5.3 Marxist and socialist feminism

Marxist and socialist feminism emerged in the late 1960s, analyzing women's oppression through the lens of capitalism and class struggle. These perspectives argue that women's subordination is rooted in the economic system and the sexual division of labor, emphasizing the interconnection between patriarchy and capitalism.

These feminist approaches examine how women's unpaid domestic labor contributes to capitalist exploitation and how gender ideologies serve economic interests. They propose strategies for women's liberation that involve dismantling both capitalism and patriarchy, emphasizing collective resistance and envisioning a socialist future with genuine equality.

Marxist feminism origins

• Marxist feminism emerged in the late 1960s and 1970s, drawing upon the theories of Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels to analyze women's oppression
• Marxist feminists argue that the root cause of women's subordination lies in the capitalist economic system and the sexual division of labor
• Marxist feminism seeks to understand how the material conditions of production and reproduction shape gender relations and women's experiences

Roots in Marxist theory

Top images from around the web for Roots in Marxist theory

• 

  Pyramid of Capitalist System - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Members of the Women's Trade Union League (WTUL) of New York pose with a banner calling for the ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Women pressers on strike for higher wages | Title: Women pre… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Pyramid of Capitalist System - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Members of the Women's Trade Union League (WTUL) of New York pose with a banner calling for the ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Roots in Marxist theory

• 

  Pyramid of Capitalist System - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Members of the Women's Trade Union League (WTUL) of New York pose with a banner calling for the ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Women pressers on strike for higher wages | Title: Women pre… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Pyramid of Capitalist System - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Members of the Women's Trade Union League (WTUL) of New York pose with a banner calling for the ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Marxist feminism builds upon Marx's analysis of class struggle and the exploitation of workers under capitalism
• Marxist theory posits that the capitalist mode of production is based on the private ownership of the means of production and the extraction of surplus value from wage labor
• Marxist feminists extend this analysis to examine how women's unpaid domestic labor and reproductive labor contribute to the reproduction of the capitalist system

Influence of Engels

• Friedrich Engels' book "The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State" (1884) was a significant influence on Marxist feminist thought
• Engels argued that the emergence of private property and the family as an economic unit led to the subordination of women and the rise of patriarchy
• Engels suggested that women's liberation would require the abolition of private property and the socialization of domestic labor

Capitalism and women's oppression

• Marxist feminists contend that capitalism and patriarchy are interconnected systems that reinforce women's oppression
• Under capitalism, women's unpaid domestic labor is essential for reproducing the labor force and maintaining the system of exploitation
• The sexual division of labor, which assigns women primary responsibility for unpaid domestic work, serves the interests of capital accumulation and male domination

Socialist feminism emergence

• Socialist feminism developed in the 1970s as a response to the limitations of both Marxist feminism and radical feminism
• Socialist feminists sought to integrate an analysis of patriarchy and gender oppression with a critique of capitalism and class exploitation
• Socialist feminism emphasizes the need to challenge both economic and cultural structures that perpetuate women's subordination

Limitations of Marxist feminism

• Some feminists critiqued Marxist feminism for its tendency to prioritize class struggle over gender struggle and to subsume women's oppression under the broader critique of capitalism
• Socialist feminists argued that Marxist feminism did not adequately address the specific ways in which patriarchy operates as a distinct system of oppression
• Socialist feminists called for a more nuanced analysis of the interplay between capitalism and patriarchy in shaping women's lives

Dual systems theory

• Socialist feminists developed dual systems theory, which posits that capitalism and patriarchy are two separate but interlocking systems of oppression
• Dual systems theory suggests that women's oppression cannot be reduced solely to economic factors or class relations but must also consider the role of gender ideology and patriarchal structures
• Socialist feminists argue that challenging both capitalism and patriarchy is necessary for achieving women's liberation

Patriarchy and capitalism interplay

• Socialist feminists examine how patriarchy and capitalism reinforce each other and shape women's experiences in the workplace, the family, and society at large
• Patriarchal gender norms and ideologies (women as primary caregivers, men as breadwinners) serve the interests of capital by ensuring a supply of cheap, flexible, and unpaid female labor
• Capitalism, in turn, benefits from and perpetuates patriarchal relations by exploiting women's paid and unpaid labor and maintaining gender-based hierarchies and inequalities

Domestic labor debate

• The domestic labor debate was a key theoretical discussion among Marxist and socialist feminists in the 1970s and 1980s
• The debate centered on the nature and value of women's unpaid domestic labor and its relationship to the capitalist mode of production
• Marxist and socialist feminists sought to make visible and politicize the hidden work that women perform in the home and to challenge the devaluation of this labor

Women's unpaid labor

• Women's unpaid domestic labor includes tasks such as cooking, cleaning, childcare, and emotional support that are essential for the daily and generational reproduction of the workforce
• This labor is often rendered invisible and devalued as "women's work" and is not recognized as productive labor within the capitalist system
• Marxist and socialist feminists argue that women's unpaid domestic labor is a key site of women's oppression and exploitation

Reproduction of labor power

• Marxist feminists contend that women's unpaid domestic labor plays a crucial role in reproducing labor power, which is the capacity of workers to engage in wage labor
• By performing domestic tasks and caring for family members, women ensure the daily and generational renewal of the workforce, enabling the continuation of capitalist production
• The reproduction of labor power is essential for the functioning of capitalism, yet women's contribution to this process is unrecognized and uncompensated

Housework as productive work

• Some Marxist and socialist feminists argue that housework should be considered productive work that creates value and contributes to the economy
• They challenge the traditional Marxist distinction between productive labor (which produces surplus value) and unproductive labor (which does not)
• Recognizing housework as productive work would require a fundamental reevaluation of the economic and social value of women's labor and a restructuring of the gendered division of labor

Wages for housework movement

• The Wages for Housework movement emerged in the 1970s as a radical feminist campaign to demand compensation for women's unpaid domestic labor
• The movement argued that women's unpaid housework and care work is essential to the functioning of the capitalist economy and should be recognized and remunerated as such
• Wages for Housework activists sought to make visible the hidden work that women perform and to challenge the devaluation of this labor

Dalla Costa and James

• Mariarosa Dalla Costa and Selma James were key theorists and activists in the Wages for Housework movement
• In their influential pamphlet "The Power of Women and the Subversion of the Community" (1972), they argued that women's unpaid housework is the foundation of capitalist exploitation
• Dalla Costa and James called for a wages for housework campaign as a strategy for making women's work visible, valuing it, and ultimately challenging the capitalist system

Compensating domestic labor

• The Wages for Housework movement demanded that women be compensated for their unpaid domestic labor, either through direct wages or through state-funded services and support
• Advocates argued that paying women for their housework would recognize the value of this work, give women greater economic independence, and challenge the gendered division of labor
• Some proponents suggested that compensating domestic labor could also serve as a transitional strategy towards the socialization of housework and the creation of collective alternatives to the privatized family

Critiques and limitations

• The Wages for Housework movement faced critiques from both within and outside the feminist movement
• Some critics argued that the demand for wages for housework could reinforce the gendered division of labor and the privatization of social reproduction
• Others suggested that the focus on individual wages could undermine efforts to challenge the structural roots of women's oppression and to build collective alternatives
• The movement also faced challenges in terms of practical implementation and the potential unintended consequences of monetizing domestic labor

Capitalism and gender ideology

• Marxist and socialist feminists examine how capitalism shapes and relies upon gender ideologies and norms that perpetuate women's subordination
• Gender ideologies, such as the notion of women as "natural" caregivers and men as "breadwinners," serve the interests of capital accumulation and the maintenance of the capitalist system
• Capitalism both benefits from and reinforces patriarchal relations and gendered divisions of labor

Gender roles and capitalism

• Capitalist production relies on the gendered division of labor, which assigns women primary responsibility for unpaid domestic work and care work
• This division of labor enables the reproduction of the workforce at minimal cost to capital and ensures a supply of cheap, flexible, and disposable female labor
• Gender roles and norms (women as nurturing, self-sacrificing, and submissive) are reinforced by capitalist ideologies and institutions (media, education, religion) to maintain this gendered division of labor

Family as economic unit

• The nuclear family serves as a key economic unit under capitalism, functioning as a site of social reproduction and consumption
• Women's unpaid labor within the family (childcare, housework, emotional support) is essential for reproducing the next generation of workers and maintaining the current workforce
• The privatization of social reproduction within the family unit allows the costs of this essential labor to be borne by women, rather than by the state or employers

Women's subordination and profit

• Women's subordination and the devaluation of their labor is profitable for capitalism, as it allows for the extraction of greater surplus value
• The gender wage gap, women's concentration in low-paid and precarious jobs, and their disproportionate responsibility for unpaid care work all contribute to the accumulation of capital
• Capitalism relies on and perpetuates women's economic dependence on men and their vulnerability to exploitation, both within the workplace and the family

Intersections of class and gender

• Marxist and socialist feminists recognize that women's experiences of oppression are shaped by the intersections of gender, class, race, sexuality, and other social identities
• Working-class women, women of color, and immigrant women often face heightened forms of exploitation and marginalization due to the compounding effects of multiple systems of oppression
• An intersectional analysis is crucial for understanding the complex ways in which capitalism and patriarchy interact to shape women's lives

Working class women's experiences

• Working-class women are doubly oppressed by their class position and their gender, facing exploitation in the workplace and the burden of unpaid domestic labor
• They are often concentrated in low-wage, precarious, and feminized sectors of the economy (service work, care work, domestic work) and face limited opportunities for advancement
• Working-class women's struggles for better wages, working conditions, and social support are central to the fight against capitalist exploitation and gender oppression

Racialized and gendered labor

• Women of color and immigrant women are disproportionately represented in low-paid, precarious, and often informal sectors of the economy
• They face the intersection of racism, sexism, and economic marginalization, which shapes their experiences in the workplace, the family, and the community
• The racialization and gendering of certain forms of labor (domestic work, agricultural work, garment work) serves to devalue this work and to justify the exploitation of women of color and immigrant women

Marginalization and exploitation

• Capitalism and patriarchy operate together to marginalize and exploit women who experience multiple forms of oppression
• Women's social identities and locations shape their access to resources, opportunities, and power, and render them vulnerable to specific forms of economic and sexual exploitation
• Challenging the intersecting systems of oppression requires a multi-pronged approach that addresses the structural roots of inequality and builds solidarity across different groups of women

Strategies for women's liberation

• Marxist and socialist feminists propose a range of strategies for achieving women's liberation and dismantling the oppressive structures of capitalism and patriarchy
• These strategies emphasize the need for collective resistance, organizing, and the transformation of both economic and social relations
• The ultimate goal is to create a society free from exploitation, oppression, and inequality, in which all individuals can flourish and realize their full potential

Dismantling capitalism and patriarchy

• Marxist and socialist feminists argue that women's liberation requires the dismantling of both capitalism and patriarchy, as these systems are mutually reinforcing and oppressive
• This involves challenging the economic structures that exploit women's labor, as well as the cultural and ideological norms that perpetuate women's subordination
• Strategies for dismantling these systems include mass mobilization, political education, and the creation of alternative economic and social arrangements

Collective resistance and organizing

• Marxist and socialist feminists emphasize the importance of collective resistance and organizing in the struggle for women's liberation
• This includes building solidarity among women across different social locations and identities, and forging alliances with other progressive movements (labor, anti-racist, LGBTQ+)
• Collective organizing can take many forms, such as trade unions, women's organizations, grassroots movements, and political parties, and can operate at various scales (local, national, international)

Envisioning a socialist future

• Marxist and socialist feminists envision a future society based on the principles of socialism, in which the means of production are collectively owned and democratically controlled
• In this society, women's unpaid domestic labor would be socialized and shared, and the gendered division of labor would be eliminated
• A socialist future would prioritize the well-being and development of all individuals, rather than the accumulation of profit, and would strive to create conditions of genuine equality and freedom

Contributions and influence

• Marxist and socialist feminism have made significant contributions to feminist theory and practice, and continue to inform contemporary debates and struggles
• These perspectives have challenged traditional Marxist and feminist analyses, and have expanded our understanding of the complex ways in which capitalism and patriarchy shape women's lives
• Marxist and socialist feminist ideas have had a lasting impact on the development of intersectional feminism and on the strategies and goals of the feminist movement

Impact on feminist theory

• Marxist and socialist feminism have brought attention to the material and economic dimensions of women's oppression, and have challenged the notion that gender inequality is primarily a cultural or ideological problem
• These perspectives have expanded feminist theory by integrating an analysis of class and capitalism with an understanding of patriarchy and gender oppression
• Marxist and socialist feminists have also contributed to the development of key concepts, such as social reproduction, the gendered division of labor, and the intersection of multiple systems of oppression

Informing intersectional analysis

• Marxist and socialist feminism have been influential in the development of intersectional feminism, which examines the ways in which different forms of oppression (based on gender, race, class, sexuality, etc.) intersect and shape women's experiences
• By highlighting the importance of class and economic relations in shaping women's lives, Marxist and socialist feminists have helped to deepen our understanding of the complex and multifaceted nature of oppression
• Intersectional analysis, informed by Marxist and socialist feminist insights, has become a key tool for understanding and challenging the interlocking systems of power and inequality that affect women's lives

Ongoing relevance and legacy

• The insights and analyses of Marxist and socialist feminism continue to be relevant in the contemporary context, as women around the world face the challenges of neoliberal capitalism, austerity, and the rise of right-wing populism
• Marxist and socialist feminist ideas inform ongoing struggles for women's rights, economic justice, and social transformation, from the fight for equal pay and reproductive rights to the movement for a just transition to a post-carbon economy
• The legacy of Marxist and socialist feminism can be seen in the work of contemporary feminist scholars and activists who continue to grapple with the complex intersections of gender, class, race, and other forms of oppression, and who seek to build a more just and equitable world for all