6.3 State Supreme Courts and Constitutional Interpretation

State supreme courts wield immense power as the ultimate arbiters of state law and constitutions. They interpret laws, resolve disputes, and establish precedents that shape the legal landscape within their states.

These courts employ various methods of constitutional interpretation, from textualism to the living constitution approach. Their decisions significantly impact public policy, civil rights, and the balance of power, often leading to far-reaching changes in areas like education and marriage equality.

The Role and Impact of State Supreme Courts

State supreme courts as ultimate arbiters

Top images from around the web for State supreme courts as ultimate arbiters

• 

  The Dual Court System – American Government (2e) View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chapter Three: Courts in the United States – CRIMJ 100 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  U S Courts: Structure and Procedure | United States Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Dual Court System – American Government (2e) View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chapter Three: Courts in the United States – CRIMJ 100 View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for State supreme courts as ultimate arbiters

• 

  The Dual Court System – American Government (2e) View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chapter Three: Courts in the United States – CRIMJ 100 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  U S Courts: Structure and Procedure | United States Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Dual Court System – American Government (2e) View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chapter Three: Courts in the United States – CRIMJ 100 View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• State supreme courts hold the highest judicial authority within their respective states
  • Have the final say on matters related to state constitutions and state laws
  • Decisions bind lower state courts
• Interpret and apply state constitutions
  • Ensure state laws and executive actions align with the state constitution
  • Strike down state laws or executive orders that violate the state constitution
• Resolve disputes and controversies arising under state law
  • Hear appeals from lower state courts
  • Provide guidance and clarification on interpreting state statutes
• Establish legal precedents that shape the state's legal landscape
  • Create case law that guides lower courts and influences future legal decisions within the state (stare decisis)

Methods of constitutional interpretation

• Textualism
  • Focuses on the plain meaning of the constitutional text
  • Interprets the constitution based on the ordinary meaning of the words at the time they were written
  • Avoids considering external factors or evolving societal norms
• Originalism
  • Seeks to interpret the constitution according to the original intent or understanding of its framers
  • Relies on historical evidence and context to determine the meaning of constitutional provisions
  • Aims to maintain the original principles and values embodied in the constitution
• Living Constitution Approach
  • Views the constitution as a dynamic document that can adapt to changing times and societal needs
  • Interprets the constitution in light of evolving values, norms, and social conditions
  • Allows for a more flexible and expansive reading of constitutional rights and protections (right to privacy)
• State supreme courts may employ a combination of these methods or favor one approach over others
  • The chosen method of interpretation can significantly impact the outcome of cases and the development of state constitutional law (gun rights, abortion)

The Significance of State Supreme Court Decisions

Impact of state court decisions

• Public Policy
  • Shape public policy by interpreting and applying state laws
  • Uphold, strike down, or modify policies enacted by the legislative or executive branches
  • Influence the direction and implementation of policies (education, healthcare, environmental regulation)
• Civil Rights
  • Play a crucial role in protecting and expanding civil rights within their states
  • Interpret state constitutional provisions related to individual rights and liberties
  • Affect issues such as equality, privacy, freedom of speech, and due process rights (same-sex marriage, racial discrimination)
• Balance of Power
  • Impact the balance of power among the three branches of state government
  • Act as a check on the legislative and executive branches, ensuring they operate within constitutional limits
  • Define the scope of each branch's authority and resolve disputes between them (gubernatorial powers, legislative redistricting)

Notable state supreme court cases

• Goodridge v. Department of Public Health (Massachusetts, 2003)
  • Legalized same-sex marriage in Massachusetts
  • Paved the way for other states to recognize and legalize same-sex marriage
• Serrano v. Priest (California, 1971)
  • Ruled that California's school financing system, which relied heavily on local property taxes, was unconstitutional
  • Led to reforms in school funding and efforts to reduce disparities between wealthy and poor school districts
• Edgewood Independent School District v. Kirby (Texas, 1989)
  • Found that Texas's school financing system violated the state constitution's guarantee of an efficient and equitable education
  • Prompted legislative action to overhaul the state's education funding formula
• These cases demonstrate the significant impact state supreme court decisions have on shaping state policies, advancing civil rights, and addressing social and economic issues within their jurisdictions (education funding, LGBTQ+ rights)