasure or displacement
  • Graffiti tags and murals can mark a community's history and resilience in the face of gentrification and urban renewal
  • Indigenous artists have used graffiti to assert sovereignty and challenge colonial narratives (Chippewar's "Unceded" mural in Montréal)
• Street art and graffiti can create alternative narratives and counter-histories that challenge dominant perspectives and "official" accounts
  • Murals and wheatpastes have been used to celebrate the contributions of women, LGBTQ+ people, and people of color to art, history, and social movements
  • Street art has been used to raise awareness about forgotten or suppressed histories (Icy and Sot's "Refugees Welcome" series, Tatyana Fazlalizadeh's "Stop Telling Women to Smile" project)
• The anonymity of many street artists allows for greater freedom of expression and critique without fear of repercussion
  • Anonymous artists can create more politically charged or controversial work without fear of personal or professional consequences
  • Anonymity can also allow for greater experimentation and risk-taking in style and subject matter

Legal and Ethical Implications of Street Art

Criminalization and Disproportionate Policing

• The creation of street art and graffiti often involves the unauthorized use of public or private property, which is considered vandalism and illegal in most jurisdictions
  • Graffiti writers and street artists can face fines, arrest, and imprisonment for their work
  • The legal status of street art and graffiti varies widely by country and city, with some places having more permissive or tolerant policies than others
• The criminalization of graffiti has disproportionately affected communities of color and low-income communities, leading to increased policing and surveillance
  • Graffiti has often been associated with gang activity and urban decay, leading to "broken windows" policing strategies that target minor offenses
  • The enforcement of anti-graffiti laws has led to racial profiling and the over-policing of minority neighborhoods

Debates Around Free Speech and Property Rights

• Some argue that street art and graffiti constitute a form of free speech and should be protected under the First Amendment
  • Proponents argue that public space should be a forum for diverse voices and expressions, including dissenting or controversial ones
  • Some cities have designated "free walls" or legal graffiti zones where artists can work without fear of prosecution
• Others contend that property owners have the right to control the appearance of their buildings and that unauthorized art violates their property rights
  • Property owners may view graffiti as a form of vandalism that lowers property values and attracts crime
  • Some cities have adopted "zero tolerance" policies that require the immediate removal of any unauthorized graffiti

Commercialization and Co-optation of Street Art

• The commercialization of street art and graffiti by corporations and the art market raises questions about the co-optation and commodification of resistance
  • Some street artists have been accused of "selling out" or compromising their artistic integrity by partnering with brands or galleries
  • The popularity of street art has led to a market for prints, merchandise, and even "street art tours" that can strip the work of its original context and meaning
• Street artists and graffiti writers often face ethical dilemmas around the use of public space, the potential for their work to contribute to gentrification, and the line between art and vandalism
  • The presence of street art can attract wealthier residents and businesses to a neighborhood, leading to rising rents and displacement of long-time residents
  • Some artists have been criticized for creating work that is more decorative than political, or that fails to engage with the communities where it is placed

Challenges of Preservation and Ephemerality

• The ephemeral nature of street art and graffiti poses challenges for preservation and conservation efforts
  • Many works are intentionally temporary or are destroyed by weather, construction, or cleaning crews
  • Efforts to preserve or restore street art can be controversial, as they may go against the artist's intentions or alter the work's meaning
• The removal or buffing of street art and graffiti by authorities can erase important community histories and voices
  • The whitewashing of graffiti can be seen as a form of censorship or cultural erasure
  • Some communities have advocated for the preservation of historically significant graffiti as a form of cultural heritage

Street Art and Community Engagement

Transforming Neglected Spaces into Community Assets

• Street art and graffiti can transform neglected or abandoned spaces into vibrant community assets, as seen in projects like 5Pointz in New York City or the Wynwood Walls in Miami
  • 5Pointz was an informal graffiti mecca that attracted artists from around the world before its demolition in 2014
  • The Wynwood Walls are a series of curated murals that have helped revitalize a former industrial district in Miami
• Participatory street art projects can foster a sense of community ownership and pride, as well as provide opportunities for intergenerational and cross-cultural dialogue
  • The "Paint the Change" project in Oakland, California invited community members to help create murals addressing issues like gentrification and police violence
  • The "Mural Arts Program" in Philadelphia has created over 4,000 murals through collaborations between artists and community members

Impacts on Neighborhood Identity and Development

• The presence of street art and graffiti can signal a neighborhood's cultural vitality and diversity, but may also be seen as a sign of disorder or criminality by some
  • Street art can help create a sense of place and identity for a neighborhood, reflecting its history, culture, and aspirations
  • However, some residents may view graffiti as a symbol of urban decay or a lack of social control
• Street art festivals and mural projects can attract tourism and economic development to underserved neighborhoods, but may also contribute to gentrification and displacement
  • The "Wynwood Art District" in Miami has become a major tourist destination, with galleries, restaurants, and boutiques catering to affluent visitors
  • However, the influx of capital and attention has led to rising rents and the displacement of long-time residents and businesses

Digital Engagement and Participation

• Digital technologies and social media have enabled new forms of community engagement and participation around street art and graffiti, such as online galleries, virtual tours, and crowdsourced maps
  • The "Google Street Art Project" allows users to virtually explore street art from around the world using Google Street View technology
  • The "Street Art Cities" app allows users to upload and map street art in their own cities, creating a collaborative archive of global street art
• Unauthorized street art and graffiti can provoke public debates about the nature of public space, property rights, and the role of art in society
  • The arrest of graffiti writers or the removal of popular murals can spark public outcry and media attention
  • Street art can be a catalyst for broader discussions about urban planning, social justice, and cultural policy