6.1 Civil Code

Japan's Civil Code, born in the Meiji era, marked a shift from feudal laws to a modern legal framework. Blending French and German influences, it established a comprehensive system of private law, covering everything from contracts to inheritance.

The Code's five books form the backbone of Japan's civil law system, governing private relationships and transactions. Recent amendments have modernized provisions, addressing societal changes and evolving legal needs in areas like family law and property rights.

Historical background of Civil Code

• Japanese Civil Code emerged during the Meiji era as part of broader legal reforms aimed at modernizing Japan's legal system
• Adoption of the Civil Code marked a significant shift from feudal laws to a modern, codified legal framework aligned with Western legal principles

Meiji era legal reforms

Top images from around the web for Meiji era legal reforms

• 

  From the Edo Period to Meiji Restoration in Japan | World Civilizations II (HIS102) – Biel View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Meiji era - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  From the Edo Period to Meiji Restoration in Japan | World Civilizations I (HIS101) – Biel View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  From the Edo Period to Meiji Restoration in Japan | World Civilizations II (HIS102) – Biel View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Meiji era - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Meiji era legal reforms

• 

  From the Edo Period to Meiji Restoration in Japan | World Civilizations II (HIS102) – Biel View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Meiji era - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  From the Edo Period to Meiji Restoration in Japan | World Civilizations I (HIS101) – Biel View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  From the Edo Period to Meiji Restoration in Japan | World Civilizations II (HIS102) – Biel View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Meiji era - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Initiated in 1868 to modernize Japan's legal system and establish a constitutional monarchy
• Involved comprehensive overhaul of existing laws and creation of new legal codes
• Aimed to strengthen Japan's position internationally and facilitate economic growth
• Resulted in the promulgation of the Constitution of the Empire of Japan in 1889

Influence of European legal systems

• French Civil Code initially served as primary model for Japanese Civil Code drafting
• Later drafts incorporated elements from German Civil Code (BGB) due to its systematic structure
• Boissonade's draft heavily influenced by French law, while subsequent revisions drew more from German legal concepts
• Final version of Japanese Civil Code reflected a blend of French and German civil law traditions

Structure of Japanese Civil Code

• Japanese Civil Code consists of five books covering different areas of private law
• Serves as the foundation for Japan's civil law system, governing various aspects of private relationships and transactions

Five books of Civil Code

• Book 1: General Provisions (総則) covers legal capacity, juridical acts, and time limitations
• Book 2: Real Rights (物権) deals with property rights, ownership, and possession
• Book 3: Obligations (債権) focuses on contracts, torts, and other forms of obligations
• Book 4: Family (親族) addresses marriage, divorce, and parent-child relationships
• Book 5: Inheritance (相続) covers rules for succession and division of estates

Relationship to other laws

• Civil Code interacts with other specialized laws (Commercial Code, Labor Standards Act)
• Provides general principles that apply when specific laws are silent on an issue
• Serves as a reference point for interpreting and applying other private law statutes
• Complements public law by regulating private relationships and transactions

General provisions

• Book 1 of the Civil Code establishes fundamental legal concepts and principles
• Provides a framework for interpreting and applying other provisions throughout the Code

Legal capacity and competence

• Defines who can enter into legally binding agreements and exercise rights
• Establishes age of majority (成年) at 18 years old (lowered from 20 in 2022)
• Outlines conditions for limited capacity (制限行為能力) and legal incompetence (行為無能力)
• Addresses guardianship (後見) and curatorship (保佐) for individuals with limited capacity

Juridical acts and agency

• Defines juridical acts (法律行為) as expressions of intent that produce legal effects
• Outlines requirements for valid juridical acts (意思表示, 法律行為の有効要件)
• Covers principles of agency (代理), including types and scope of authority
• Addresses issues of apparent authority (表見代理) and unauthorized agency (無権代理)

Time limitations and periods

• Establishes rules for calculating legal time periods and deadlines
• Defines statute of limitations (消滅時効) for various types of claims and rights
• Outlines principles for suspension and interruption of limitation periods
• Addresses issues of acquisitive prescription (取得時効) for property rights

Property rights

• Book 2 of the Civil Code governs real rights and property-related matters
• Establishes framework for ownership, possession, and other property interests

Types of property rights

• Distinguishes between movable (動産) and immovable (不動産) property
• Defines various types of real rights (物権), including ownership and limited real rights
• Covers security interests (担保物権) such as mortgages (抵当権) and pledges (質権)
• Addresses special types of property rights like surface rights (地上権) and emphyteusis (永小作権)

Ownership and possession

• Defines ownership (所有権) as the most comprehensive property right
• Outlines rights and responsibilities of property owners
• Distinguishes between possession (占有) and ownership
• Addresses issues of adverse possession (取得時効) and boundary disputes (境界確定)

Usufruct and easements

• Defines usufruct (用益物権) as the right to use and enjoy another's property
• Covers various types of usufructuary rights, including superficies (地上権) and emphyteusis (永小作権)
• Outlines principles governing easements (地役権) and their creation, use, and termination
• Addresses issues of public and private easements

Obligations and contracts

• Book 3 of the Civil Code governs obligations, contracts, and related matters
• Establishes framework for creating, modifying, and terminating contractual relationships

Formation of contracts

• Outlines requirements for valid contract formation (offer and acceptance, 申込みと承諾)
• Addresses issues of capacity, consent, and consideration in contract formation
• Covers principles of good faith (信義則) and fair dealing in contractual relationships
• Addresses issues of mistake (錯誤), fraud (詐欺), and duress (強迫) in contract formation

Types of obligations

• Distinguishes between contractual obligations and obligations arising from torts or unjust enrichment
• Covers various types of contracts (sale, lease, loan, employment)
• Addresses issues of joint and several obligations (連帯債務) and indivisible obligations (不可分債務)
• Outlines principles governing conditional obligations and obligations with time stipulations

Breach of contract

• Defines breach of contract (債務不履行) and its consequences
• Outlines remedies available to the aggrieved party (damages, specific performance)
• Addresses issues of impossibility of performance and force majeure
• Covers principles of anticipatory breach and repudiation of contracts

Family law

• Book 4 of the Civil Code governs family relationships and related matters
• Establishes legal framework for marriage, divorce, and parent-child relationships

Marriage and divorce

• Outlines requirements for valid marriage (婚姻の成立要件) and registration procedures
• Addresses issues of marital property rights and obligations between spouses
• Covers grounds for divorce (離婚原因) and procedures for divorce by agreement (協議離婚) and judicial divorce (裁判離婚)
• Outlines principles governing division of property and spousal support upon divorce

Parent-child relationships

• Defines legal parentage and establishes rules for determining parenthood
• Addresses issues of legitimacy and legitimation of children
• Outlines parental rights and responsibilities (親権) including custody and education
• Covers principles governing child support obligations and visitation rights

Adoption and guardianship

• Outlines requirements and procedures for adoption (養子縁組), including special adoption (特別養子縁組)
• Addresses legal effects of adoption on familial relationships and inheritance rights
• Defines guardianship (後見) and curatorship (保佐) for minors and adults with limited capacity
• Outlines duties and responsibilities of guardians and curators

Inheritance law

• Book 5 of the Civil Code governs succession and inheritance matters
• Establishes framework for transferring property and rights upon death

Intestate succession

• Defines rules for inheritance when there is no valid will (法定相続)
• Outlines order of succession and shares of inheritance for different classes of heirs
• Addresses issues of representation in succession (代襲相続) and per stirpes distribution
• Covers principles governing acceptance and renunciation of inheritance

Wills and testamentary succession

• Outlines requirements for valid wills (遺言の方式) including holographic and notarial wills
• Addresses issues of testamentary capacity and undue influence in will-making
• Covers principles governing interpretation and execution of wills
• Outlines rules for revoking or modifying wills

Division of estate

• Establishes procedures for dividing inherited property among multiple heirs
• Addresses issues of co-ownership of inherited property and partition of estate
• Outlines principles governing collation (持戻し) of gifts and advancements
• Covers rules for calculating and satisfying legally reserved portions (遺留分)

Amendments and revisions

• Japanese Civil Code has undergone several amendments since its enactment
• Revisions aim to address societal changes and modernize legal provisions

Post-war amendments

• Major reforms implemented after World War II to align with new constitutional principles
• Included changes to family law provisions to promote gender equality
• Abolished feudal concepts like house system (家制度) and patriarchal authority
• Introduced changes to property rights and inheritance laws

Recent updates to Civil Code

• 2017 amendment modernized provisions on obligations and contracts
• Lowered age of majority from 20 to 18 years old (effective 2022)
• Updated provisions on guardianship and support for adults with diminished capacity
• Introduced changes to inheritance law to address issues of aging population and changing family structures

Civil Code in practice

• Application and interpretation of Civil Code provisions in real-world situations
• Interaction between codified law and judicial decisions in Japanese legal system

Role of courts in interpretation

• Supreme Court of Japan plays crucial role in interpreting Civil Code provisions
• Lower courts apply and interpret Civil Code in light of Supreme Court precedents
• Judicial decisions help clarify ambiguous provisions and adapt Code to changing circumstances
• Courts balance strict application of Code with considerations of fairness and social norms

Interaction with customary law

• Civil Code recognizes role of customary law in certain areas (Article 92)
• Courts may consider local customs when interpreting and applying Civil Code provisions
• Customary practices often influence interpretation of family law and property rights
• Balancing codified law with customary practices presents ongoing challenge in Japanese legal system

Comparison with other legal systems

• Japanese Civil Code shares similarities and differences with other legal systems
• Comparison helps understand unique features of Japanese civil law

Civil Code vs common law

• Civil Code system relies more on codified statutes than case law
• Common law systems (UK, US) place greater emphasis on judicial precedents
• Japanese system incorporates elements of both, with growing importance of case law
• Civil Code provides more comprehensive and systematic coverage of private law areas

Japanese Civil Code vs German BGB

• Both codes share similar structure and many conceptual similarities
• Japanese Code more concise, with fewer detailed provisions than German BGB
• Japanese Code incorporates some unique concepts reflecting Japanese legal tradition
• Recent revisions to Japanese Code have introduced some divergences from German model

Criticisms and debates

• Ongoing discussions about modernization and reform of Japanese Civil Code
• Addressing societal changes and evolving legal needs

Gender equality issues

• Debates over remaining gender disparities in family law provisions
• Discussions about modernizing rules on surnames for married couples
• Addressing issues of gender-based discrimination in inheritance and property rights
• Efforts to align Civil Code more closely with constitutional principles of gender equality

Modernization challenges

• Adapting Civil Code to rapid technological changes and digital transactions
• Addressing new forms of property rights and obligations in digital age
• Balancing traditional legal concepts with needs of modern economy
• Discussions about comprehensive revision vs piecemeal amendments to Civil Code