6.4 Disability representation

Disability representation on TV has evolved from early stereotypes to more nuanced portrayals. This shift reflects changing societal attitudes and the influence of disability rights movements. Understanding this progression helps us appreciate the progress made and challenges still faced.

TV often relies on familiar tropes when depicting disabilities, like inspiration porn or villainous characters. Recognizing these stereotypes is crucial for understanding their impact on audience perceptions. Authentic representation aims to challenge these tropes through accurate portrayals and inclusion of actors with disabilities.

Historical context of disability representation

• Disability representation in television reflects broader societal attitudes and evolves alongside cultural shifts
• Understanding historical context provides insight into the progress made and challenges still faced in portraying disabilities on screen
• This section examines the trajectory of disability representation from early stereotypes to more nuanced portrayals in modern television

Early portrayals in television

Top images from around the web for Early portrayals in television

• 

  Svengali - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Caliban - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Meeting Point View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Svengali - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Caliban - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Early portrayals in television

• 

  Svengali - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Caliban - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Meeting Point View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Svengali - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Caliban - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Characterized by stereotypical and often offensive depictions of disabilities
• Focused on physical disabilities as visual shorthand for character traits (villains with facial scars)
• Relied heavily on tropes such as the "tragic hero" or "burden on society"
• Limited roles often relegated characters with disabilities to background or supporting parts

Shift towards inclusivity

• Gradual movement towards more diverse and authentic representations began in the late 20th century
• Influenced by disability rights movements and increased social awareness
• Television shows started incorporating characters with disabilities in more prominent and complex roles
• Shift from purely medical model to exploring social aspects of disability experiences

Landmark moments in representation

• "Life Goes On" (1989-1993) featured Chris Burke, an actor with Down syndrome, in a leading role
• "NYPD Blue" (1993-2005) included Detective Bobby Simone, portrayed by Jimmy Smits, who used a wheelchair
• "Breaking Bad" (2008-2013) featured RJ Mitte, an actor with cerebral palsy, playing a character with the same condition
• "Speechless" (2016-2019) centered around a family with a son who has cerebral palsy, played by Micah Fowler, who has the condition in real life

Stereotypes and tropes

• Television often relies on familiar narratives and character archetypes when portraying disabilities
• Recognizing and analyzing these tropes is crucial for understanding their impact on audience perceptions
• This section explores common stereotypes that have persisted in disability representation on television

Inspiration porn

• Portrays individuals with disabilities as sources of inspiration solely based on their disability
• Often focuses on "overcoming" disability rather than depicting it as a natural part of human diversity
• Examples include storylines where characters with disabilities are praised for ordinary activities
• Criticized for objectifying people with disabilities and reinforcing ableist attitudes

Villainous disabilities

• Associates physical or mental disabilities with evil or antagonistic characters
• Perpetuates harmful stereotypes linking disability to moral corruption or social deviance
• Often uses visible disabilities (facial scars, limb differences) as visual shorthand for villainy
• Examples include characters like Dr. Loveless in "The Wild Wild West" or Davros in "Doctor Who"

Supercrip narrative

• Depicts individuals with disabilities as having extraordinary abilities or superhuman qualities
• Suggests that people with disabilities must compensate for their condition through exceptional achievements
• Can create unrealistic expectations and pressure on individuals with disabilities in real life
• Examples include characters like Daredevil, who is blind but has heightened other senses

Authentic representation

• Focuses on portraying disabilities in a realistic and respectful manner
• Aims to challenge stereotypes and provide more accurate depictions of disability experiences
• Involves collaboration with disability communities and inclusion of individuals with disabilities in the creative process

Actors with disabilities

• Increasing trend of casting actors with disabilities to play characters with disabilities
• Provides more authentic performances and representation on screen
• Challenges the practice of "cripping up" where non-disabled actors play disabled characters
• Examples include Ali Stroker in "Glee" and "Oklahoma!" on Broadway, and Marlee Matlin in various roles

Consulting with disability communities

• Involves seeking input from disability advocacy groups and individuals with lived experiences
• Helps ensure accuracy in portraying specific disabilities and associated challenges
• Provides insights into the daily lives and perspectives of people with disabilities
• Can lead to more nuanced and realistic storylines and character development

Intersectionality in disability portrayal

• Recognizes that disability intersects with other aspects of identity (race, gender, sexuality)
• Explores how multiple marginalized identities impact characters' experiences
• Aims to provide more complex and diverse representations of disability
• Examples include Ryan O'Connell in "Special," portraying a gay man with cerebral palsy

Disability narratives

• Examines the different approaches to storytelling when it comes to disability representation
• Explores how narratives shape audience understanding and perceptions of disability
• Highlights the importance of diverse and nuanced storytelling in representing disability experiences

Medical vs social model

• Medical model focuses on disability as a condition to be cured or treated
• Social model emphasizes societal barriers and attitudes as the primary disabling factors
• Television narratives often struggle to balance these perspectives
• Shift towards social model in recent years has led to more empowering portrayals

Disability as identity

• Explores how characters with disabilities navigate their sense of self and community
• Challenges narratives that solely focus on "overcoming" disability
• Depicts disability as an integral part of a character's identity and lived experience
• Examples include Matilda "Tilly" Ramsay in "Bad Sisters," who embraces her identity as a person with dwarfism

Everyday life vs extraordinary feats

• Contrasts narratives that focus on ordinary experiences of people with disabilities
• Compares with stories that emphasize exceptional achievements or abilities
• Balancing these approaches can provide a more comprehensive representation
• Examples of everyday life portrayals include "Ramy," featuring Steve Way as a character with muscular dystrophy