6.2 Equity distribution

Equity distribution is a crucial aspect of entrepreneurship, impacting a company's ownership structure and stakeholder incentives. This topic explores various types of equity, allocation strategies, and legal considerations that founders must navigate when dividing ownership among founders, employees, advisors, and investors.

Understanding equity distribution is essential for aligning interests, attracting talent, and securing resources for growth. This section covers key concepts like common and preferred stock, vesting schedules, dilution, and tax implications, providing a comprehensive overview of equity management in startups.

Types of equity

• Equity represents ownership in a company and can be distributed in various forms to founders, employees, advisors, and investors
• The two main types of equity are common stock and preferred stock, each with different rights and privileges
• Equity can also be classified as voting or non-voting shares, which determines the holder's ability to participate in company decision-making

Common vs preferred stock

Top images from around the web for Common vs preferred stock

• 

  Information Exchange Market and the Performance of Small Businesses in Soweto View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Rules and Rights of Common and Preferred Stock | Boundless Finance View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Learning Strategies for Future Entrepreneurs: New Methodology of Stock Market Development Assessment View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Information Exchange Market and the Performance of Small Businesses in Soweto View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Rules and Rights of Common and Preferred Stock | Boundless Finance View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Common vs preferred stock

• 

  Information Exchange Market and the Performance of Small Businesses in Soweto View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Rules and Rights of Common and Preferred Stock | Boundless Finance View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Learning Strategies for Future Entrepreneurs: New Methodology of Stock Market Development Assessment View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Information Exchange Market and the Performance of Small Businesses in Soweto View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Rules and Rights of Common and Preferred Stock | Boundless Finance View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Common stock is the most basic form of equity ownership in a company and is typically held by founders and employees
  • Comes with voting rights and the potential for capital appreciation if the company succeeds
  • In the event of liquidation, common stockholders are last in line to receive any remaining assets after creditors and preferred stockholders
• Preferred stock is a class of ownership that has priority over common stock in terms of dividends and asset distribution during liquidation
  • Often held by investors and comes with additional rights such as anti-dilution protection and liquidation preferences
  • Preferred stockholders typically do not have voting rights unless specified in the agreement

Voting vs non-voting shares

• Voting shares grant the holder the right to participate in company decision-making, such as electing board members or approving major transactions
  • Typically held by founders, key employees, and some investors to maintain control over the company's direction
• Non-voting shares do not come with the right to vote on company matters but still provide ownership and the potential for financial returns
  • Often used to distribute equity to employees or advisors without diluting the control of the primary decision-makers
  • Can be an attractive option for investors who prioritize financial returns over governance

Equity allocation

• Equity allocation refers to the distribution of ownership among various stakeholders in a company, including founders, employees, advisors, and investors
• Determining the appropriate equity allocation is crucial for aligning incentives, attracting talent, and securing necessary resources for growth
• Factors to consider when allocating equity include the individual's contribution, role, and the company's stage and growth potential

Founder equity

• Founders typically receive the largest portion of equity in the early stages of a company in recognition of their vision, risk-taking, and initial contributions
  • Founder equity is often subject to vesting schedules to ensure long-term commitment and alignment with the company's success
  • As the company grows and raises additional funding, founder equity may be diluted to accommodate new investors and employees
• Considerations for founder equity include the number of co-founders, their respective roles and responsibilities, and the agreed-upon equity split

Employee equity

• Employee equity is used to attract, retain, and motivate talented individuals to join and contribute to the company's growth
  • Can be in the form of stock options, restricted stock units (RSUs), or outright stock grants
  • Employee equity is typically subject to vesting schedules to encourage long-term commitment and align interests with the company's success
• The amount of equity allocated to employees depends on factors such as their role, seniority, and the company's stage and industry benchmarks

Advisor equity

• Advisors are often granted equity in exchange for their expertise, network, and support in helping the company navigate challenges and opportunities
  • Advisor equity is typically a smaller portion compared to founders and employees, ranging from 0.1% to 1% depending on the level of involvement and value provided
  • Vesting schedules for advisor equity are usually shorter than those for employees, often ranging from 1-2 years
• Advisor equity can be an effective way to align incentives and compensate valuable contributors without significant cash outlays

Investor equity

• Investors receive equity in exchange for providing capital to fuel the company's growth and expansion
  • The amount of equity allocated to investors depends on the funding round, valuation, and negotiated terms
  • Investor equity is often in the form of preferred stock, which comes with additional rights and protections compared to common stock
• As the company raises subsequent rounds of funding, investor equity may be diluted to accommodate new investors and maintain appropriate ownership percentages

Vesting schedules

• Vesting schedules determine how equity is earned over time, aligning the interests of equity holders with the long-term success of the company
• Vesting helps ensure that equity holders, such as founders and employees, continue to contribute to the company's growth and prevents early departures from being overly rewarded
• Common vesting schedules include cliff vesting, graded vesting, and acceleration provisions

Cliff vesting

• Cliff vesting requires equity holders to remain with the company for a specified period (usually 1 year) before any portion of their equity vests
  • If the equity holder leaves before the cliff period, they forfeit all unvested equity
  • After the cliff period, a portion of the equity vests, and the remainder continues to vest according to the predetermined schedule
• Cliff vesting helps protect the company from early departures and ensures that equity holders are committed to the company's long-term success

Graded vesting

• Graded vesting allows equity to vest incrementally over a set period, typically 3-4 years
  • Vesting occurs in equal installments, such as monthly or quarterly, providing a gradual reward for continued contribution to the company
  • Example: A 4-year graded vesting schedule with monthly vesting would result in 1/48th of the equity vesting each month
• Graded vesting provides a more gradual incentive structure compared to cliff vesting and can help retain talent over an extended period

Acceleration provisions

• Acceleration provisions allow equity to vest more quickly or immediately under certain circumstances, such as a change of control (acquisition) or termination without cause
  • Single-trigger acceleration: Equity vests automatically upon a specified event, such as an acquisition
  • Double-trigger acceleration: Equity vests only if two conditions are met, such as an acquisition and termination without cause within a specified period
• Acceleration provisions help protect equity holders from losing unvested equity in the event of a major corporate transaction or unexpected termination

Equity dilution

• Equity dilution occurs when a company issues new shares, reducing the ownership percentage of existing shareholders
• Dilution is a common occurrence as companies raise additional funding, issue equity to new employees, or undergo corporate transactions
• Understanding and managing dilution is crucial for founders, employees, and investors to maintain a fair and attractive equity distribution

Pre-money vs post-money valuation

• Pre-money valuation refers to the company's value before receiving new investment, while post-money valuation includes the new investment
  • Example: If a company raises $1 million at a$4 million pre-money valuation, the post-money valuation would be $5 million
• The difference between pre-money and post-money valuation determines the amount of equity dilution experienced by existing shareholders

Down rounds vs up rounds

• A down round occurs when a company raises funds at a lower valuation than its previous funding round, resulting in significant dilution for existing shareholders
  • Down rounds can signal challenges in the company's performance or market conditions and may require anti-dilution provisions to protect earlier investors
• An up round occurs when a company raises funds at a higher valuation than its previous round, minimizing dilution for existing shareholders
  • Up rounds generally reflect strong company performance, market traction, and investor confidence

Anti-dilution provisions

• Anti-dilution provisions protect investors, typically those with preferred stock, from excessive dilution in the event of a down round
  • Weighted average anti-dilution: Adjusts the conversion price of preferred stock based on a formula that considers the price and number of shares issued in the new round
  • Full ratchet anti-dilution: Adjusts the conversion price of preferred stock to match the price of the new round, providing maximum protection against dilution
• Anti-dilution provisions can help maintain investor confidence and attract funding, but they can also create complexities in the company's equity structure

Legal considerations

• Distributing and managing equity involves various legal considerations to ensure compliance, protect stakeholder interests, and minimize potential disputes
• Key legal aspects include stock purchase agreements, the choice between restricted stock and options, and 83(b) elections for tax purposes
• Seeking guidance from experienced legal counsel is essential to navigate the complexities of equity distribution and management

Stock purchase agreements

• Stock purchase agreements outline the terms and conditions under which equity is purchased, including the number of shares, price, vesting schedule, and any restrictions or obligations
  • Helps ensure clarity and alignment between the company and equity holders regarding their rights and responsibilities
  • May include provisions such as right of first refusal, co-sale rights, and drag-along rights to manage future equity transactions
• Stock purchase agreements are legally binding contracts that protect the interests of both the company and the equity holders

Restricted stock vs options

• Restricted stock refers to shares that are granted outright to an equity holder but are subject to vesting schedules and potential forfeiture if certain conditions are not met
  • Restricted stock grants provide immediate ownership but may result in higher upfront tax liabilities for the recipient
• Stock options give the holder the right to purchase shares at a predetermined price (strike price) within a specified period, often subject to vesting schedules
  • Options provide the potential for future ownership without the immediate tax implications of restricted stock
  • Incentive stock options (ISOs) and non-qualified stock options (NSOs) have different tax treatments and requirements

83(b) election

• An 83(b) election is a tax filing that allows equity holders to pay taxes on the fair market value of restricted stock at the time of grant, rather than as the stock vests
  • By making an 83(b) election, the equity holder can potentially minimize future tax liabilities, especially if the stock appreciates significantly in value
  • The election must be filed with the IRS within 30 days of the stock grant and requires careful consideration of the potential risks and benefits
• Consulting with a tax professional is recommended when considering an 83(b) election to ensure compliance and understand the implications for the individual's tax situation

Equity management

• Effective equity management involves tracking ownership, implementing stock option plans, and facilitating liquidity events for shareholders
• Proper equity management helps maintain accurate records, comply with legal requirements, and support the company's growth and stakeholder interests
• Tools and processes for equity management include cap table maintenance, stock option plan administration, and secondary market transactions

Cap table maintenance

• A capitalization table (cap table) is a record of all the company's securities, including equity ownership, convertible debt, and options
  • Tracks the ownership percentages of each shareholder, the value of their holdings, and the dilution impact of new issuances
  • Helps ensure accurate record-keeping, inform decision-making, and facilitate due diligence during fundraising or M&A activities
• Regular cap table maintenance is essential to keep ownership records up-to-date and avoid discrepancies that could lead to legal or financial issues

Stock option plans

• Stock option plans establish the framework for granting and administering employee stock options, including eligibility, vesting schedules, and exercise procedures
  • Helps attract and retain talent by providing a clear and competitive equity compensation structure
  • Ensures compliance with legal and tax requirements, such as ISO and NSO limitations and expiration dates
• Implementing and managing stock option plans requires careful planning, documentation, and communication with employees to maximize their effectiveness as a compensation and retention tool

Secondary markets

• Secondary markets provide liquidity for shareholders by allowing them to sell their equity to other investors before a traditional exit event (IPO or acquisition)
  • Enables early investors, employees, and founders to realize some of the value of their equity holdings without waiting for a major liquidity event
  • Can help manage shareholder expectations and align incentives by providing interim liquidity options
• Facilitating secondary market transactions requires careful consideration of legal, tax, and valuation implications, as well as potential impacts on the company's cap table and future fundraising efforts

Tax implications

• Equity compensation and transactions have various tax implications for both the company and the equity holders
• Understanding and properly managing the tax aspects of equity is crucial to minimize liabilities, ensure compliance, and maximize the benefits for all parties involved
• Key tax considerations include the treatment of ordinary income vs capital gains, 409A valuations, and qualified small business stock exemptions

Ordinary income vs capital gains

• The tax treatment of equity compensation depends on the type of equity and the circumstances of the transaction
  • Ordinary income tax applies to compensation such as salary, bonuses, and the spread between the exercise price and fair market value of non-qualified stock options (NSOs) at exercise
  • Capital gains tax applies to the sale of equity, such as stock or qualified small business stock, and is generally lower than ordinary income tax rates
• Proper tax planning and structuring of equity compensation can help optimize the tax treatment and maximize the after-tax value for equity holders

409A valuations

• 409A valuations are independent appraisals of a company's fair market value, required by the IRS to ensure that stock options are granted at or above fair market value
  • Helps avoid adverse tax consequences for the company and the option holders, such as immediate taxation and potential penalties
  • Typically conducted annually or when there are significant changes in the company's valuation, such as a new funding round or a material event
• Ensuring regular and accurate 409A valuations is essential for compliance and to provide a defensible basis for the company's stock option pricing

Qualified small business stock

• Qualified small business stock (QSBS) is a tax exemption that allows founders and early investors to exclude a portion of their capital gains from federal taxes when selling eligible stock
  • To qualify, the stock must be from a C-corporation with less than $50 million in assets at the time of issuance and held for at least 5 years
  • QSBS can provide significant tax savings, with up to $10 million or 10 times the original investment (whichever is greater) excluded from capital gains taxes
• Structuring equity transactions to take advantage of QSBS exemptions can be a valuable strategy for minimizing tax liabilities and maximizing returns for early-stage investors and founders

Equity strategy

• Developing a comprehensive equity strategy is essential for startups to balance competing priorities, such as attracting talent, raising capital, and maintaining control
• An effective equity strategy aligns the interests of various stakeholders, supports the company's long-term vision, and provides a framework for making equity-related decisions
• Key considerations in crafting an equity strategy include the trade-offs between attracting talent and raising capital, maintaining control versus rewarding contributors, and balancing short-term and long-term objectives

Attracting talent vs raising capital

• Allocating equity for employee compensation can help attract and retain top talent, particularly when cash compensation may be limited in early-stage startups
  • Equity-based compensation aligns employee interests with the company's success and provides a powerful incentive for long-term commitment
  • However, allocating too much equity to employees can dilute the positions of founders and investors, potentially making the company less attractive for future fundraising
• Balancing the need to attract talent with the need to raise capital requires careful consideration of the company's stage, industry, and growth potential, as well as benchmarking against comparable companies

Maintaining control vs rewarding contributors

• Founders often face the challenge of maintaining control over the company's direction while also rewarding key contributors, such as employees and advisors, with equity
  • Issuing voting shares to founders and key decision-makers can help maintain control, while non-voting shares can be used to reward contributors without diluting control
  • Vesting schedules and equity pools can be structured to align incentives and ensure that contributors are rewarded for their ongoing commitment to the company's success
• Striking the right balance between maintaining control and rewarding contributors requires careful planning, communication, and alignment of expectations among all stakeholders

Short-term vs long-term planning

• Equity decisions made in the short term, such as early-stage equity grants or fundraising rounds, can have significant long-term implications for the company's ownership structure and future growth
  • Over-allocating equity early on can limit the company's ability to attract future talent, raise capital, or achieve a desired exit valuation
  • Under-allocating equity or setting unfavorable terms can hinder the company's ability to attract and retain the necessary talent and resources to succeed
• Developing a long-term equity plan that considers the company's vision, milestones, and potential exit strategies can help guide short-term decisions and ensure a sustainable and attractive equity structure over time
• Regularly reviewing and adjusting the equity strategy based on the company's progress, market conditions, and stakeholder feedback is essential to maintain alignment and adapt to changing circumstances