3.3 Indian reserves and reservations

Indian reserves and reservations are lands set aside for Indigenous peoples in Canada and the US. These areas, governed by complex legal frameworks, have played a crucial role in shaping Indigenous experiences and relationships with settler governments.

The history of reserves and reservations is marked by land cessions, forced relocations, and cultural disruption. Today, these communities face challenges like underfunding and limited economic opportunities, while also serving as vital spaces for cultural preservation and self-governance.

Definition of Indian reserves

• Indian reserves are tracts of land set aside by the Canadian government for the exclusive use of First Nations bands
• Reserves are held in trust by the Crown and are not owned outright by First Nations
• The Indian Act governs the administration of reserves and the lives of First Nations people living on them

Reserves in Canada

Top images from around the web for Reserves in Canada

• 

  Liste des bandes indiennes au Québec — Wikipédia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  List of Indian reserves in Canada - WikiVisually View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  List of Indian reserves in Canada - WikiVisually View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Liste des bandes indiennes au Québec — Wikipédia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  List of Indian reserves in Canada - WikiVisually View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Reserves in Canada

• 

  Liste des bandes indiennes au Québec — Wikipédia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  List of Indian reserves in Canada - WikiVisually View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  List of Indian reserves in Canada - WikiVisually View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Liste des bandes indiennes au Québec — Wikipédia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  List of Indian reserves in Canada - WikiVisually View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• There are over 3,100 reserves in Canada, ranging in size from a few acres to over 1,000 square kilometers
• The largest reserve in Canada is the Six Nations of the Grand River reserve in Ontario, with over 25,000 residents
• Many reserves are located in remote areas, far from major population centers and economic opportunities

Reservations in the United States

• In the US, Indian reservations are lands held in trust by the federal government for Native American tribes
• There are over 300 reservations in the US, with a total land area of over 56 million acres
• The largest reservation is the Navajo Nation, which spans over 27,000 square miles across Arizona, New Mexico, and Utah

History of reserves and reservations

Pre-contact Indigenous land use

• Prior to European colonization, Indigenous peoples in North America had diverse land use practices and territorial boundaries
• Many Indigenous societies had complex systems of land stewardship, resource management, and inter-tribal diplomacy
• Indigenous land use was often based on seasonal rounds, with communities moving between different areas to access resources

Colonial era land cessions and treaties

• As European colonization expanded, Indigenous nations were pressured to cede their lands through treaties and land surrenders
• Many early treaties, such as the Royal Proclamation of 1763 in Canada, recognized Indigenous land rights and established nation-to-nation relationships
• However, later treaties often involved coercion, deception, and the forced displacement of Indigenous peoples onto smaller tracts of land

Establishment of the reserve system

• The Indian Act of 1876 in Canada formalized the reserve system and gave the federal government control over Indigenous lands and peoples
• In the US, the Indian Removal Act of 1830 and the Dawes Act of 1887 led to the forced relocation of Indigenous peoples onto reservations
• The creation of reserves and reservations was often justified as a way to "civilize" and assimilate Indigenous peoples into Euro-American society

Life on reserves and reservations

Housing and infrastructure challenges

• Many reserves and reservations face chronic underfunding and neglect, resulting in substandard housing and infrastructure
• Overcrowding, mold, and lack of basic amenities like running water and electricity are common problems
• The remoteness of many reserves also makes it difficult and expensive to build and maintain infrastructure

Economic opportunities and barriers

• Reserves and reservations often have limited economic opportunities, with high rates of unemployment and poverty
• Many communities rely on government transfers and resource extraction industries for revenue
• Barriers to economic development include lack of access to capital, limited infrastructure, and jurisdictional issues

Health and social issues

• Indigenous peoples living on reserves and reservations face significant health disparities, including higher rates of chronic diseases, mental health issues, and substance abuse
• The legacy of residential schools and other colonial policies has contributed to intergenerational trauma and social problems
• Limited access to healthcare services and cultural supports can exacerbate these challenges

Governance of reserves and reservations

Federal government jurisdiction

• In both Canada and the US, the federal government has jurisdiction over Indigenous lands and peoples
• The Indian Act in Canada and various federal laws in the US give the government control over many aspects of life on reserves and reservations
• This jurisdiction has often been used to undermine Indigenous sovereignty and self-determination

Tribal sovereignty and self-governance

• Despite federal jurisdiction, Indigenous nations have inherent rights to self-government and self-determination
• Many Indigenous communities have established their own governments, courts, and service delivery systems
• The recognition of tribal sovereignty has been a key goal of Indigenous activism and legal challenges

Role of band councils and tribal governments

• In Canada, band councils are elected under the Indian Act to govern individual First Nations reserves
• In the US, tribal governments are recognized as sovereign entities with the power to make laws and manage their own affairs
• These Indigenous governments play a crucial role in advocating for their communities and delivering essential services

Land rights and resource management

Traditional vs reserve land ownership

• Traditional Indigenous land tenure systems were often based on communal stewardship and use rights, rather than individual ownership
• The reserve system imposed a Western model of land ownership, with the Crown or federal government holding ultimate title
• This has created conflicts between traditional Indigenous land use practices and the legal and bureaucratic constraints of the reserve system

Natural resource development on reserves

• Many reserves and reservations are rich in natural resources, such as timber, minerals, and oil and gas
• The development of these resources can provide much-needed revenue for Indigenous communities, but also raises concerns about environmental impacts and the equitable sharing of benefits
• Indigenous nations have increasingly asserted their rights to control and benefit from resource development on their lands

Environmental protection and conservation

• Indigenous peoples have long been stewards of the land and have deep cultural and spiritual connections to their territories
• The reserve system has often hindered Indigenous peoples' ability to protect and conserve their lands and resources
• Many Indigenous communities are now leading efforts to protect ecosystems, preserve biodiversity, and address climate change through traditional knowledge and land management practices

Cultural identity and preservation

Role of reserves in maintaining culture

• Despite the many challenges, reserves and reservations have played a crucial role in preserving Indigenous cultures and identities
• These lands provide a space for Indigenous peoples to maintain their languages, traditions, and ways of life
• Many reserves are home to cultural centers, pow wows, and other events that celebrate and share Indigenous heritage

Language retention and revitalization efforts

• Indigenous languages are an essential part of cultural identity, but many are at risk of being lost due to the impacts of colonization and assimilation policies
• Reserves and reservations have become important sites for language revitalization efforts, such as immersion schools and adult language classes
• Indigenous-led initiatives are working to document, teach, and promote the use of traditional languages

Traditional knowledge and practices

• Reserves and reservations are also repositories of traditional knowledge and practices, such as medicinal plant use, hunting and fishing techniques, and spiritual ceremonies
• The preservation and transmission of this knowledge is vital for the cultural continuity and well-being of Indigenous communities
• Many Indigenous nations are working to protect and promote traditional knowledge through cultural education programs, elder-youth mentorship, and the documentation of oral histories

Challenges facing reserve communities

Underfunding and neglect by governments

• Despite the federal government's legal obligations to provide services and support to Indigenous communities, reserves and reservations have long been underfunded and neglected
• Chronic underfunding has led to inadequate housing, education, healthcare, and other essential services
• This neglect is rooted in the colonial legacy of racism and discrimination against Indigenous peoples

Intergenerational trauma and social issues

• The impacts of residential schools, forced relocations, and other colonial policies have created a legacy of intergenerational trauma in many Indigenous communities
• This trauma contributes to high rates of substance abuse, domestic violence, and other social problems on reserves and reservations
• Addressing these issues requires a holistic approach that recognizes the ongoing impacts of colonization and supports community-led healing and resilience

Discrimination and racism off-reserve

• Indigenous peoples living on reserves and reservations often face discrimination and racism when they leave their communities
• This can include barriers to accessing education, employment, housing, and other opportunities in mainstream society
• Systemic racism and stereotyping of Indigenous peoples perpetuate social and economic inequalities and undermine efforts to build positive relationships between Indigenous and non-Indigenous communities

Activism and resistance movements

Historical resistance to land dispossession

• Indigenous peoples have a long history of resistance to colonization and land dispossession
• In the 19th and early 20th centuries, leaders like Sitting Bull, Louis Riel, and Geronimo led armed resistance against colonial encroachment on Indigenous lands
• Other forms of resistance included legal challenges, petitions, and diplomatic efforts to assert Indigenous rights and sovereignty

Modern Indigenous rights organizations

• In the 1960s and 70s, a new wave of Indigenous activism emerged, led by organizations like the American Indian Movement (AIM) and the National Indian Brotherhood (now the Assembly of First Nations) in Canada
• These organizations fought for Indigenous rights, self-determination, and the recognition of treaty obligations
• They used a variety of tactics, including protests, occupations, and legal challenges to advance their cause

Protests and direct action strategies

• Direct action and civil disobedience have been important tools for Indigenous activists seeking to raise awareness and pressure governments to address their concerns
• Examples include the Alcatraz occupation of 1969-71, the Oka Crisis of 1990, and the Standing Rock protests against the Dakota Access Pipeline in 2016-17
• These actions have often been met with state violence and repression, but have also galvanized public support and solidarity for Indigenous struggles

Future of reserves and reservations

Calls for increased autonomy and funding

• Indigenous leaders and organizations have long called for greater autonomy and control over their lands, resources, and affairs
• This includes demands for increased funding for housing, education, healthcare, and other essential services on reserves and reservations
• Many Indigenous nations are also seeking to expand their land base and jurisdiction through land claims, treaty negotiations, and other legal avenues

Reconciliation and nation-to-nation relations

• In recent years, there has been a growing recognition of the need for reconciliation between Indigenous and non-Indigenous peoples in Canada and the US
• This includes acknowledging the historical and ongoing impacts of colonization, and working to build new relationships based on mutual respect, trust, and cooperation
• Initiatives like the Truth and Reconciliation Commission in Canada and the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) have provided frameworks for advancing reconciliation and Indigenous rights

Visions for sustainable, thriving communities

• Despite the many challenges facing reserves and reservations, Indigenous peoples have a vision for sustainable, thriving communities that are grounded in their cultural values and traditions
• This includes developing community-led initiatives in areas like renewable energy, sustainable agriculture, and cultural tourism
• It also means investing in education, healthcare, and social services that are culturally relevant and responsive to the needs of Indigenous communities
• Ultimately, the future of reserves and reservations will depend on the ability of Indigenous peoples to assert their rights, reclaim their lands and resources, and build strong, self-determining nations that can provide for the well-being of their peoples for generations to come