5.7 Thematic resolution

Thematic resolution in playwriting is the art of concluding and conveying a play's central ideas to the audience. It's a crucial element that can make or break the overall impact of a theatrical work. Playwrights must carefully consider how to resolve themes in a way that resonates with viewers.

There are various approaches to thematic resolution, including explicit vs. implicit, positive vs. negative, and open vs. closed. Each method has its strengths and challenges, requiring playwrights to choose wisely based on their play's goals and intended message.

Types of thematic resolution

• Thematic resolution refers to how the central themes or ideas of a play are concluded and conveyed to the audience
• The way in which themes are resolved can significantly impact the overall message and emotional resonance of the play

Explicit vs implicit

Top images from around the web for Explicit vs implicit

• 

  How Memory Functions | Introduction to Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Rhetorical Situation – Communication for Business Professionals View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Origin of the Good Samaritan Parable and Other Lucan Favourites View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  How Memory Functions | Introduction to Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Rhetorical Situation – Communication for Business Professionals View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Explicit vs implicit

• 

  How Memory Functions | Introduction to Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Rhetorical Situation – Communication for Business Professionals View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Origin of the Good Samaritan Parable and Other Lucan Favourites View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  How Memory Functions | Introduction to Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Rhetorical Situation – Communication for Business Professionals View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Explicit thematic resolution directly states or summarizes the central themes through dialogue, monologue, or overt symbolism
  • Can provide clarity and ensure the audience grasps the intended message
  • May risk feeling heavy-handed or preachy if not handled with subtlety (Brecht's "The Good Person of Szechwan")
• Implicit thematic resolution conveys themes through subtext, character actions, or subtle imagery
  • Allows for audience interpretation and personal resonance
  • Requires careful crafting to ensure themes are still effectively communicated (Chekhov's "The Cherry Orchard")

Positive vs negative

• Positive thematic resolution concludes with an affirmative or uplifting message, often emphasizing growth, hope, or redemption
  • Can leave audiences feeling inspired or optimistic
  • May be appropriate for plays exploring triumph over adversity or personal transformation (Hansberry's "A Raisin in the Sun")
• Negative thematic resolution concludes with a pessimistic, tragic, or unresolved message, highlighting the consequences of characters' actions or societal issues
  • Can provoke thought, critique, or emotional impact
  • May be suitable for plays dealing with weighty themes or the human condition (Miller's "Death of a Salesman")

Open vs closed

• Open thematic resolution leaves room for interpretation, ambiguity, or unresolved questions
  • Encourages audience reflection and discussion
  • Can create a sense of realism or acknowledge life's complexities (Beckett's "Waiting for Godot")
• Closed thematic resolution provides a clear, definitive conclusion to the themes
  • Offers a sense of completeness or finality
  • May be satisfying for audiences seeking a straightforward message or resolution (Ibsen's "A Doll's House")

Techniques for effective resolution

• Playwrights employ various techniques to effectively resolve themes and create a lasting impact on the audience
• The choice and execution of these techniques can greatly influence the success of the thematic resolution

Foreshadowing and setup

• Planting thematic elements, symbols, or motifs early in the play that pay off in the resolution
  • Creates a sense of cohesion and purposeful storytelling
  • Allows for a satisfying "aha" moment when themes are resolved (Shakespeare's use of prophecy in "Macbeth")
• Establishing character conflicts or dilemmas that align with the central themes
  • Provides a foundation for thematic exploration and resolution
  • Ensures the resolution feels earned and integral to the narrative (Sophocles' "Antigone")

Character arcs and growth

• Developing characters' internal journeys in relation to the themes
  • Demonstrating how characters' experiences, decisions, and changes reflect the thematic message
  • Creates emotional investment and resonance for the audience (Willy Loman's decline in Miller's "Death of a Salesman")
• Resolving character arcs in a way that reinforces the themes
  • Showing the consequences or rewards of characters' actions and growth
  • Provides a satisfying sense of completion and thematic coherence (Nora's transformation in Ibsen's "A Doll's House")

Symbolic imagery and motifs

• Employing visual symbols or recurring motifs that encapsulate the themes
  • Creates a subconscious association between the imagery and the thematic message
  • Allows for subtle reinforcement and artistic expression (The glass menagerie in Williams' "The Glass Menagerie")
• Resolving or transforming the symbolic imagery in the final scenes
  • Provides a powerful visual representation of the thematic resolution
  • Leaves a lasting impression on the audience (The breaking of the unicorn in Williams' "The Glass Menagerie")

Dialogue and monologue

• Using characters' words to articulate or debate the central themes
  • Allows for direct exploration of ideas and conflicts
  • Can provide varying perspectives or arguments surrounding the themes (The philosophical debates in Sartre's "No Exit")
• Crafting pivotal monologues that encapsulate the thematic resolution
  • Gives characters a platform to express realizations, epiphanies, or final statements
  • Creates a memorable and impactful moment of thematic clarity (Nina's final monologue in Chekhov's "The Seagull")

Challenges in crafting resolution

• Playwrights face various challenges when attempting to effectively resolve themes in their plays
• Navigating these challenges requires skill, creativity, and a deep understanding of the themes and desired impact

Avoiding clichés and predictability

• Steering clear of overused or predictable thematic resolutions
  • Ensures the play feels fresh, original, and thought-provoking
  • Challenges the playwright to find innovative ways to explore and conclude themes
• Subverting audience expectations while still delivering a satisfying resolution
  • Creates a sense of surprise or novelty
  • Requires a delicate balance between setup and payoff (The unexpected resolution in Stoppard's "Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead")

Balancing subtlety and clarity

• Conveying themes with nuance and subtlety to avoid heavy-handedness
  • Allows for audience interpretation and personal resonance
  • Requires carefully crafted subtext, symbolism, or characterization
• Ensuring the thematic resolution is still clear and impactful
  • Prevents the message from being lost or overlooked
  • May involve strategic use of explicit techniques or pivotal moments (The balance of subtlety and clarity in Chekhov's plays)

Tying up loose ends

• Addressing any unresolved plot points, character arcs, or thematic threads
  • Creates a sense of completeness and satisfaction for the audience
  • Requires careful planning and attention to detail throughout the writing process
• Integrating the resolution of loose ends with the thematic resolution
  • Ensures a cohesive and purposeful conclusion
  • Avoids a disjointed or tacked-on feeling (The interconnectedness of plot and theme in Shakespeare's plays)

Satisfying audience expectations

• Meeting the audience's expectations for emotional catharsis or intellectual stimulation
  • Ensures the play delivers on its promised themes and impact
  • Requires an understanding of the audience's needs and desires
• Balancing audience satisfaction with artistic integrity and originality
  • Avoids pandering or compromising the play's themes for the sake of popularity
  • Involves finding a middle ground between accessibility and depth (The balance of entertainment and social commentary in Hansberry's "A Raisin in the Sun")

Thematic resolution in context

• The effectiveness of thematic resolution often depends on its relationship to other elements of the play
• Understanding how thematic resolution functions within the larger context is crucial for creating a cohesive and impactful play

Relationship to plot resolution

• Ensuring the thematic resolution aligns with or enhances the plot resolution
  • Creates a sense of unity and purposefulness in the play's conclusion
  • Avoids a disconnect between the story's events and its underlying themes (The alignment of plot and theme in Shakespeare's tragedies)
• Using the plot resolution to reinforce or complicate the thematic resolution
  • Provides an additional layer of meaning or irony
  • Can create a thought-provoking or emotionally resonant ending (The ironic relationship between plot and theme in Ibsen's "An Enemy of the People")

Impact on overall message

• Considering how the thematic resolution contributes to the play's central message or argument
  • Ensures the resolution supports or strengthens the intended takeaway for the audience
  • Requires a clear understanding of the play's purpose and themes from the outset
• Evaluating whether the thematic resolution is consistent with the established themes and tone
  • Maintains the play's integrity and coherence
  • Avoids contradicting or undermining the previously explored ideas (The consistent thematic messaging in Brecht's plays)

Alignment with genre conventions

• Understanding how thematic resolution functions within different theatrical genres (tragedy, comedy, realism, absurdism, etc.)
  • Allows for effective use of genre-specific techniques or expectations
  • Ensures the resolution feels appropriate and satisfying within the genre's framework
• Subverting or playing with genre conventions for a unique thematic resolution
  • Creates a fresh or unexpected take on familiar themes
  • Requires a deep understanding of the genre's tropes and audience expectations (The subversion of tragic conventions in Beckett's "Waiting for Godot")

Resonance and memorability

• Crafting a thematic resolution that lingers in the audience's minds long after the play has ended
  • Ensures the play's themes have a lasting impact and encourage further reflection
  • Often involves a striking image, profound insight, or emotional gut-punch
• Using the thematic resolution to create a sense of universality or timelessness
  • Allows the play's themes to resonate with a wide range of audiences
  • Taps into shared human experiences, desires, or fears (The timeless resonance of the thematic resolution in Miller's "The Crucible")

Evaluating thematic resolution

• Assessing the effectiveness of a play's thematic resolution is a crucial skill for playwrights, directors, and critics alike
• Developing a critical eye for thematic resolution involves understanding its key components, recognizing common pitfalls, and learning from successful examples

Criteria for success

• Clarity: Is the thematic resolution clear and easily discernible to the audience?
  • Ensures the play's themes are effectively communicated
  • Avoids ambiguity or confusion that may undermine the play's impact
• Coherence: Does the thematic resolution align with and build upon the play's established themes and tone?
  • Maintains the play's integrity and sense of purposefulness
  • Avoids a disjointed or contradictory conclusion
• Emotional resonance: Does the thematic resolution evoke a strong emotional response in the audience?
  • Ensures the themes are not only intellectually understood but also felt on a visceral level
  • Creates a lasting impact and encourages audience reflection
• Originality: Does the thematic resolution offer a fresh perspective or avoid clichés?
  • Sets the play apart from others exploring similar themes
  • Demonstrates the playwright's creativity and unique voice

Common pitfalls and mistakes

• Heavy-handedness: Is the thematic resolution too overt or preachy?
  • Can alienate the audience or undermine the play's artistic merit
  • Suggests a lack of trust in the audience's ability to interpret the themes
• Predictability: Is the thematic resolution too obvious or formulaic?
  • Diminishes the play's impact and fails to challenge the audience
  • Indicates a reliance on tired tropes or a lack of originality
• Inconsistency: Does the thematic resolution contradict or undermine the play's previously established themes?
  • Creates confusion or frustration for the audience
  • Suggests a lack of clarity or purposefulness in the playwright's vision
• Unearned resolution: Does the thematic resolution feel forced or unearned based on the play's events and character development?
  • Undermines the audience's suspension of disbelief and emotional investment
  • Indicates a disconnect between the play's structure and its thematic goals

Analyzing examples from plays

• Examining how successful plays resolve their themes
  • Provides insights into effective techniques, structures, and creative choices
  • Allows playwrights to learn from and build upon the work of their predecessors (Analyzing the thematic resolution in Williams' "A Streetcar Named Desire")
• Identifying the strengths and weaknesses of different approaches to thematic resolution
  • Develops a critical understanding of what works and what doesn't in various contexts
  • Encourages playwrights to experiment with and refine their own approaches (Comparing the thematic resolutions in Ibsen's "A Doll's House" and Shaw's "Pygmalion")

Receiving feedback and critique

• Seeking input from trusted readers, collaborators, or mentors on the effectiveness of the thematic resolution
  • Provides an outside perspective and identifies potential blind spots or areas for improvement
  • Allows for a constructive dialogue about the play's themes and their impact
• Incorporating feedback and making revisions to strengthen the thematic resolution
  • Demonstrates a commitment to the play's success and a willingness to learn and grow as a playwright
  • Ensures the final product is as polished and effective as possible (Workshopping and refining the thematic resolution through multiple drafts and staged readings)