6.3 Arthur Conan Doyle and the detective fiction genre

Arthur Conan Doyle revolutionized detective fiction with Sherlock Holmes. His stories blended logic, science, and thrilling mysteries, setting the standard for the genre. Holmes became an icon, inspiring countless adaptations and influencing real-world forensics.

Doyle's work established key conventions like the brilliant detective and loyal sidekick. His innovative techniques and vivid Victorian London setting captivated readers, leading to a surge in detective fiction's popularity and shaping the genre for generations to come.

Detective Fiction's Rise in Victorian England

Origins and Key Works

Top images from around the web for Origins and Key Works

• 

  Edgar Allan Poe - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Arthur Conan Doyle bibliography - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Arthur Conan Doyle – Wikipedie View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Edgar Allan Poe - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Arthur Conan Doyle bibliography - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Origins and Key Works

• 

  Edgar Allan Poe - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Arthur Conan Doyle bibliography - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Arthur Conan Doyle – Wikipedie View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Edgar Allan Poe - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Arthur Conan Doyle bibliography - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Detective fiction emerged as a distinct literary genre in the mid-19th century with Edgar Allan Poe's "The Murders in the Rue Morgue" (1841) marking the first true detective story
• Wilkie Collins' "The Moonstone" (1868) established many conventions of the genre as one of the first full-length detective novels
• Late Victorian era saw a surge in detective fiction's popularity coinciding with organized police forces and growing public interest in crime and justice
• Serialized detective stories in popular magazines played a crucial role in the genre's development and widespread appeal (Strand Magazine)

Key Elements and Influences

• Brilliant detective, Watson-like sidekick, and logical deduction to solve complex mysteries crystallized as key elements during this period
• Victorian detective fiction reflected societal anxieties about urbanization, scientific advancements, and changing social norms
• Genre influenced by real-life detectives and criminal investigations (Jack the Ripper case, Scotland Yard)
• Incorporated emerging forensic techniques and scientific methods into storylines

Arthur Conan Doyle's Literary Techniques

Narrative Structure and Perspective

• First-person narration through Dr. Watson creates a unique perspective
  • Allows readers to admire Holmes's deductions
  • Maintains an air of mystery around his methods
• Distinct story structure employed
  • Introduction of the case
  • Investigation and deduction
  • Dramatic resolution, often with a twist or surprising revelation
• Blend of realism and sensationalism in plot construction
  • Strikes a balance between plausibility and excitement
  • Contributes to the stories' enduring appeal

Characterization and Setting

• Characterization of Holmes as an eccentric genius with admirable and flawed traits
  • Adds depth and complexity to the detective archetype
  • Creates a memorable and relatable protagonist
• Vivid descriptions of Victorian London create a rich, atmospheric backdrop
  • Integral part of the stories' appeal
  • Immerses readers in the historical setting
• Use of red herrings and misdirection
  • Challenges readers' deductive skills
  • Maintains suspense throughout the narrative

Innovative Investigative Methods

• Innovative use of forensic science and logical reasoning in Holmes's methods
  • Reflected emerging investigative techniques of the time
  • Popularized scientific approach to crime-solving
• Incorporation of detailed observations and deductions
  • Showcases Holmes's exceptional analytical skills
  • Engages readers in the problem-solving process

Sherlock Holmes' Cultural Impact

Enduring Popularity and Adaptations

• Sherlock Holmes stories continuously in print since first publication
  • Translated into numerous languages
  • Adapted across various media (film, television, radio)
• Holmes as an iconic figure in popular culture
  • Recognizable by deerstalker cap, pipe, and catchphrase "Elementary, my dear Watson"
  • Inspired countless imitations and parodies
• Character's adaptability to different time periods and settings
  • Modern adaptations demonstrate timeless appeal and relevance
  • Allows for reinterpretation of the character for new generations

Fandom and Real-World Influence

• Sherlock Holmes societies and fan clubs exist worldwide
  • Engage in scholarly study, role-playing, and preservation of Holmesian lore
  • Foster a dedicated and passionate fan community
• Significant impact on real-world forensic practices
  • Some techniques described by Doyle later adopted by actual investigators
  • Influenced public perception of detective work and forensic science
• Numerous pastiches and continuation stories by other authors
  • Expand the "canon" beyond Doyle's original works
  • Demonstrate the character's lasting appeal and versatility

Doyle's Influence on Crime Fiction

Establishing Genre Conventions

• Doyle's work established many conventions of the detective genre
  • Brilliant but flawed detective
  • Loyal sidekick
  • Emphasis on logical deduction
• Success of Sherlock Holmes stories led to proliferation of detective fiction
  • Inspired authors to create unique detective characters and series
  • Set a standard for character-driven narratives with intricate plots

Evolution of Crime Fiction Subgenres

• Approach to forensic science paved way for scientifically-oriented crime novels
  • Led to eventual emergence of police procedural subgenre
  • Influenced incorporation of forensic details in mystery writing
• "Locked room mystery" and puzzle-like elements influenced development of "Golden Age" detective fiction
  • 1920s and 1930s saw rise of complex, puzzle-oriented mysteries
  • Authors like Agatha Christie and Dorothy L. Sayers built upon Doyle's foundation

Broader Literary Impact

• International popularity of Sherlock Holmes contributed to globalization of detective fiction
  • Inspired works in various cultural contexts
  • Influenced detective fiction traditions worldwide (Scandinavian noir, Japanese detective fiction)
• Influence extends beyond traditional detective fiction
  • Impacted related genres such as spy novels and thrillers
  • Elements of mystery and investigation incorporated into literary fiction