4.4 Opening of Korea to the West

Korea's isolation policy, rooted in Confucian tradition and fear of foreign influence, shaped its interactions with the outside world for centuries. The Joseon Dynasty's strict measures limited contact, preserving Korean culture but hindering technological advancement and economic opportunities.

Western powers, driven by economic interests, made numerous attempts to establish relations with Korea. These ranged from peaceful overtures to forceful naval expeditions, gradually increasing pressure on Korea to open its borders and engage with the international community.

Origins of isolation policy

• Korea's isolation policy stemmed from centuries of Confucian tradition and a desire to maintain cultural purity
• The Joseon Dynasty implemented strict measures to limit foreign contact, shaping Korea's interactions with the outside world for generations

Reasons for seclusion

Top images from around the web for Reasons for seclusion

• 

  Confucius - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Japanese invasions of Korea (1592–1598) - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Les invasions japonaises de la Corée (1592-1598) - Japanese invasions of Korea (1592–1598 ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Confucius - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Japanese invasions of Korea (1592–1598) - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Reasons for seclusion

• 

  Confucius - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Japanese invasions of Korea (1592–1598) - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Les invasions japonaises de la Corée (1592-1598) - Japanese invasions of Korea (1592–1598 ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Confucius - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Japanese invasions of Korea (1592–1598) - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Fear of foreign ideological influence threatened Confucian social order
• Traumatic experiences with Japanese invasions in the late 16th century fostered distrust of outsiders
• Desire to maintain political autonomy and cultural identity in the face of expanding Western imperialism
• Belief that Korea was a self-sufficient "hermit kingdom" capable of thriving without external trade

Impacts on Korean society

• Limited technological advancements compared to rapidly industrializing Western nations
• Preservation of traditional Korean culture, arts, and social structures
• Reduced exposure to global trade networks and economic opportunities
• Development of a distinct national identity rooted in isolation and self-reliance

Western attempts at contact

• Western powers, driven by economic and geopolitical interests, made numerous efforts to establish diplomatic and trade relations with Korea
• These attempts ranged from peaceful overtures to forceful naval expeditions, gradually increasing pressure on Korea to open its borders

Early European expeditions

• Dutch sailor Hendrick Hamel's shipwreck and subsequent stay in Korea (1653-1666) provided early insights into the isolated kingdom
• French Catholic missionaries attempted to enter Korea in the late 18th and early 19th centuries, facing persecution and martyrdom
• British naval expeditions, including that of Captain Basil Hall in 1816, conducted limited coastal surveys but failed to establish formal contact

American diplomatic missions

• USS South America's expedition in 1853 sought to establish trade relations but was rebuffed by Korean officials
• Incident of the General Sherman in 1866 resulted in the destruction of an American merchant ship and heightened tensions
• Low-Rodgers expedition of 1871 led to a brief military confrontation known as the Shinmiyangyo, ending in a stalemate

Internal pressures for change

• Within Korea, a growing awareness of the outside world and its rapid advancements led to debates about the country's future
• Competing factions emerged, advocating for different approaches to modernization and foreign relations

Modernization advocates

• Silhak scholars promoted practical learning and selective adoption of Western technologies
• Progressive officials like Park Gyu-su argued for cautious engagement with foreign powers to strengthen Korea
• Enlightenment thinkers such as Yu Kil-chun advocated for comprehensive reforms inspired by Western models

Opposition to foreign influence

• Conservative Confucian scholars viewed Western ideas as a threat to traditional Korean values and social order
• Xenophobic sentiments fueled by historical invasions and religious persecutions reinforced isolationist policies
• Fear of losing national sovereignty to foreign powers motivated resistance to opening borders

Treaty of Ganghwa

• The Treaty of Ganghwa, signed in 1876, marked the official end of Korea's isolation policy and opened the country to foreign trade and diplomacy
• This agreement fundamentally altered Korea's international status and set the stage for further foreign involvement in Korean affairs

Negotiation process

• Japanese warships led by Kuroda Kiyotaka arrived at Ganghwa Island in 1876, demanding negotiations
• Korean negotiators, led by Shin Heon, initially resisted but ultimately conceded to Japanese demands
• Negotiations lasted for several weeks, with Japan leveraging its military superiority to secure favorable terms

Key provisions

• Recognized Korea as an independent nation, challenging China's traditional suzerainty
• Opened three Korean ports (Busan, Wonsan, and Incheon) to Japanese trade
• Granted extraterritoriality rights to Japanese citizens in Korea
• Allowed Japan to conduct coastal surveys and establish a legation in Seoul
• Permitted Korea to send diplomatic missions to Japan and adopt modern international practices

Consequences of opening

• The opening of Korea to the outside world triggered a series of rapid and profound changes in Korean society, economy, and politics
• These transformations set the stage for Korea's modernization efforts and its complex relationships with foreign powers

Economic effects

• Influx of foreign goods disrupted traditional Korean industries and crafts
• Increased trade opportunities led to the growth of port cities and emergence of a merchant class
• Introduction of modern banking systems and currency reforms (adoption of the won)
• Foreign investment in infrastructure projects (railroads, telegraphs, mines)

Social transformations

• Exposure to Western ideas challenged traditional Confucian social hierarchies
• Gradual adoption of Western-style clothing and customs among urban elites
• Establishment of modern educational institutions introduced new fields of study
• Increased mobility and urbanization as people moved to newly opened port cities

Unequal treaties era

• Following the Treaty of Ganghwa, Korea entered a period characterized by the signing of multiple unequal treaties with Western powers
• These agreements further eroded Korean sovereignty and created a complex web of foreign interests within the country

Foreign concessions

• Establishment of foreign settlements in treaty ports with their own administration and laws
• Granting of land and resource exploitation rights to foreign companies (mining concessions)
• Creation of foreign-controlled customs services to manage trade and tariffs
• Development of foreign-owned infrastructure projects (Seoul-Incheon railroad)

Extraterritoriality issues

• Foreign nationals exempt from Korean law and subject to their own country's legal system
• Establishment of foreign consular courts to handle cases involving their citizens
• Challenges to Korean sovereignty and ability to enforce laws within its own territory
• Resentment among Koreans over preferential treatment given to foreigners

Modernization efforts

• In response to increasing foreign pressure and internal recognition of the need for change, Korea embarked on a series of modernization initiatives
• These efforts aimed to strengthen the country and preserve its independence in the face of growing external threats

Military reforms

• Establishment of the Pyolgigun (Special Skills Force) in 1881 to train soldiers in modern warfare techniques
• Adoption of Western-style uniforms and weapons for select military units
• Creation of the Hullyeondae training center to modernize military education and tactics
• Attempts to reorganize the traditional military structure into a more efficient fighting force

Educational initiatives

• Founding of the Dongmunhak (English language school) in 1883 to train interpreters and diplomats
• Establishment of the Yugyeong Gongwon (Royal College) in 1886 to teach Western sciences and technologies
• Introduction of modern subjects (mathematics, physics, geography) into traditional educational curricula
• Sending of Korean students abroad to study in Japan, the United States, and Europe

Foreign advisors in Korea

• As part of its modernization efforts, Korea invited foreign experts to assist in various fields, bringing new knowledge and skills to the country
• These advisors played crucial roles in shaping Korea's modernization policies but also became entangled in international power struggles

Role of Western experts

• American military advisors like General William McEntyre Dye helped train and modernize Korean armed forces
• German diplomat Paul Georg von Möllendorff served as a foreign policy advisor and customs official
• American diplomat Owen Nickerson Denny advised on foreign relations and internal reforms
• British customs official John McLeavy Brown oversaw Korea's customs service and financial reforms

Japanese influence

• Increasing number of Japanese advisors in Korean government after the Sino-Japanese War (1894-1895)
• Japanese military instructors played a significant role in training and equipping Korean forces
• Japanese financial advisors gained control over Korea's economy, particularly after the Russo-Japanese War (1904-1905)
• Gradual displacement of Western advisors by Japanese counterparts as Japan's influence in Korea grew

Domestic reactions

• The opening of Korea and subsequent modernization efforts elicited diverse responses from different segments of Korean society
• These reactions ranged from enthusiastic support to fierce opposition, reflecting the complex social and political dynamics of the time

Conservative resistance

• Confucian scholars and officials viewed Western influences as a threat to traditional Korean values and social order
• Peasant uprisings (Donghak Rebellion) against foreign encroachment and domestic corruption
• Opposition to Christian missionaries and their perceived undermining of Korean customs and beliefs
• Resistance to land reforms and changes in traditional agricultural practices

Progressive support

• Emergence of the Gaehwapa (Enlightenment Party) advocating for comprehensive modernization and openness to the West
• Support for educational reforms and the adoption of Western scientific and technological knowledge
• Advocacy for constitutional monarchy and political reforms inspired by Western models
• Promotion of modern industries and infrastructure development to strengthen Korea's economy

International power dynamics

• The opening of Korea placed the country at the center of a complex web of international rivalries and power struggles
• Major powers sought to exert influence over Korea, viewing it as a strategic foothold in East Asia

China vs Japan in Korea

• Erosion of China's traditional suzerainty over Korea following the Treaty of Ganghwa
• Sino-Japanese rivalry intensified, culminating in the First Sino-Japanese War (1894-1895)
• Japan's victory in 1895 effectively ended Chinese influence in Korea
• Assassination of Queen Min (1895) by Japanese agents marked a turning point in Korea-Japan relations

Western powers' interests

• Russia sought warm-water ports and economic concessions in Korea
• United States pursued trade opportunities and missionary activities
• Britain aimed to counter Russian expansion and protect its commercial interests
• France and Germany sought to establish their presence in the region through trade and diplomacy

Cultural exchange

• The opening of Korea facilitated unprecedented levels of cultural exchange between Korea and the outside world
• This exchange brought new ideas, technologies, and beliefs that profoundly impacted Korean society

Introduction of Christianity

• Protestant missionaries established schools, hospitals, and churches throughout Korea
• Translation and distribution of the Bible in Korean language (Hangeul)
• Growth of Christian communities and their role in social reform movements
• Tensions between Christian teachings and traditional Korean religious practices (Buddhism, Confucianism, shamanism)

Western technology adoption

• Introduction of modern printing presses and the growth of newspapers and publications
• Adoption of Western-style architecture in urban areas (brick buildings, Western-style houses)
• Importation of modern transportation technologies (steamships, railroads, streetcars)
• Establishment of modern communication systems (telegraph, telephone)

Long-term implications

• The opening of Korea to the West set in motion a series of events that would shape the country's future for generations to come
• The legacy of this period continues to influence modern Korea's place in the global community

Path to colonization

• Weakening of Korea's ability to maintain independence in the face of foreign pressures
• Intensification of Japanese influence leading to the protectorate status in 1905
• Annexation of Korea by Japan in 1910, marking the beginning of colonial rule
• Long-lasting impact of colonial experience on Korean national identity and post-liberation development

Foundations of modern Korea

• Emergence of Korean nationalism as a response to foreign encroachment and modernization
• Development of modern educational institutions that would shape future Korean leaders
• Exposure to Western political ideas influencing post-liberation political structures
• Economic transformations setting the stage for Korea's rapid industrialization in the latter half of the 20th century