3.3 Tax Incidence and Burden

Tax incidence and burden are crucial concepts in public economics. They explore who really pays taxes, beyond just who's legally responsible. This topic digs into how market forces and economic behaviors determine the actual distribution of tax burdens.

Understanding tax incidence helps policymakers design fair and efficient tax systems. It reveals how taxes impact different groups, influence market behaviors, and affect overall economic well-being. This knowledge is key for creating balanced fiscal policies.

Statutory vs Economic Incidence of Taxes

Defining Tax Incidence Types

Top images from around the web for Defining Tax Incidence Types

• 

  G. Mick Smith, PhD: 03/17/11 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Tax Incidence | Macroeconomics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Reading: Tax Incidence | Macroeconomics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  G. Mick Smith, PhD: 03/17/11 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Tax Incidence | Macroeconomics View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Defining Tax Incidence Types

• 

  G. Mick Smith, PhD: 03/17/11 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Tax Incidence | Macroeconomics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Reading: Tax Incidence | Macroeconomics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  G. Mick Smith, PhD: 03/17/11 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Tax Incidence | Macroeconomics View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Statutory incidence designates the legal responsibility to pay a tax as specified by law
• Economic incidence reveals who actually bears the tax burden in practice
• Difference between statutory and economic incidence emerges from market forces and the ability of economic agents to shift the tax burden
• Tax shifting occurs when the party legally responsible for paying can pass some or all of the burden to others through price adjustments
  • Forward shifting passes tax burden to consumers via higher prices
  • Backward shifting passes burden to suppliers through lower input prices

Factors Affecting Tax Incidence

• Extent of tax shifting depends on market factors
  • Elasticity of demand and supply
  • Market structure (competitive markets, monopolies, oligopolies)
  • Time frame considered (short-term vs long-term effects)
• In competitive markets, economic incidence remains independent of whether tax is legally imposed on buyers or sellers
• Tax neutrality concept suggests efficient tax systems should not distort economic decisions
  • Aims to avoid creating excess burden beyond revenue collected
  • Minimizes interference with market mechanisms

Distribution of Tax Burden

Elasticity and Tax Burden Distribution

• Relative elasticities of demand and supply in taxed good/service market determine tax burden distribution
• Party with more inelastic demand or supply curve bears larger share of tax burden
• Tax incidence analysis examines how tax introduction affects:
  • Equilibrium price and quantity in market
  • Changes in consumer and producer surplus distribution
• Deadweight loss measures efficiency cost of taxation
  • Represents loss in total surplus due to tax-induced reduction in market activity
  • Quantifies economic inefficiency created by taxation

Measuring and Analyzing Tax Burden

• Tax burden measured in absolute terms (amount of tax paid) or relative terms (percentage of income or wealth)
• Relative measurements lead to discussions of tax system types:
  • Progressive (higher earners pay higher percentage)
  • Regressive (lower earners pay higher percentage)
  • Proportional (all pay same percentage)
• General equilibrium effects consider indirect impacts of taxes in one market on other markets
  • Changes in relative prices
  • Income effects on consumer behavior
• Long-term distributional effects of tax burden impact:
  • Savings rates (retirement accounts, emergency funds)
  • Investment levels (business expansion, stock market participation)
  • Economic growth (GDP, productivity improvements)

Factors Influencing Tax Incidence

Elasticity Concepts and Their Impact

• Price elasticity of demand measures quantity demanded responsiveness to price changes
  • Affects producers' ability to pass tax burdens to consumers
  • Example: Inelastic demand for gasoline allows for more tax burden shifting to consumers
• Price elasticity of supply measures quantity supplied responsiveness to price changes
  • Influences producers' ability to absorb tax burdens or pass to consumers
  • Example: Highly elastic supply of mass-produced goods allows producers to shift more tax burden to consumers
• Relative elasticities principle states more inelastic side of market bears larger tax burden share
  • Example: Cigarette taxes often fall heavily on consumers due to addictive nature creating inelastic demand

Market Structure and Time Considerations

• Market structure affects tax incidence by influencing firms' price and quantity adjustment abilities
  • Perfect competition: Limited individual firm influence on prices
  • Monopoly: Greater ability to pass tax burden to consumers
  • Oligopoly: Strategic interactions between firms affect tax burden distribution
• Time horizon plays crucial role in tax incidence
  • Short-run elasticities often differ from long-run elasticities
  • Example: Labor supply more elastic in long run as workers can retrain or relocate
• Mobility of production factors (labor, capital) impacts tax incidence by affecting supply elasticity
  • Highly mobile factors (financial capital) can more easily avoid tax burdens
  • Less mobile factors (specialized labor) may bear greater tax burden

Policy and Behavioral Factors

• Government regulations interact with taxes to influence incidence and economic impact
  • Price controls may prevent full passing of tax burden to consumers
  • Quantity restrictions can alter supply elasticity and tax burden distribution
• Tax salience affects behavioral responses and actual tax incidence
  • More visible taxes (sales tax) may have larger impact on consumer behavior
  • Less salient taxes (employer portion of payroll taxes) may be more easily shifted to employees
• Behavioral economics insights reveal additional factors influencing tax incidence
  • Mental accounting: How individuals categorize and prioritize different types of income and expenses
  • Loss aversion: Tendency for people to prefer avoiding losses over acquiring equivalent gains