5.3 Access Control Models and Implementation

Access control models are crucial for securing operating systems and data. They determine who can access what resources and under what conditions. From discretionary to mandatory, role-based to attribute-based, each model offers unique benefits and trade-offs in balancing security and usability.

Implementing access control involves using mechanisms like access control lists and capability-based security. Best practices include choosing the right model, regular audits, and applying principles like least privilege and separation of duties. These strategies help create a robust defense against unauthorized access and potential security breaches.

Access Control Models

Discretionary and Mandatory Access Control

Top images from around the web for Discretionary and Mandatory Access Control

• 

  A beginner's guide to Linux permissions | Opensource.com View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Information Security Principles View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Blueprint for Security in 2013 | Black Swan Security View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  A beginner's guide to Linux permissions | Opensource.com View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Information Security Principles View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Discretionary and Mandatory Access Control

• 

  A beginner's guide to Linux permissions | Opensource.com View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Information Security Principles View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Blueprint for Security in 2013 | Black Swan Security View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  A beginner's guide to Linux permissions | Opensource.com View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Information Security Principles View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Discretionary Access Control (DAC) allows resource owners to determine access permissions
  • Users have full control over objects they own and can grant access to others
  • Commonly used in operating systems (Windows, Unix)
  • Provides flexibility but can lead to security vulnerabilities if users make poor decisions
• Mandatory Access Control (MAC) enforces system-wide security policies
  • Access decisions made by system administrators, not individual users
  • Based on security clearances and object classifications
  • Used in high-security environments (military, government)
  • Provides stronger security but less flexibility than DAC
• DAC and MAC can be combined in some systems for balanced security and usability

Role-Based and Attribute-Based Access Control

• Role-Based Access Control (RBAC) assigns permissions based on user roles
  • Users are assigned roles, and roles are assigned permissions
  • Simplifies access management in large organizations
  • Supports principle of least privilege by limiting access to role requirements
  • Can be hierarchical, with higher-level roles inheriting permissions from lower levels
• Attribute-Based Access Control (ABAC) uses attributes to determine access
  • Considers multiple factors (user attributes, resource attributes, environmental conditions)
  • Offers fine-grained access control and dynamic decision-making
  • Can adapt to changing conditions in real-time
  • More complex to implement and manage than other models

Access Control Implementation

Access Control Lists and Capability-Based Security

• Access Control Lists (ACLs) specify permissions for each object
  • List of users or groups and their allowed actions (read, write, execute)
  • Commonly used in file systems and network devices
  • Easy to understand and implement
  • Can become complex to manage for large systems with many objects
• Capability-based security uses unforgeable tokens to grant access
  • Capabilities are like keys that allow specific actions on objects
  • Provides better protection against certain types of attacks (confused deputy problem)
  • Can be more efficient than ACLs for systems with many objects
  • Less widely adopted than ACLs in mainstream operating systems

Implementation Considerations and Best Practices

• Choose appropriate access control model based on system requirements and security needs
• Implement access controls at multiple levels (network, application, database)
• Regularly audit and review access controls to ensure they remain effective
• Use automated tools to manage and enforce access control policies
• Implement strong authentication mechanisms to support access control
• Consider performance impact of access control mechanisms, especially for large-scale systems
• Train users and administrators on proper use of access control systems

Access Control Principles

Principle of Least Privilege

• Grant users only the minimum permissions necessary to perform their tasks
  • Reduces potential damage from accidents, errors, or malicious actions
  • Limits the attack surface available to adversaries
  • Can be implemented through RBAC or fine-grained permission systems
• Implement time-based access control to further restrict privileges
  • Grant elevated permissions only for the duration needed (just-in-time access)
  • Automatically revoke unnecessary permissions after task completion
• Regularly review and adjust user privileges to maintain least privilege
  • Conduct periodic access audits to identify and remove unnecessary permissions
  • Implement processes for requesting and approving privilege changes

Separation of Duties and Additional Security Measures

• Separation of duties divides critical tasks among multiple users
  • Prevents single points of failure in security-sensitive operations
  • Reduces risk of fraud, errors, and malicious actions
  • Can be static (permanent role separation) or dynamic (task-based separation)
• Implement job rotation to enhance separation of duties
  • Periodically reassign responsibilities among qualified staff
  • Helps detect and prevent long-term fraudulent activities
• Use the two-person rule for highly sensitive operations
  • Require two authorized individuals to complete critical actions
  • Commonly used in military and financial sectors (nuclear launch codes, large financial transactions)
• Combine access control principles with other security measures
  • Implement strong authentication (multi-factor authentication)
  • Use encryption to protect sensitive data at rest and in transit
  • Maintain detailed logs of access attempts and privilege changes for auditing purposes