6.10 Negotiable instruments

Negotiable instruments are vital financial tools in U.S. commercial law, facilitating the transfer of monetary value. These instruments, including promissory notes, checks, and drafts, are governed by specific legal principles to ensure their validity and enforceability.

The Uniform Commercial Code sets forth requirements for negotiability, such as being in writing, containing an unconditional promise to pay, and stating a fixed amount. Understanding these rules is crucial for parties involved in commercial transactions and dispute resolution.

Types of negotiable instruments

• Negotiable instruments play a crucial role in commercial transactions and financial systems within United States law
• These instruments facilitate the transfer of monetary value and are governed by specific legal principles to ensure their validity and enforceability

Promissory notes

Top images from around the web for Promissory notes

• 

  Notes Receivable | Boundless Accounting View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Recognizing Notes Receivable | Financial Accounting View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Promissory Note - Clipboard image View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Notes Receivable | Boundless Accounting View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Recognizing Notes Receivable | Financial Accounting View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Promissory notes

• 

  Notes Receivable | Boundless Accounting View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Recognizing Notes Receivable | Financial Accounting View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Promissory Note - Clipboard image View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Notes Receivable | Boundless Accounting View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Recognizing Notes Receivable | Financial Accounting View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Written promises to pay a specified sum of money to a designated party
• Contains essential elements such as date, principal amount, interest rate, and maturity date
• Used in various contexts (loans, mortgages, business transactions)
• Transferable through endorsement, allowing the holder to become a "holder in due course"

Checks

• Written orders directing a bank to pay a specified amount to the bearer or a named payee
• Includes personal checks, cashier's checks, and certified checks
• Subject to specific rules under the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC)
• Serve as a common form of payment in everyday transactions and business dealings

Drafts and bills of exchange

• Written orders instructing a third party to pay a specified sum to the bearer or a named payee
• Involves three parties: drawer, drawee, and payee
• Used in international trade (letters of credit, documentary drafts)
• Can be sight drafts (payable on demand) or time drafts (payable at a future date)

Certificates of deposit

• Written acknowledgments by banks of receipt of money and promise to repay with interest
• Can be negotiable or non-negotiable depending on their terms
• Typically have fixed maturity dates and interest rates
• Serve as investment instruments and sources of funds for banks

Requirements for negotiability

• Negotiability is a crucial concept in United States commercial law, determining an instrument's ability to be freely transferred
• The Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) sets forth specific requirements for an instrument to be considered negotiable, ensuring its reliability in commerce

Writing and signature

• Instrument must be in writing, either handwritten or printed
• Requires a signature by the maker or drawer
• Electronic signatures may be acceptable under certain circumstances (E-SIGN Act)
• Signature can be any symbol executed or adopted with intent to authenticate the writing

Unconditional promise or order

• Must contain an unconditional promise or order to pay
• Cannot be subject to any other agreement or contingency
• Statements of consideration or transaction details do not affect negotiability
• References to other documents may be permissible if they do not make the promise conditional

Fixed amount of money

• Instrument must state a sum certain in money
• Can include interest, stated rates, or exchange rates
• Variable interest rates are acceptable if tied to a readily available standard
• Foreign currency instruments can be negotiable if the currency is specified

Payable on demand or at definite time

• Must be payable on demand or at a definite time
• "On demand" includes instruments payable at sight or on presentation
• Definite time can be a specific date, a fixed period after date, or upon the occurrence of a specified event
• Instruments payable at the will of the holder are considered payable on demand

Payable to order or bearer

• Must be payable to order or to bearer
• "Pay to the order of" language indicates negotiability
• Bearer instruments are payable to whoever possesses them
• Instruments payable to identified persons can become bearer instruments through endorsement

Parties to negotiable instruments

• Understanding the roles and responsibilities of parties involved in negotiable instruments is essential in United States commercial law
• These distinctions impact liability, rights, and obligations under the instrument

Maker vs drawer

• Maker: party who creates and signs a promissory note, promising to pay
  • Primary obligor on the instrument
  • Directly liable for payment
• Drawer: party who writes and signs a check or draft, ordering payment
  • Secondary obligor, becomes primarily liable if the instrument is dishonored
  • Typically maintains the account from which payment will be made

Payee vs holder

• Payee: person to whom the instrument is originally made payable
  • Named on the face of the instrument
  • Has the right to enforce payment or negotiate the instrument
• Holder: person in possession of a negotiable instrument
  • Can be the original payee or a subsequent transferee
  • Acquires rights to enforce payment and may qualify as a holder in due course

Endorser vs endorsee

• Endorser: party who signs the instrument to transfer it or assume liability
  • Creates a contract of secondary liability
  • May add conditions or limit their liability through special endorsements
• Endorsee: party to whom an instrument is endorsed
  • Receives the rights to the instrument from the endorser
  • May become a holder or a holder in due course, depending on circumstances

Acceptor and drawee

• Acceptor: party who agrees to pay a draft or bill of exchange
  • Usually the drawee who has accepted the instrument
  • Becomes primarily liable upon acceptance
• Drawee: party ordered to make payment on a draft or check
  • Typically a bank for checks
  • Has no liability on the instrument until acceptance

Transfer and negotiation

• Transfer and negotiation are fundamental concepts in the circulation of negotiable instruments within the United States legal system
• These processes determine how instruments change hands and the rights acquired by subsequent holders

Delivery and endorsement

• Delivery: physical transfer of possession of the instrument
  • Required for effective negotiation
  • Can be actual or constructive delivery
• Endorsement: signature of the holder on the instrument
  • Necessary for negotiation of order instruments
  • Not required for bearer instruments
• Combination of delivery and proper endorsement completes negotiation

Types of endorsements

• Blank endorsement: endorser's signature alone
  • Converts an order instrument to a bearer instrument
• Special endorsement: specifies person to whom instrument is payable
  • "Pay to the order of [specific person]"
• Restrictive endorsement: limits the purpose of the endorsement
  • "For deposit only" or "For collection"
• Qualified endorsement: endorser disclaims contract of warranty
  • "Without recourse"
• Anomalous endorsement: made by someone who is not a holder
  • Often used to add security to the instrument

Holder in due course status

• Special legal status providing maximum protection under commercial law
• Requirements for holder in due course (HDC) status:
  • Takes instrument for value
  • In good faith
  • Without notice of defects or defenses
• HDC can enforce instrument free from most defenses
• Importance in facilitating free transferability of negotiable instruments

Defenses to payment

• Defenses to payment are crucial aspects of negotiable instrument law in the United States
• Understanding these defenses is essential for parties involved in commercial transactions and dispute resolution

Real vs personal defenses

• Real defenses: valid against all holders, including holders in due course
  • Infancy (to the extent provided by state law)
  • Duress, lack of legal capacity, or illegality of the transaction
  • Fraud in the factum (fraud that induced the making of the instrument)
  • Discharge in insolvency proceedings
  • Forgery
• Personal defenses: only valid against holders who are not holders in due course
  • Fraud in the inducement
  • Failure of consideration
  • Breach of warranty
  • Unauthorized completion of an incomplete instrument
  • Prior payment

Holder in due course protection

• Holders in due course (HDC) are protected from personal defenses
• HDC status provides maximum enforceability of the instrument
• Exceptions to HDC protection:
  • Real defenses still apply
  • Federal Trade Commission (FTC) Holder Rule for consumer transactions
• Policy rationale: promotes free transferability and reliability of negotiable instruments
• Balances interests of innocent purchasers and original parties to the instrument

Liability on negotiable instruments

• Understanding liability on negotiable instruments is crucial for parties involved in commercial transactions under United States law
• The nature and extent of liability can vary depending on the role of each party and the circumstances of the instrument

Primary vs secondary liability

• Primary liability: direct obligation to pay the instrument
  • Maker of a note
  • Acceptor of a draft
  • Drawee bank on a certified check
• Secondary liability: obligation to pay if the primarily liable party defaults
  • Drawer of a check or draft
  • Endorsers
• Order of liability: determines the sequence in which parties can be held responsible
  • Primary obligors first, then secondary obligors in reverse order of endorsement

Discharge of liability

• Methods of discharge:
  • Payment in full by any party
  • Cancellation or renunciation by the holder
  • Material alteration of the instrument
  • Impairment of recourse or collateral
• Discharge of secondary parties:
  • Discharge of a prior party discharges subsequent parties
  • Unexcused delay in presentment or notice of dishonor
• Effect of discharge:
  • Terminates the party's obligation on the instrument
  • May not affect liability of other parties

Uniform Commercial Code Article 3

• Article 3 of the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) governs negotiable instruments in the United States
• This uniform law has been adopted by all states, providing consistency in commercial transactions across jurisdictions

Scope and application

• Covers negotiable instruments including promissory notes, drafts, and checks
• Applies to transactions involving negotiable instruments in commercial contexts
• Interacts with other UCC articles (Article 4 for bank deposits and collections)
• Supersedes common law rules for negotiable instruments where applicable
• Does not apply to money, payment orders governed by Article 4A, or securities

Key provisions and amendments

• Defines requirements for negotiability (UCC § 3-104)
• Establishes rules for transfer and negotiation (UCC § 3-201 to 3-207)
• Outlines holder in due course doctrine (UCC § 3-302)
• Addresses liability of parties (UCC § 3-401 to 3-420)
• Covers enforcement, presentment, and dishonor (UCC § 3-501 to 3-505)
• 1990 revisions: modernized language, addressed technological changes
• 2002 amendments: clarified issues related to lost or stolen instruments

Electronic negotiable instruments

• The rise of digital technology has led to the development of electronic negotiable instruments in the United States
• This evolution presents both opportunities and challenges within the legal framework of commercial transactions

Legal recognition and challenges

• Electronic Signatures in Global and National Commerce Act (E-SIGN) provides legal basis
• Uniform Electronic Transactions Act (UETA) adopted by most states
• Challenges in maintaining negotiability features in electronic form:
  • Ensuring uniqueness of the instrument
  • Preventing unauthorized duplication
  • Establishing control equivalent to possession
• Concept of "control" as electronic equivalent of possession for electronic chattel paper

Digital signatures and authentication

• Use of cryptographic techniques to verify authenticity and integrity
• Public Key Infrastructure (PKI) for secure digital signatures
• Biometric authentication methods (fingerprint, facial recognition)
• Blockchain technology for creating immutable records of transactions
• Legal standards for electronic signatures under E-SIGN and UETA:
  • Intent to sign
  • Association of signature with the record
  • Attribution to the signer

Banking and negotiable instruments

• Banking plays a crucial role in the use and processing of negotiable instruments within the United States financial system
• Understanding these processes is essential for comprehending the practical application of negotiable instrument law

Check clearing process

• Traditional paper-based clearing:
  • Depositary bank receives check from depositor
  • Check sent to Federal Reserve or clearinghouse
  • Presented to drawee bank for payment
  • Funds transferred between banks
• Electronic check processing:
  • Check truncation: conversion of paper check to electronic image
  • Check 21 Act: allows use of substitute checks
  • Remote deposit capture: deposit checks via mobile devices
• Automated Clearing House (ACH) network for electronic fund transfers

Electronic funds transfer

• Governed by Electronic Fund Transfer Act (EFTA) and Regulation E
• Types of electronic fund transfers:
  • Wire transfers
  • Automated Teller Machine (ATM) transactions
  • Point-of-Sale (POS) transactions
  • Direct deposits and withdrawals
• Consumer protections under EFTA:
  • Disclosure requirements
  • Error resolution procedures
  • Limitations on consumer liability for unauthorized transfers

Fraud and forgery issues

• Fraud and forgery pose significant risks in the realm of negotiable instruments within the United States legal system
• Understanding these issues is crucial for protecting the integrity of commercial transactions and allocating liability

Altered instruments

• Material alteration: unauthorized change that modifies the obligations of parties
  • Changes in amount, date, or parties
• Effect of alteration:
  • Discharge of parties who did not assent to the alteration
  • Enforcement limited to original terms for holders in due course
• Prevention measures:
  • Use of security features on checks (watermarks, holograms)
  • Electronic instruments with tamper-evident features

Forged signatures

• Forgery: unauthorized signing of another's name on an instrument
• Types of forgery:
  • Maker's or drawer's signature
  • Endorser's signature
• Legal consequences:
  • Forged maker's signature: instrument is wholly inoperative
  • Forged endorsement: does not pass title to the instrument
• Allocation of loss:
  • Generally falls on the party who took the instrument from the forger
  • Exceptions based on negligence or failure to exercise ordinary care

Bank's liability for fraud

• Duty to exercise ordinary care in paying or collecting items
• Liability for paying forged checks:
  • General rule: bank liable for paying on forged drawer's signature
  • Exception: customer's failure to promptly report forgeries
• Comparative negligence principles may apply
• Responsibility for verifying endorsements:
  • Depository bank generally responsible for forged endorsements
  • Exceptions for imposter and fictitious payee situations (UCC § 3-404, 3-405)

International aspects

• Negotiable instruments play a significant role in international trade and finance, requiring consideration of cross-border issues in United States law
• Understanding these aspects is crucial for parties engaged in global commercial transactions

Foreign currency instruments

• Negotiable instruments can be denominated in foreign currencies
• UCC recognizes foreign currency instruments as negotiable if they meet other requirements
• Exchange rate considerations:
  • Instrument may specify an exchange rate or a method for determining it
  • If not specified, the rate at the place of payment on the day of payment applies
• Risks associated with currency fluctuations:
  • Impact on value of the instrument
  • Allocation of exchange rate risk between parties

Cross-border negotiation issues

• Conflict of laws: determining which jurisdiction's laws apply
  • Place of issuance, place of payment, or parties' choice of law
• International conventions and treaties:
  • United Nations Convention on International Bills of Exchange and International Promissory Notes (not widely adopted)
  • Hague Convention Abolishing the Requirement of Legalisation for Foreign Public Documents
• Recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments related to negotiable instruments
• Impact of international sanctions and export controls on negotiable instrument transactions
• Compliance with anti-money laundering (AML) and know-your-customer (KYC) regulations in cross-border transactions