5.3 Intellectual Property Infringement and Remedies

Intellectual property infringement can seriously impact businesses and creators. From trademark confusion to patent violations, understanding the various forms of infringement is crucial. This section breaks down the legal tests used to determine infringement and outlines potential remedies.

Protecting intellectual property rights requires vigilance and legal know-how. We'll explore strategies for licensing, dispute resolution, and prevention to help safeguard valuable intellectual assets. These tools are essential for navigating the complex landscape of IP law.

Forms of Intellectual Property Infringement

Trademark and Patent Infringement

Top images from around the web for Trademark and Patent Infringement

• 

  Design patent - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Patent Infringement - Free of Charge Creative Commons Legal Engraved image View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Trademark and Patent Law – Legal Issues in Libraries and Archives View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Design patent - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Patent Infringement - Free of Charge Creative Commons Legal Engraved image View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Trademark and Patent Infringement

• 

  Design patent - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Patent Infringement - Free of Charge Creative Commons Legal Engraved image View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Trademark and Patent Law – Legal Issues in Libraries and Archives View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Design patent - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Patent Infringement - Free of Charge Creative Commons Legal Engraved image View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Trademark infringement occurs when an unauthorized party uses a mark confusingly similar to a registered trademark for selling goods or services
• Patent infringement involves unauthorized making, using, selling, or importing a patented invention within the United States
  • Includes utility patents (inventions and processes)
  • Design patents (ornamental designs applied to products)
  • Plant patents (asexually reproduced plants)
• Examples:
  • Using a logo similar to Nike's swoosh on sneakers
  • Manufacturing a smartphone with features patented by Apple

Copyright and Trade Secret Infringement

• Copyright infringement involves unauthorized use, reproduction, distribution, performance, or display of copyrighted work
  • Applies to literary, musical, dramatic, and artistic works
• Trade secret misappropriation occurs when acquiring, disclosing, or using a trade secret without owner's consent through improper means
  • Can involve industrial formulas, customer lists, or manufacturing processes
• Examples:
  • Illegally downloading and sharing music files online
  • A former employee disclosing a company's secret recipe to a competitor

Legal Tests for Infringement

Trademark and Patent Infringement Tests

• Trademark infringement determined by "likelihood of confusion" test evaluating:
  • Similarity of marks
  • Proximity of goods/services
  • Consumer sophistication
  • Evidence of actual confusion
• Patent infringement analyzed using "all elements" rule
  • Each claim element of patented invention must be present in accused product/process
• Doctrine of equivalents allows finding infringement even without literal presence of all elements
  • Considers if accused product/process performs substantially same function in substantially same way
• Examples:
  • Court comparing Adidas' three-stripe design to a four-stripe design on competitor's shoes
  • Analyzing if a generic drug contains all elements of a patented drug formula

Copyright and Trade Secret Infringement Tests

• Copyright infringement assessed using "substantial similarity" test
  • Compares copyrighted work to allegedly infringing work for similarity in protectable expression
• Courts also consider:
  • Defendant's access to copyrighted work
  • Whether similarities due to independent creation or common sources
• Trade secret misappropriation evaluated on:
  • If information qualifies as trade secret
  • If acquired through improper means or breach of confidence
• Examples:
  • Comparing melody and lyrics of two songs for substantial similarity
  • Investigating if a former employee used confidential customer lists to solicit business for a new employer

Remedies for Infringement

Injunctive Relief and Monetary Damages

• Injunctive relief stops infringing activities through:
  • Temporary restraining orders
  • Preliminary injunctions
  • Permanent injunctions
• Monetary damages may include:
  • Actual damages compensating owner's losses
  • Infringer's profits attributable to infringement
  • Statutory damages in certain copyright and trademark cases (predetermined amounts)
• Enhanced damages awarded in cases of willful infringement
  • Treble damages possible in patent and trademark cases
• Examples:
  • Court ordering a company to cease production of counterfeit luxury handbags
  • Awarding a record label lost profits from illegally downloaded music

Additional Remedies and Costs

• Attorneys' fees and costs awarded to prevailing party in exceptional cases
• Seizure and destruction of infringing goods ordered by courts
  • Particularly for counterfeit trademark goods or pirated copyrighted works
• Corrective advertising required in trademark cases to dispel consumer confusion
• Examples:
  • Destroying shipments of fake designer watches at customs
  • Requiring a company to run ads clarifying they are not associated with a well-known brand they infringed upon

Licensing and Dispute Resolution

Licensing Strategies

• Licensing agreements grant permission to use intellectual property under specific terms
  • Prevents potential infringement disputes
• Cross-licensing arrangements involve parties exchanging licenses to their respective intellectual property
  • Often used to resolve patent disputes in technology industries
• Patent pools allow multiple patent holders to license patents to each other or third parties
  • Facilitates use of complementary technologies
  • Reduces litigation risks
• Coexistence agreements in trademark law allow similar marks to coexist under specific conditions
• Examples:
  • Microsoft licensing its Office software to computer manufacturers
  • Smartphone companies cross-licensing cellular technology patents

Alternative Dispute Resolution and Prevention

• Alternative dispute resolution methods include:
  • Mediation
  • Arbitration
  • More efficient and cost-effective than litigation
• Cease and desist letters serve as initial communications to alleged infringers
  • Often lead to negotiations and settlements without formal legal action
• Due diligence and freedom-to-operate searches identify potential infringement risks
  • Allows for proactive risk management strategies before launching new products/services
• Examples:
  • Two companies agreeing to arbitration over a patent dispute
  • A startup conducting a trademark search before finalizing their company name and logo