4.3 Crito: Justice, law, and civil disobedience

Crito dives into the complex relationship between justice, law, and civil disobedience. Socrates argues for obeying laws, even unjust ones, to maintain social order. He introduces the social contract theory and emphasizes citizens' obligations to the state.

The dialogue explores when civil disobedience might be justified and the tension between individual conscience and societal duties. It raises questions about moral autonomy, civic responsibility, and the ethical implications of breaking laws for a higher purpose.

Justice and the Law in Crito

Fundamental Concepts of Justice

Top images from around the web for Fundamental Concepts of Justice

• 

  Social justice - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chapter 6: Political Theory – Politics, Power, and Purpose: An Orientation to Political Science View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Obedience and Disobedience in Plato’s Crito and the Apology: Anticipating the Democratic Turn of ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Social justice - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chapter 6: Political Theory – Politics, Power, and Purpose: An Orientation to Political Science View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Fundamental Concepts of Justice

• 

  Social justice - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chapter 6: Political Theory – Politics, Power, and Purpose: An Orientation to Political Science View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Obedience and Disobedience in Plato’s Crito and the Apology: Anticipating the Democratic Turn of ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Social justice - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chapter 6: Political Theory – Politics, Power, and Purpose: An Orientation to Political Science View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Justice governs individual conduct and societal order, intertwined with law
• Acting in accordance with virtue, even when conflicting with personal interests
• Explores relationship between justice and law
  • Questions whether laws are always just
  • Examines whether unjust laws should be obeyed
• Personifies Laws of Athens as entities with moral authority
• Emphasizes reciprocity in justice
  • Citizens owe obedience to laws
  • State provides benefits and protections in return
• Examines tension between personal loyalty and civic duty (Crito's arguments for escape)

Socratic View of Justice and Law

• Justice transcends mere law-following
• Requires alignment with moral rightness and virtue
• Presents Laws as entities demanding citizen obedience
• Explores concept of civic duty in relation to justice
• Analyzes justice in context of state-citizen relationship
• Considers long-term societal implications of just actions

Socrates' Arguments for Obeying the Law

Social Contract Theory

• Introduces implicit agreement between citizens and state
• Presents principle of tacit consent
  • Choosing to remain in Athens implies agreement to abide by its laws
• Argues disobeying law undermines societal foundations
  • Leads to social instability and chaos
• Emphasizes moral consistency in law obedience
  • Rejects selective obedience based on personal preferences
• Asserts duty to persuade state when laws are unjust
  • Favors reform over disobedience
• Explores consequences of widespread disobedience
  • Weakens state authority
  • Compromises governmental function

Citizenship Obligations

• Links acceptance of citizenship benefits to law obedience
• Stresses importance of rule of law for social stability
• Examines reciprocal nature of citizen-state relationship
• Discusses moral responsibility of citizens to uphold laws
• Considers impact of individual actions on broader society
• Analyzes role of civic virtue in maintaining just society

Justification of Civil Disobedience

Conditions for Civil Disobedience

• Examines civil disobedience as response to unjust laws
• Raises questions about moral authority of state
• Suggests exhausting legal means of persuasion before disobedience
• Explores concept of higher moral law or natural justice
  • Potential justification when positive law conflicts with ethics
• Considers consequences of civil disobedience
  • Individual impact (legal punishment, social ostracism)
  • Societal impact (social unrest, legal reform)
• Examines role of conscience in civil disobedience
  • Questions whether personal morals can override societal obligations
• Addresses civil disobedience as potential form of patriotism
  • Challenging unjust laws as civic duty

Ethical Considerations in Disobedience

• Analyzes moral implications of breaking laws
• Explores tension between legal and ethical obligations
• Discusses potential for civil disobedience to effect social change
• Examines historical examples of justified civil disobedience (Civil Rights Movement, Gandhi's Salt March)
• Considers long-term societal effects of normalized disobedience
• Evaluates role of public opinion in justifying civil disobedience

Individual Conscience vs Societal Obligations

Moral Autonomy and Civic Duty

• Explores conflict between personal morals and societal laws
• Examines Socrates' decision to accept punishment
  • Highlights clash between individual ethics and legal obligations
• Analyzes concept of moral autonomy in relation to societal expectations
• Considers role of rational deliberation in resolving internal conflicts
• Contrasts Crito's arguments of personal loyalty with broader societal obligations
• Explores tension between short-term individual interests and long-term societal stability
• Raises questions about nature of true harm and benefit
  • Suggests unjust actions harm the soul more than physical punishment

Ethical Decision-Making in Society

• Examines process of navigating conflicting moral imperatives
• Analyzes role of education in developing ethical reasoning skills
• Explores concept of moral courage in face of societal pressure
• Considers impact of cultural norms on individual moral judgments
• Discusses importance of critical thinking in evaluating laws and social norms
• Examines historical examples of individuals choosing conscience over law (Sophie Scholl, Nelson Mandela)