6.3 Opinion polls and their influence on democracy

Opinion polls significantly shape public perception and political outcomes in democracies. They influence media coverage, voter behavior, and campaign strategies. However, polls have limitations and can be misused, potentially distorting the democratic process.

Understanding polling methodology and its impact is crucial for media literacy. Voters must critically evaluate poll results, considering factors like sampling techniques, question wording, and potential biases. This knowledge helps citizens make informed decisions and resist manipulation through polls.

Opinion Polling Methodology and Limitations

Sampling Techniques and Error

Top images from around the web for Sampling Techniques and Error

• 

  Margen de error - Wikipedia, la enciclopedia libre View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Sampling Techniques | OER Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Stratified sampling - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Margen de error - Wikipedia, la enciclopedia libre View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Sampling Techniques | OER Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Sampling Techniques and Error

• 

  Margen de error - Wikipedia, la enciclopedia libre View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Sampling Techniques | OER Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Stratified sampling - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Margen de error - Wikipedia, la enciclopedia libre View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Sampling Techniques | OER Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Opinion polls survey a representative sample of the population using techniques like random sampling (selecting participants by chance) and stratified sampling (dividing the population into subgroups and sampling from each)
• Sampling error is the difference between the sample results and the true population values, often expressed as a margin of error
  • Sample size and population size affect the margin of error, with larger samples generally producing smaller margins of error
  • For example, a poll with a sample size of 1,000 and a population of 100,000 might have a margin of error of ±3%
• Response bias occurs when respondents' answers do not accurately reflect their true beliefs due to factors like social desirability bias (answering in a way that will be viewed favorably), acquiescence bias (tendency to agree with statements), and extremity bias (tendency to choose extreme responses)

Question Design and Polling Methods

• Question wording significantly shapes poll responses, with slight variations in phrasing or order leading to different results
  • For instance, asking "Do you support or oppose policy X?" can yield different responses than "Do you oppose or support policy X?"
• The mode and medium of polling influence outcomes, as respondents may answer differently in online polls compared to live telephone interviews
  • Online polls allow for more visual aids and complex question formats, while live interviews may be influenced by social desirability bias
• Polls are a snapshot of public opinion at a specific moment and may not capture evolving sentiment, especially during fast-moving events or campaigns
  • For example, a poll conducted before a major campaign announcement or scandal may not reflect the impact of those events on public opinion

Impact of Opinion Polls on Elections

Media Coverage and Voter Behavior

• Horse race coverage in the media heavily emphasizes poll standings, potentially overshadowing substantive policy issues
  • Candidates may allocate more time and resources to states or demographics where they are polling well, neglecting others
• Strategic voting occurs when voters base decisions on a candidate's perceived chance of winning based on polls, rather than voting for their preferred candidate
  • In a close three-way race, a voter might choose their second-choice candidate who is polling higher to avoid "wasting" their vote
• Strong poll numbers attract donors and endorsements, while campaigns struggling in the polls may lose support
  • A candidate leading in early polls may receive a flood of donations, allowing them to expand their campaign operations and ad buys

Polling Aggregation and Close Races

• Polling aggregation and forecasting models (FiveThirtyEight) have increased the prominence of polls in shaping perceptions of political races
  • These models combine multiple polls to produce more stable estimates of public opinion and forecast election outcomes
• In close races, polls can create a self-fulfilling prophecy by discouraging turnout among supporters of a candidate perceived to be losing
  • If polls show a candidate trailing by a wide margin, their supporters may feel that their vote won't make a difference and stay home
• Political leaders use favorable polls to claim mandates for their agendas and pressure legislators to fall in line
  • A president with a high approval rating might argue that the public supports their policy proposals and demand that Congress pass them

Bandwagon Effect in Opinion Polls

Perception of Consensus and Social Proof

• The bandwagon effect suggests that people are more likely to adopt beliefs or behaviors perceived as popular or trending in polls
  • As more people express support for a candidate or policy in polls, others may follow suit to align with the majority
• Polls can create an illusion of consensus, where people assume the majority opinion is more widespread than it actually is
  • If a poll shows 60% support for a policy, people may overestimate the policy's popularity and feel pressure to conform
• Media coverage of polls amplifies the bandwagon effect by repeatedly emphasizing the majority opinion
  • Constant reporting on a candidate's polling lead can make their victory seem inevitable, attracting more supporters

Herding and Pluralistic Ignorance

• Irrational herding can result from the bandwagon effect, as individuals rely on collective opinion instead of individual judgment
  • In a stock market bubble, investors may continue buying overvalued stocks because everyone else is doing it, leading to a crash
• Social proof theory suggests that people determine what is correct by looking at what others believe, especially under uncertainty
  • When faced with an unfamiliar ballot measure, voters may base their decision on which side is polling higher
• Pluralistic ignorance emerges when people privately reject a norm but believe that most others accept it based on how public opinion is portrayed
  • If polls consistently show high approval for a leader, people may express support publicly even if they privately disapprove

Ethical Considerations in Opinion Polls

Misrepresentation and Lack of Transparency

• Selective reporting of poll results can paint a misleading picture of public opinion
  • Media may focus on outlier polls or omit important context like methodology and margin of error
• Conflicts of interest arise when polling organizations have financial or ideological ties to campaigns, interest groups, or media outlets
  • A poll sponsored by a partisan think tank may be designed to produce results favorable to a particular ideology
• Push polls are negative campaigning disguised as opinion polling, designed to spread rumors rather than measure public sentiment
  • A push poll might ask leading questions like "If you knew Candidate X had a history of tax fraud, would you be more or less likely to vote for them?"
• Lack of transparency in polling methodology, such as not disclosing full question wording or sample composition, can obscure potential biases
  • A poll that oversamples a particular demographic group may produce skewed results if the methodology is not disclosed

Voter Suppression and Premature Projections

• Failure to adjust for nonresponse bias can skew poll results, as those who respond may differ systematically from those who do not
  • Oversampling techniques and weighting adjustments can mitigate nonresponse bias, but they can also be misused to manipulate results
• Premature election projections based on early returns or exit polls can influence voter behavior and potentially affect outcomes in close races
  • If media outlets project a winner before all polls have closed, voters who have not yet cast ballots may be discouraged from doing so
• Polling data can be misused to suppress voter turnout by creating a false impression that the outcome is already decided
  • If polls show a wide margin between candidates, campaigns may engage in negative messaging to convince opposing voters that turning out is futile