4.2 Patents and trade secrets

Patents and trade secrets are crucial forms of intellectual property protection in the business world. They allow inventors and companies to safeguard their innovations, encouraging creativity and investment in research and development.

However, these protections also raise ethical questions about balancing innovation incentives with public access to knowledge. In the digital age, new challenges emerge around software patents, cybersecurity threats to trade secrets, and the rapid pace of technological change.

Patents overview

• Patents are a form of intellectual property protection granted by governments to inventors
• Provide exclusive rights to make, use, and sell an invention for a limited period of time (typically 20 years from filing date)
• Encourage innovation by allowing inventors to profit from their creations and prevent others from copying them
• In exchange for patent protection, inventors must publicly disclose details of their invention which promotes sharing of knowledge

Patent requirements

Top images from around the web for Patent requirements

• 

  Putting It Together: Ethics in Business | Principles of Management View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Novelty and non-obviousness in Canadian patent law - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Core Values and Ethics | Flickr - Photo Sharing! View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Putting It Together: Ethics in Business | Principles of Management View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Novelty and non-obviousness in Canadian patent law - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Patent requirements

• 

  Putting It Together: Ethics in Business | Principles of Management View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Novelty and non-obviousness in Canadian patent law - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Core Values and Ethics | Flickr - Photo Sharing! View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Putting It Together: Ethics in Business | Principles of Management View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Novelty and non-obviousness in Canadian patent law - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Invention must be novel (new and not previously known or used by others)
• Non-obvious (not an obvious improvement or modification of existing technology that someone skilled in the field could easily come up with)
• Useful (has a practical application and is not just a theory or idea)
• Patentable subject matter (falls into one of the categories eligible for patent protection such as machines, manufactured items, processes, or compositions of matter)

Patent application process

• Inventor files a patent application with the patent office which includes a detailed description of the invention, drawings, and claims defining the scope of protection
• Patent examiner reviews the application to ensure it meets all requirements and searches for prior art (existing patents, publications, or public knowledge) that may invalidate the claims
• If approved, the patent is granted and published in the official gazette
• Process can take several years and often involves back-and-forth communication between the inventor and patent office to refine the application

Patent rights and protections

• Patent holder has the exclusive right to make, use, sell, and import the patented invention for the duration of the patent term
• Can license or sell the patent rights to others
• Can sue for infringement if someone makes, uses, or sells the patented invention without permission
• Limited exceptions for research, prior use, or compulsory licensing in some cases

Patent infringement consequences

• Patent holder can sue for an injunction to stop the infringing activity
• Seek damages for lost profits or reasonable royalties
• In some cases, infringer may have to pay enhanced damages (up to 3 times) if infringement was willful
• Infringer may also have to pay patent holder's attorney fees in exceptional cases

Famous patent cases

• Wright brothers' patent on the flying machine which they defended against Glenn Curtiss and others in early aviation
• Alexander Graham Bell's telephone patent that he used to establish AT&T's monopoly
• Apple v. Samsung smartphone patent battles over features like slide-to-unlock and app icon layouts
• Polaroid v. Kodak instant camera patent dispute resulting in nearly $1 billion award and Kodak's exit from the instant camera market

Trade secrets overview

• A trade secret is confidential business information that provides a competitive advantage
• Can include formulas, patterns, methods, techniques, processes, or compilations of information not generally known or reasonably ascertainable
• Protected by keeping the information secret and taking reasonable measures to maintain secrecy (non-disclosure agreements, security measures, limited access)
• No formal registration process or expiration date like patents, but protection can be lost if secret is publicly disclosed

Trade secret qualifications

• Must have independent economic value from not being generally known to or readily ascertainable by others who could obtain economic value from its disclosure or use
• Requires reasonable efforts to maintain secrecy such as confidentiality agreements, employee training, security measures, and restricted access
• Examples include customer lists, manufacturing processes, business plans, and software algorithms

Trade secret protections

• Protected against misappropriation by others through improper means such as theft, bribery, misrepresentation, breach of duty, or espionage
• Owner can sue for injunction to prevent further disclosure or use of the trade secret
• Seek damages for actual losses and unjust enrichment or a reasonable royalty
• In some cases, exemplary damages and attorney fees may be awarded for willful and malicious misappropriation

Trade secret misappropriation

• Acquiring a trade secret through improper means like theft, bribery, misrepresentation, or espionage
• Disclosing or using a trade secret without consent when it was acquired through improper means or under circumstances giving rise to a duty to maintain secrecy
• Disclosing or using a trade secret with knowledge that it was acquired through improper means or under circumstances giving rise to a duty to maintain secrecy

Famous trade secret cases

• DuPont v. Christopher industrial espionage case where aerial photographs of a plant under construction were ruled an improper means of obtaining trade secrets
• Waymo v. Uber self-driving car trade secrets case resulting in $245 million settlement and restrictions on Uber's use of Waymo technology
• Coca-Cola trade secret formula kept in a vault and known to only a handful of employees
• KFC's secret blend of 11 herbs and spices protected as a trade secret for decades

Patents vs trade secrets

• Both patents and trade secrets are forms of intellectual property protection for inventions and business information
• Provide competitive advantages and legal remedies against unauthorized use by others
• Key considerations include the nature of the invention, likelihood of independent discovery, and business strategy

Similarities in protections

• Provide exclusivity and competitive advantages
• Allow legal action against infringement or misappropriation
• Require documentation and reasonable efforts to maintain protection
• Can be licensed or sold to others

Key differences

• Patents require public disclosure while trade secrets must be kept confidential
• Patents have a fixed term (20 years) while trade secrets can last indefinitely if kept secret
• Patents provide stronger protection against independent discovery or reverse engineering
• Trade secrets have no formal registration process or maintenance fees
• Patents are more expensive to obtain and maintain than trade secrets

When to choose patents

• Invention can be easily reverse engineered or independently discovered
• Invention has a long commercial lifespan and will be difficult to keep secret
• Having a patent will attract investors or customers
• Want to establish a strong market position and deter competitors
• Invention is a physical product rather than a process or formula

When to choose trade secrets

• Invention is a process, method, or formula that can be kept secret
• Invention has a short commercial lifespan or will be quickly superseded
• Cost of patenting is too high relative to the value of the invention
• Want to avoid disclosing the details of the invention to competitors
• Invention is difficult to reverse engineer or independently discover

Ethical considerations

• Intellectual property protections like patents and trade secrets have significant ethical implications for innovation, competition, and society
• Need to balance the interests of inventors, companies, and the public in promoting progress and access to knowledge
• Digital technologies raise new challenges for patent and trade secret systems

Promoting innovation

• Patents and trade secrets provide incentives for research and development by allowing inventors to profit from their creations
• Encourage public disclosure of new inventions and sharing of knowledge to spur further innovation
• Temporary monopolies granted by patents may be necessary to recoup R&D investments

Stifling competition

• Overly broad or trivial patents can stifle competition and innovation by blocking others from using basic building blocks
• Patent thickets and trolls can use patents to extract royalties without contributing to innovation
• Trade secrets can create barriers to entry and limit consumer choice

Protecting intellectual property

• Intellectual property is a form of property that should be protected from theft or unauthorized use
• Inventors and companies have a right to profit from their creations and intellectual labor
• Intellectual property protections are necessary to encourage innovation and creativity

Balancing interests of inventors and public

• Need to balance incentives for innovation with public access to knowledge and technologies
• Patent terms and scope should be limited to avoid excessive monopolies
• Exceptions for research, education, and public health may be necessary
• Compulsory licensing can ensure access to essential technologies

International patent and trade secret issues

• Differences in national patent and trade secret laws can create challenges for global businesses
• Need for international harmonization and cooperation to ensure consistent protections
• Concerns about IP theft and forced technology transfers in some countries
• Balancing IP protections with technology transfer and development in less developed countries

Digital age challenges

• Digital technologies like software, AI, and biotech raise new challenges for patent and trade secret systems
• Rapid pace of innovation and global distribution of digital products create enforcement difficulties
• Cybersecurity threats and ease of copying increase risks of trade secret theft
• Ethical debates around patenting software, genes, and other digital inventions

Rise of digital inventions

• Software, algorithms, and digital technologies are increasingly the subject of patent applications
• Challenges in applying traditional patent doctrines to digital inventions (obviousness, enablement, etc.)
• Concerns about overbroad software patents stifling innovation and competition
• Open source software as an alternative model for promoting innovation and collaboration

Software patents debate

• Debate over whether software should be patentable subject matter or protected by copyright
• Critics argue software patents are often trivial, overbroad, and used for trolling
• Defenders argue software patents are necessary to protect investments and encourage innovation
• Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank case raised the bar for software patent eligibility

Protecting trade secrets in digital era

• Ease of copying and distributing digital information makes it harder to protect trade secrets
• Need for robust cybersecurity measures, access controls, and employee training
• Use of digital rights management (DRM), encryption, and blockchain to secure trade secrets
• Challenges of enforcing trade secret rights across borders and against anonymous infringers

Cybersecurity and trade secrets

• Cyber attacks and data breaches are a growing threat to trade secrets
• Need for proactive cybersecurity measures and incident response plans
• Employee training and background checks to prevent insider threats
• Balancing security with employee mobility and open innovation partnerships

Ethical dilemmas in digital patents and trade secrets

• Patenting of software, AI, and digital technologies raises ethical questions about scope of protection
• Concerns about impact on open source software, interoperability, and user freedoms
• Trade secrets in digital products can limit transparency, accountability, and consumer choice
• Balancing IP protections with privacy, free speech, and other human rights in digital age