6.4 Social media screening and background checks

Social media screening has become a common practice in hiring, with employers reviewing candidates' online presence for insights. This raises ethical concerns about privacy, fairness, and discrimination, as personal information may be used to make hiring decisions.

Employers must navigate legal and ethical considerations when conducting social media screenings. Best practices include obtaining consent, focusing on job-relevant information, and applying screenings consistently to all candidates to mitigate risks and ensure fairness.

Social media screening overview

• Social media screening involves reviewing a job candidate's online presence and activity as part of the hiring process
• Employers use social media screening to gather additional information about candidates beyond traditional application materials
• The practice has become increasingly common in recent years due to the widespread use of social media platforms (Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn)

Prevalence in hiring practices

Top images from around the web for Prevalence in hiring practices

• 

  5 categories of social media measurement | The Social Media … | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Charts, Diagrams, and Graphic Organizers | Business Communication Skills for Managers View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Power of Social Media in finding Job View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  5 categories of social media measurement | The Social Media … | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Charts, Diagrams, and Graphic Organizers | Business Communication Skills for Managers View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Prevalence in hiring practices

• 

  5 categories of social media measurement | The Social Media … | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Charts, Diagrams, and Graphic Organizers | Business Communication Skills for Managers View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Power of Social Media in finding Job View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  5 categories of social media measurement | The Social Media … | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Charts, Diagrams, and Graphic Organizers | Business Communication Skills for Managers View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• A significant percentage of employers (70% according to CareerBuilder survey) conduct social media screening for job candidates
• Social media screening is more common for certain industries (marketing, public relations) and positions (customer-facing roles)
• Some companies have formalized social media screening as part of their standard hiring procedures

Potential benefits for employers

• Gain insights into a candidate's personality, interests, and communication style
• Identify red flags (inappropriate content, discriminatory views) that may not be apparent in a resume or interview
• Verify information provided in the application (education, work history)
• Assess a candidate's fit with company culture and values

Ethical considerations

• Social media screening raises important ethical questions about privacy, fairness, and the use of personal information in hiring decisions
• Employers must balance their desire for information with respect for candidates' rights and the potential for unintended consequences

Privacy concerns

• Candidates may consider their social media activity to be private and separate from their professional lives
• Accessing and using personal information without consent could be seen as an invasion of privacy
• Employers may inadvertently access protected characteristics (age, religion, sexual orientation) that should not be considered in hiring

Fairness and discrimination issues

• Social media screening could lead to bias and discrimination if not applied consistently across all candidates
• Employers may make judgments based on factors unrelated to job performance (political views, lifestyle choices)
• Certain groups (minorities, women) may be disproportionately affected by social media screening due to societal biases

Accuracy and context of information

• Social media posts can be taken out of context or misinterpreted without full understanding of the situation
• Information found online may be outdated, incomplete, or inaccurate
• Candidates may have limited control over content posted about them by others (friends, family, colleagues)

Legal landscape

• The legal framework surrounding social media screening is still evolving as the practice becomes more widespread
• Employers must navigate a complex web of federal, state, and local laws related to privacy, discrimination, and employment

Current laws and regulations

• Federal laws (Fair Credit Reporting Act, Title VII of Civil Rights Act) provide some protections for candidates
• Some states have enacted laws specifically addressing social media screening (prohibiting requesting passwords, requiring disclosure of screening practices)
• Employers must also consider industry-specific regulations (healthcare, finance) that may impose additional restrictions

Compliance requirements for employers

• Obtain written consent from candidates before conducting social media screening
• Use a third-party screening service that complies with Fair Credit Reporting Act requirements
• Have a clear, written policy outlining the purpose and scope of social media screening
• Document the decision-making process and ensure consistency across all candidates

Employee rights and protections

• Employees and candidates have the right to keep certain information private (medical history, genetic information)
• Discrimination based on protected characteristics (race, gender, age) is illegal even if discovered through social media
• Candidates may have legal recourse if they believe they were unfairly denied employment based on social media information

Best practices for employers

• Employers can mitigate legal and ethical risks by following best practices for social media screening
• Developing a thoughtful, consistent approach can help ensure that screening is fair, relevant, and compliant

Establishing clear policies

• Create a written policy outlining the purpose, scope, and procedures for social media screening
• Specify what types of information will be considered and how it will be used in the hiring process
• Communicate the policy to all employees involved in hiring and provide training on proper implementation

Obtaining consent from candidates

• Notify candidates that social media screening will be conducted as part of the hiring process
• Obtain written consent from candidates before accessing their social media profiles
• Allow candidates to opt-out of social media screening without penalty

Consistent and unbiased application

• Apply social media screening consistently to all candidates for a given position
• Use objective criteria for evaluating social media information and document the decision-making process
• Have multiple people review social media profiles to reduce the potential for individual bias

Focus on job-relevant information

• Limit social media screening to information that is directly relevant to the job requirements and responsibilities
• Avoid making judgments based on personal characteristics or beliefs unrelated to job performance
• Consider the context and reliability of social media information before making hiring decisions

Background check basics

• Social media screening is just one component of a comprehensive background check process
• Employers may use a variety of methods to verify candidate information and assess suitability for a position

Traditional vs social media checks

• Traditional background checks may include criminal records, credit reports, and reference checks
• Social media screening provides additional insight into a candidate's online presence and behavior
• Social media information should be considered alongside, not in place of, traditional background check methods

Information typically included

• Criminal records and public court documents
• Credit reports and financial history
• Employment and education verification
• Professional licenses and certifications
• Driving records (for positions requiring operation of vehicles)

Third-party screening services

• Many employers outsource background checks to specialized screening services
• These services can access a wider range of information and ensure compliance with legal requirements
• Employers must obtain candidate consent and follow Fair Credit Reporting Act guidelines when using third-party services

Candidate perspectives

• As social media screening becomes more common, candidates are increasingly aware of the potential impact on their job prospects
• Candidates may take proactive steps to manage their online presence and protect their privacy

Awareness of screening practices

• Candidates are becoming more savvy about employers' use of social media in hiring
• Some may adjust privacy settings or limit public access to their profiles
• Others may curate their online presence to showcase professional accomplishments and interests

Managing online presence and reputation

• Candidates can actively manage their online reputation by being mindful of the content they post and share
• Building a positive personal brand through social media can be an asset in the job search process
• Regularly monitoring online presence can help identify and address any potentially damaging content

Recourse for unfair treatment

• Candidates who believe they have been unfairly denied employment based on social media information may have legal options
• Filing a complaint with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission or state fair employment practices agency
• Pursuing a discrimination lawsuit against the employer
• Seeking assistance from privacy advocacy organizations or legal aid clinics

Future developments and trends

• As social media continues to evolve, so too will the landscape of social media screening in hiring
• Employers and candidates alike will need to stay informed about emerging platforms, technologies, and legal developments

Evolving social media platforms

• New social media platforms and features are constantly emerging, presenting new opportunities and challenges for screening
• Employers may need to adapt their screening practices to keep pace with changing social media usage patterns
• Candidates may need to be proactive in managing their presence across a wider range of platforms

Potential for new regulations

• As social media screening becomes more widespread, there may be increased pressure for additional legal protections for candidates
• Some states are considering laws that would prohibit employers from requiring access to candidates' social media accounts
• Federal lawmakers may also weigh in with new regulations or guidance on the use of social media in hiring

Balancing employer needs and candidate privacy

• The future of social media screening will likely involve a continued balancing act between employers' desire for information and candidates' privacy rights
• Employers may need to become more transparent about their screening practices and provide clear guidelines for candidates
• Candidates may need to take a more active role in curating their online presence and advocating for their privacy interests
• Collaboration between employers, lawmakers, and privacy advocates can help ensure that social media screening practices are fair, ethical, and compliant with evolving legal standards