3.5 Advantages and Disadvantages of Federalism

Federalism, the division of power between national and state governments, has both benefits and drawbacks. It allows for policy innovation and diverse representation but can lead to economic disparities and inconsistent regulations across states.

Federalism impacts national policy by promoting experimentation and obstructing unified action. It has played a crucial role in civil rights access, with the federal government often intervening to protect rights when states fell short.

Federalism: Advantages and Disadvantages

Benefits vs drawbacks of federalism

Top images from around the web for Benefits vs drawbacks of federalism

• 

  Federalism: How should power be structurally divided? | United States Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Federalism: Basic Structure of Government | United States Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Division of Powers | American Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Federalism: How should power be structurally divided? | United States Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Federalism: Basic Structure of Government | United States Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Benefits vs drawbacks of federalism

• 

  Federalism: How should power be structurally divided? | United States Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Federalism: Basic Structure of Government | United States Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Division of Powers | American Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Federalism: How should power be structurally divided? | United States Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Federalism: Basic Structure of Government | United States Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Benefits of federalism
  • Policy innovation
    • States can experiment with new policies and programs (marijuana legalization, healthcare reforms)
    • Successful policies can be adopted by other states or the federal government (Massachusetts' health insurance mandate)
  • Diverse representation
    • State and local governments are more responsive to the needs and preferences of their constituents
    • Allows for regional differences in culture, values, and priorities to be reflected in policy (gun laws, environmental regulations)
  • Subsidiarity: Decisions are made at the lowest possible level of government, closest to the people affected
• Drawbacks of federalism
  • Economic disparities across states
    • Differences in resources, tax bases, and economic conditions can lead to unequal provision of public services
    • Wealthy states may have better-funded education, healthcare, and infrastructure compared to poorer states (Connecticut vs Mississippi)
  • Lack of uniformity in policies and regulations
    • Varying state laws can create confusion and compliance challenges for businesses and individuals (sales tax rates, professional licensing)
    • Inconsistencies in areas such as education standards, environmental regulations, and healthcare access (Common Core, Medicaid expansion)

Power Distribution in Federalism

• Vertical power sharing: Division of authority between federal and state governments
• Horizontal power sharing: Separation of powers among executive, legislative, and judicial branches (checks and balances)
• Dual federalism: Clear division of powers between federal and state governments
• Concurrent powers: Areas where both federal and state governments have authority to act

Federalism's impact on national policy

• Promotes experimentation
  • States serve as "laboratories of democracy," testing new policies and approaches (carbon pricing, ranked-choice voting)
  • Successful state-level policies can be adopted at the national level (same-sex marriage, minimum wage increases)
• Obstructs unified action
  • Divergent state policies can hinder the implementation of cohesive national policies (immigration enforcement, climate change mitigation)
  • States may resist or challenge federal mandates, leading to conflicts and delays (Affordable Care Act, Real ID Act)
• Intergovernmental relations
  • Cooperative federalism: federal and state governments work together to address common goals (infrastructure projects, disaster response)
  • Coercive federalism: federal government uses financial incentives or penalties to influence state policies (highway funding, education grants)
  • Competitive federalism: states compete with each other to attract businesses and residents through favorable policies (tax incentives, business-friendly regulations)

Federalism and civil rights access

• Historical context
  • States' rights arguments were used to justify discrimination and resist federal civil rights legislation (Jim Crow laws, school segregation)
  • Federal government intervened to protect civil rights through legislation and court decisions
    • Civil Rights Act of 1964: prohibited discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin
    • Brown v. Board of Education (1954): declared state laws establishing racial segregation in public schools unconstitutional
• Recent legal challenges
  • Voting rights: Shelby County v. Holder (2013) weakened federal oversight of state voting laws, leading to concerns about voter suppression (voter ID laws, polling place closures)
  • LGBTQ+ rights: Obergefell v. Hodges (2015) legalized same-sex marriage nationwide, overriding state-level bans
• State control over election administration
  • States determine voter registration requirements, polling locations, and voting methods (early voting, mail-in ballots)
  • Disparities in access to voting across states, with some implementing more restrictive policies (felony disenfranchisement, voter purges)
• Federal role in protecting voting rights
  • Voting Rights Act of 1965: prohibited discriminatory voting practices and provided federal oversight (preclearance requirement)
  • Recent challenges to the VRA have led to increased state-level control and concerns about voter suppression (gerrymandering, voter ID laws)