5.6 Background extinction rates

Background extinction is a natural process of species loss occurring gradually over time. It's crucial for understanding long-term biodiversity patterns and evolutionary processes in Earth's ecosystems. This concept helps biogeographers analyze species turnover rates and distinguish between natural and human-caused extinctions.

Measuring background extinction involves analyzing fossil records and using molecular clock methods. Factors like environmental changes, competition, and genetic drift influence these rates. Historical patterns provide context for assessing current biodiversity trends and human impacts on modern ecosystems.

Definition of background extinction

• Background extinction refers to the natural, ongoing process of species loss occurring gradually over time in Earth's ecosystems
• This concept plays a crucial role in understanding long-term biodiversity patterns and evolutionary processes in World Biogeography
• Distinguishing background extinction from mass extinction events helps biogeographers analyze species turnover rates and ecosystem dynamics

Natural vs anthropogenic extinction

Top images from around the web for Natural vs anthropogenic extinction

• 

  Big 5 Mass Extinctions Poster by BudCharles on DeviantArt View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  ECOLOGY View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Charting Earth’s (Many) Mass Extinctions — Blog of the Long Now View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Big 5 Mass Extinctions Poster by BudCharles on DeviantArt View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  ECOLOGY View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Natural vs anthropogenic extinction

• 

  Big 5 Mass Extinctions Poster by BudCharles on DeviantArt View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  ECOLOGY View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Charting Earth’s (Many) Mass Extinctions — Blog of the Long Now View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Big 5 Mass Extinctions Poster by BudCharles on DeviantArt View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  ECOLOGY View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Natural extinction results from evolutionary processes and environmental changes without human influence
• Occurs due to factors like habitat shifts, resource competition, and genetic drift
• Anthropogenic extinction stems from human activities (deforestation, pollution, overhunting)
• Rate of anthropogenic extinction significantly higher than natural background rates

Baseline extinction rates

• Represent the expected number of species going extinct over a given time period under normal conditions
• Typically measured in extinctions per million species-years (E/MSY)
• Vary across different taxonomic groups and ecosystems (marine invertebrates, terrestrial plants)
• Serve as a reference point for comparing current extinction rates to historical patterns

Measurement of background extinction

• Quantifying background extinction rates involves analyzing long-term trends in species diversity
• Biogeographers use multiple methods to estimate historical extinction rates across different ecosystems
• Understanding these measurement techniques is essential for assessing current biodiversity loss in a historical context

Fossil record analysis

• Examines preserved remains or traces of organisms to track species appearances and disappearances
• Utilizes stratigraphic ranges to determine extinction timing and duration
• Accounts for preservation biases and incomplete fossil records
• Provides insights into extinction patterns across geological time scales (Paleozoic, Mesozoic eras)

Molecular clock methods

• Uses genetic differences between species to estimate divergence times and extinction events
• Based on the assumption of relatively constant mutation rates over time
• Calibrated using fossil evidence and known geological events
• Complements fossil record analysis, especially for groups with poor fossil preservation (soft-bodied organisms)

Factors influencing background extinction

• Multiple interacting factors contribute to the natural extinction of species over time
• Understanding these factors helps biogeographers interpret past and present extinction patterns
• Provides context for assessing human impacts on current extinction rates

Environmental changes

• Gradual shifts in climate and habitat conditions drive species adaptations or extinctions
• Includes changes in temperature, precipitation patterns, and sea level fluctuations
• Geological processes like plate tectonics alter landmasses and create new ecological niches
• Volcanic activity and asteroid impacts can cause rapid environmental changes leading to extinctions

Competition between species

• Interspecific competition for limited resources can lead to extinction of less fit species
• Invasive species introductions disrupt existing ecological relationships
• Coevolution between predators and prey influences extinction rates in food webs
• Niche overlap and resource partitioning affect species survival in ecosystems

Genetic drift

• Random changes in allele frequencies within small populations can lead to loss of genetic diversity
• Increases vulnerability to environmental changes and disease outbreaks
• Bottleneck events reduce population size, accelerating genetic drift effects
• Inbreeding depression in small populations decreases fitness and survival rates

Historical background extinction rates

• Examining past extinction rates provides context for understanding current biodiversity trends
• Biogeographers use this information to assess the impact of human activities on modern ecosystems
• Helps identify patterns and cycles in species turnover across geological time scales

Phanerozoic eon patterns

• Covers the last 541 million years of Earth's history, characterized by abundant fossil evidence
• Background extinction rates fluctuate over time, influenced by global environmental conditions
• Generally lower rates during periods of stable climate and high biodiversity (Carboniferous period)
• Higher rates during times of significant environmental change (end-Permian transition)

Mass extinctions vs background extinction

• Mass extinctions involve rapid, widespread loss of species across multiple taxonomic groups
• Occur infrequently, with five major events recognized in Earth's history (end-Ordovician, Late Devonian)
• Background extinction represents the normal, ongoing process of species loss between mass extinctions
• Recovery periods after mass extinctions often show elevated background extinction rates

Modern background extinction rates

• Current extinction rates are significantly higher than historical background levels
• Understanding modern rates is crucial for assessing human impact on global biodiversity
• Provides context for conservation efforts and ecosystem management strategies

Pre-industrial vs current rates

• Pre-industrial rates estimated at 0.1-1 extinctions per million species-years (E/MSY)
• Current rates estimated to be 100-1000 times higher than pre-industrial levels
• Acceleration began with the Industrial Revolution and intensified in the 20th century
• Varies across taxonomic groups, with some (amphibians, reef-building corals) experiencing higher rates

Human impact on extinction rates

• Habitat destruction through deforestation and urbanization reduces available ecosystems
• Climate change alters temperature and precipitation patterns, affecting species distributions
• Overexploitation of natural resources depletes populations of targeted species
• Pollution and introduction of invasive species disrupt ecological balances

Importance in biodiversity studies

• Background extinction rates provide a baseline for assessing current biodiversity trends
• Essential for developing effective conservation strategies and policy recommendations
• Helps predict future ecosystem changes and potential cascading effects of species loss

Ecosystem stability indicators

• Stable background extinction rates often correlate with resilient, diverse ecosystems
• Sudden increases in extinction rates may signal impending ecosystem collapse
• Used to assess the health and functioning of different biomes (tropical rainforests, coral reefs)
• Helps identify keystone species and their role in maintaining ecosystem stability

Conservation implications

• Informs prioritization of conservation efforts for vulnerable species and habitats
• Guides restoration ecology practices to enhance ecosystem resilience
• Influences policy decisions on protected area designations and management
• Supports development of sustainable resource use strategies to mitigate human impacts

Case studies of background extinction

• Examining specific examples of background extinction provides insights into long-term evolutionary processes
• Helps biogeographers understand how different taxonomic groups respond to environmental changes
• Informs predictions about future extinction patterns in the face of global climate change

Marine invertebrates

• Brachiopods show declining diversity since the Permian period, with background extinction driving the trend
• Ammonites experienced fluctuating extinction rates throughout the Mesozoic era
• Trilobites underwent gradual extinction over millions of years before the end-Permian mass extinction
• Modern coral species face elevated extinction risks due to ocean acidification and warming

Terrestrial vertebrates

• Mammalian megafauna experienced increased background extinction rates during the Pleistocene
• Avian lineages show varying extinction rates across different families (ratites, passerines)
• Amphibian species currently face higher-than-background extinction rates due to habitat loss and disease
• Non-avian dinosaurs exhibited relatively stable background extinction rates before the K-Pg extinction event

Future projections

• Predicting future background extinction rates is crucial for long-term biodiversity conservation
• Biogeographers use models incorporating various environmental and anthropogenic factors
• Projections inform policy decisions and guide adaptive management strategies

Climate change effects

• Rising temperatures may increase extinction rates in temperature-sensitive species (polar bears, coral reefs)
• Shifting precipitation patterns could alter habitat suitability for many plant and animal species
• Sea level rise threatens coastal and island ecosystems, potentially increasing extinction rates
• Extreme weather events may cause local extinctions and disrupt ecosystem functioning

Habitat loss considerations

• Continued deforestation in biodiversity hotspots could dramatically increase extinction rates
• Fragmentation of habitats reduces gene flow and increases vulnerability to extinction
• Urbanization and agricultural expansion limit available habitat for many species
• Marine habitat degradation, including coral reef destruction, may lead to elevated extinction rates

Challenges in estimating rates

• Accurately determining background extinction rates presents several methodological difficulties
• Understanding these challenges is essential for interpreting extinction rate estimates and their implications
• Biogeographers continually refine techniques to improve the accuracy of extinction rate calculations

Incomplete fossil record

• Preservation biases favor hard-bodied organisms, underrepresenting soft-bodied species
• Gaps in the fossil record create uncertainties in estimating extinction timing and duration
• Varying fossil quality across different time periods and geographic regions affects rate calculations
• Taphonomic processes influence the preservation and discovery of fossil specimens

Taxonomic resolution issues

• Difficulties in distinguishing between closely related species in the fossil record
• Cryptic species complexes may lead to underestimation of true biodiversity
• Changes in taxonomic classification over time affect historical extinction rate comparisons
• Molecular data sometimes conflicts with morphological classifications, complicating rate estimates

Background extinction vs speciation

• The balance between extinction and speciation rates determines overall biodiversity trends
• Understanding this relationship is crucial for assessing long-term ecosystem dynamics
• Provides insights into the resilience and adaptability of different taxonomic groups

Equilibrium in biodiversity

• Dynamic balance between extinction and speciation maintains relatively stable species richness
• Periods of high speciation rates often coincide with elevated background extinction rates
• Adaptive radiations can temporarily offset background extinction in certain lineages
• Disturbances to this equilibrium can lead to significant shifts in ecosystem composition

Turnover rates in ecosystems

• Measures the rate at which species are replaced by new ones in a given ecosystem
• Varies across different biomes and taxonomic groups (tropical vs temperate forests)
• Influenced by factors such as environmental stability and resource availability
• High turnover rates can mask underlying extinction trends in biodiversity assessments