4.2 Market Anomalies and Limitations of EMH

Market anomalies challenge the Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH), revealing patterns that defy the idea of perfectly rational markets. These quirks, like the size effect and January effect, suggest opportunities for savvy investors to beat the market.

However, anomalies aren't foolproof. They can disappear as more people catch on, and they don't always predict future performance. Understanding these limitations helps investors make smarter choices and see the bigger picture of market behavior.

Market Anomalies vs Efficiency

Common Market Anomalies

Top images from around the web for Common Market Anomalies

• 

  APAKAH TERJADI FENOMENA JANUARY EFFECT DI BURSA EFEK INDONESIA? | Darman | Jurnal Riset ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Investor Sentiment and Size Effect View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  APAKAH TERJADI FENOMENA JANUARY EFFECT DI BURSA EFEK INDONESIA? | Darman | Jurnal Riset ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Investor Sentiment and Size Effect View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 2

Top images from around the web for Common Market Anomalies

• 

  APAKAH TERJADI FENOMENA JANUARY EFFECT DI BURSA EFEK INDONESIA? | Darman | Jurnal Riset ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Investor Sentiment and Size Effect View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  APAKAH TERJADI FENOMENA JANUARY EFFECT DI BURSA EFEK INDONESIA? | Darman | Jurnal Riset ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Investor Sentiment and Size Effect View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 2

• Size effect anomaly: Smaller-cap stocks tend to outperform larger-cap stocks over the long term (contradicts EMH assumption that market prices fully reflect all available information)
• Value effect anomaly: Stocks with low price-to-earnings (P/E) ratios or price-to-book (P/B) ratios tend to outperform growth stocks (suggests market may not always efficiently price securities)
• Momentum effect anomaly: Stocks that have performed well in the recent past tend to continue outperforming in the short term, while stocks that have performed poorly tend to continue underperforming
• January effect anomaly: Stock prices tend to rise more in January compared to other months, particularly for small-cap stocks (contradicts EMH assumption of market efficiency)
• Post-earnings announcement drift (PEAD) anomaly: Stock prices continue to drift in the direction of an earnings surprise for several weeks or months after the announcement (indicates market may not immediately incorporate all relevant information)

Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH) Assumptions

• EMH assumes all investors are rational and have access to the same information
  • In reality, investors may exhibit irrational behavior and have varying levels of information access
• EMH does not account for market frictions (transaction costs, taxes) which can affect market efficiency and the ability of prices to fully reflect all available information
• EMH assumes prices follow a random walk and future price movements are unpredictable
  • Challenged by the existence of market anomalies and success of some active investment strategies

Causes and Implications of Anomalies

Factors Contributing to Market Anomalies

• Behavioral biases contribute to the emergence and persistence of market anomalies
  • Overreaction or underreaction to news
  • Herding behavior (investors following the crowd)
  • Loss aversion (investors' tendency to avoid losses more than seeking gains)
• Market frictions prevent prices from fully reflecting all available information, leading to anomalies
  • Transaction costs
  • Taxes
  • Information asymmetry (some investors have access to more or better information than others)

Implications for Investment Decision-Making

• Existence of market anomalies suggests opportunities for investors to exploit mispricing and generate abnormal returns
• Anomalies may not persist indefinitely as market participants adapt their strategies and arbitrage opportunities diminish over time
• Investors should exercise caution when basing investment decisions on market anomalies
  • Past performance does not guarantee future results
  • Anomalies may be subject to change or disappearance
• Investors should consider their own investment objectives, risk tolerance, and time horizon before implementing strategies based on market anomalies

Limitations of the Efficient Market Hypothesis

Criticisms of EMH Assumptions

• EMH fails to explain the occurrence of market bubbles and crashes (prices can deviate significantly from fundamental values)
• EMH does not consider the role of market sentiment and investor psychology in driving short-term price movements and creating temporary inefficiencies
• EMH is overly simplistic and fails to capture the complexity of financial markets and the various factors that influence asset prices

Challenges to EMH

• Existence of market anomalies challenges EMH's assumption that prices follow a random walk and future price movements are unpredictable
• Success of some active investment strategies (value investing, momentum investing) contradicts EMH's notion of market efficiency
• Behavioral finance studies suggest investors are not always rational and can be influenced by psychological biases and heuristics

Anomalies for Investment Strategies

Alternative Investment Strategies Based on Anomalies

• Value investing: Identify and invest in undervalued stocks based on fundamental analysis (price-to-earnings ratio, price-to-book ratio) to capitalize on the value effect anomaly
• Momentum investing: Buy stocks that have performed well in the recent past and sell stocks that have performed poorly to profit from the momentum effect anomaly
• Small-cap investing: Focus on investing in smaller, less well-known companies to benefit from the size effect anomaly
• Contrarian investing: Go against prevailing market sentiment and invest in stocks or sectors that are currently out of favor (belief that market may have overreacted to negative news)

Considerations for Implementing Anomaly-Based Strategies

• Success of alternative investment strategies based on market anomalies is not guaranteed
  • Anomalies may not persist over time
  • Market conditions can change
• Investors should carefully evaluate the risks and potential rewards of alternative investment strategies
• Consider personal investment objectives, risk tolerance, and time horizon before implementing anomaly-based strategies
• Diversification remains important to manage risk, even when pursuing strategies based on market anomalies