4.4 Post-quantum cryptography

Public key cryptography faces a major threat from quantum computing. Current systems like RSA could be broken by quantum algorithms, potentially compromising data security. This has led to the development of post-quantum cryptography.

Post-quantum cryptography aims to create algorithms resistant to both classical and quantum attacks. Approaches include lattice-based, hash-based, and code-based systems. These new methods are crucial for maintaining long-term data security in the quantum era.

Quantum Computing's Impact on Security

Quantum Computing Fundamentals

Top images from around the web for Quantum Computing Fundamentals

• 

  Quantum Computing View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Quantum Computing View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Quantum Computing View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Quantum Computing View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Quantum Computing View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Quantum Computing Fundamentals

• 

  Quantum Computing View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Quantum Computing View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Quantum Computing View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Quantum Computing View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Quantum Computing View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Quantum computing leverages quantum mechanical phenomena performing computations exponentially faster than classical computers for certain problems
• Utilizes quantum bits (qubits) which can exist in superposition of states (0 and 1 simultaneously)
• Exploits quantum entanglement allowing qubits to be correlated in ways impossible for classical bits
• Quantum parallelism enables simultaneous operations on multiple states

Quantum Algorithms Threatening Cryptography

• Shor's algorithm efficiently factors large numbers and computes discrete logarithms
  • Potentially breaks widely used public-key cryptosystems (RSA, ECC)
  • Solves integer factorization in polynomial time compared to exponential time for classical computers
• Grover's algorithm provides quadratic speedup for unstructured search problems
  • Weakens symmetric cryptography by reducing effective key size
  • Searches an unsorted database of N items in approximately √N steps instead of N steps classically

Implications for Cryptographic Security

• Advent of large-scale quantum computers could render many current cryptographic systems obsolete
• Timeline for practical large-scale quantum computers remains uncertain
  • Estimates range from 5-20 years for cryptographically relevant quantum computers
• Cryptographic systems need preparation well in advance due to long-term sensitivity of some data
  • (Medical records, government classified information)
• Development of quantum-resistant alternatives (post-quantum cryptography) becomes crucial
  • Based on mathematical problems believed hard for both classical and quantum computers

Principles of Post-Quantum Cryptography

Lattice-based Cryptography

• Relies on hardness of certain lattice problems
  • Shortest Vector Problem (SVP) finding shortest non-zero vector in a lattice
  • Closest Vector Problem (CVP) finding closest lattice point to a given point
• Offers efficient performance with relatively small key sizes
• Examples include NTRU (encryption) and Falcon (digital signatures)

Hash-based Signatures

• Utilizes security of cryptographic hash functions to create quantum-resistant digital signatures
• Builds upon Merkle signature scheme
• Provides strong security guarantees with well-understood security reductions
• Examples include XMSS (eXtended Merkle Signature Scheme) and SPHINCS+

Code-based and Multivariate Cryptography

• Code-based cryptography employs error-correcting codes to construct cryptosystems
  • Security based on difficulty of decoding general linear codes
  • Example McEliece cryptosystem using Goppa codes
• Multivariate cryptography uses systems of multivariate polynomial equations over finite fields
  • Security derived from difficulty of solving such systems
  • Examples include Rainbow and HFEv- signature schemes

Isogeny-based and Symmetric-key Cryptography

• Isogeny-based cryptography leverages complexity of finding isogenies between elliptic curves
  • Creates quantum-resistant key exchange protocols
  • Example SIKE (Supersingular Isogeny Key Encapsulation)
• Symmetric-key algorithms generally considered post-quantum secure with sufficiently large key sizes
  • May require larger keys or block sizes for quantum resistance
  • Examples AES-256, ChaCha20 with 256-bit keys

Security and Performance of Post-Quantum Schemes

Security Evaluation Criteria

• Analyze resistance to both classical and quantum attacks
  • Consider potential advances in quantum algorithms
• Assess computational complexity of underlying mathematical problems
• Evaluate security reductions and formal proofs where available
• Examine history of cryptanalysis and resistance to known attack techniques

Performance Metrics and Trade-offs

• Key size impacts storage and transmission requirements
  • Lattice-based schemes often have larger keys than current public-key systems
• Ciphertext/signature size affects communication overhead
  • Code-based systems typically have larger ciphertexts
• Encryption/decryption speed crucial for real-time applications
  • Hash-based signatures generally offer fast verification but slower signing
• Computational requirements determine suitability for different devices
  • Resource-constrained environments (IoT devices) may struggle with some schemes

Comparative Analysis of Schemes

• Lattice-based schemes offer efficient performance but may have larger key or ciphertext sizes
• Hash-based signatures provide strong security guarantees but may have limitations in signature count
• Code-based systems typically have fast encryption/decryption but larger key sizes
• Multivariate schemes often have small signatures but large public keys
• Isogeny-based schemes offer compact keys but may have slower performance
• Selection involves trade-offs between security, performance, and practical considerations
  • (Network bandwidth, storage capacity, processing power)

Challenges and Future of Post-Quantum Cryptography

Standardization and Adoption Processes

• NIST's Post-Quantum Cryptography Standardization process crucial for establishing widely accepted algorithms
  • Multiple rounds of evaluation and selection
  • Considers security, performance, and implementation aspects
• Industry consortia and standards bodies (IETF, IEEE) working on integrating PQC into protocols
• Backward compatibility and transition strategies essential for integrating into existing systems
  • Quantum-safe hybrid schemes combining classical and post-quantum algorithms
  • Provides potential transition path maintaining security during adoption period

Implementation and Deployment Challenges

• Side-channel attacks and implementation security critical for practical post-quantum cryptosystems
  • Timing attacks, power analysis, fault injection
• Increased key sizes and computational resources pose challenges for resource-constrained devices
  • (IoT sensors, smart cards)
• High-performance applications may require optimized implementations
  • Hardware acceleration, efficient software libraries
• Education and training of cryptography professionals and developers essential
  • Ensure proper understanding and secure implementation of post-quantum techniques

Ongoing Research and Future Directions

• Continuous evaluation of post-quantum schemes against emerging quantum algorithms
  • Potential updates to cryptographic standards as research progresses
• Exploration of new mathematical foundations for quantum-resistant cryptography
  • (Supersingular isogenies, newer lattice problems)
• Development of more efficient implementations and optimizations
  • Reducing key sizes, improving performance on various platforms
• Investigation of post-quantum protocols for specific applications
  • (Secure messaging, blockchain, cloud computing)