7.1 Campaign finance and political action committees (PACs)

Campaign finance and PACs play a crucial role in shaping elections and policy. These organizations raise and spend money to influence outcomes, often targeting competitive races where their contributions can have the most impact.

PACs come in various forms, from connected to nonconnected, leadership to super PACs. While regulations aim to limit their influence, PACs continue to adapt their strategies, sparking ongoing debates about money in politics and its effects on democratic processes.

PACs and Campaign Financing

Role of PACs in Influencing Elections

Top images from around the web for Role of PACs in Influencing Elections

• 

  Chapter 54: Campaign Finance – Attenuated Democracy View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Pathways of Interest Group Influence | American National Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Pathways of Interest Group Influence – Introduction to American Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chapter 54: Campaign Finance – Attenuated Democracy View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Pathways of Interest Group Influence | American National Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Role of PACs in Influencing Elections

• 

  Chapter 54: Campaign Finance – Attenuated Democracy View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Pathways of Interest Group Influence | American National Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Pathways of Interest Group Influence – Introduction to American Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chapter 54: Campaign Finance – Attenuated Democracy View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Pathways of Interest Group Influence | American National Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Political Action Committees (PACs) are organizations that raise and spend money to influence elections and legislation
  • Connected to corporations, labor unions, trade associations, or ideological groups
• PACs pool campaign contributions from members and donate those funds to campaigns for or against candidates, ballot initiatives, or legislation
• PACs aim to elect or defeat candidates based on their alignment with the PAC's interests or ideology
  • Often target competitive races where their contributions can have the most impact

Impact of PAC Contributions on Electoral Outcomes

• Research has shown correlations between PAC contributions and electoral success, although the causal relationship is debated
  • Other factors like incumbent advantage and district characteristics also influence outcomes
• Critics argue that PACs give special interests disproportionate influence in elections and policymaking
• Proponents claim PACs increase political participation and support candidates who share the values of PAC donors

PAC Types and Funding

Connected and Nonconnected PACs

• Connected PACs are established and administered by corporations, labor unions, membership organizations or trade associations
  • Can only solicit contributions from individuals associated with the connected or sponsoring organization
• Nonconnected PACs are financially independent and ideologically driven, organized around a central issue or cause
  • Can solicit funds from the general public and have no connected organization

Leadership PACs and Super PACs

• Leadership PACs are formed by current or former elected officials to support candidates of their choosing
  • Not affiliated with the candidate's own campaign and can accept donations from other PACs and individuals
• Super PACs can raise and spend unlimited funds from corporations, unions, and individuals to advocate for or against political candidates
  • Prohibited from coordinating with candidates or campaigns
  • Rose to prominence after the Supreme Court's Citizens United v. FEC decision in 2010 that lifted restrictions on independent expenditures by corporations and unions
• Hybrid PACs, also known as Carey committees, can operate as both a traditional PAC, contributing funds to a candidate's committee, and as a super PAC that makes independent expenditures

Campaign Finance Regulation Impact

Key Laws and Contribution Limits

• Campaign finance laws at the federal and state levels regulate the amounts and sources of money that can be raised and spent to influence elections
  • Key laws include the Federal Election Campaign Act (FECA) and the Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act (BCRA)
• Regulations typically limit the amount that individuals and PACs can contribute to candidates, parties, and other PACs
  • These limits aim to prevent corruption and the appearance of quid pro quo arrangements
• Disclosure requirements mandate that PACs and campaigns report the sources and amounts of contributions and expenditures
  • This transparency is intended to inform voters and prevent illegal or unethical practices

Adaptation Strategies and Regulatory Debates

• Interest groups and PACs often adapt their strategies to navigate regulatory constraints
  • Shifting resources to independent expenditures or issue advocacy that is not explicitly tied to electoral outcomes
• Research suggests that contribution limits can level the playing field between incumbents and challengers, as incumbents tend to attract more PAC contributions
  • However, limits may also incentivize interest groups to find alternative ways to exert influence
• Critics argue that regulations infringe on free speech rights and have not effectively limited the influence of money in politics
• Proponents contend that reasonable regulations are necessary to maintain the integrity of the democratic process

PAC Contributions vs Voting Patterns

Electoral and Access Strategies

• Interest groups and PACs often contribute to candidates who already align with their policy positions, hoping to help elect legislators who will support their agenda (electoral strategy)
• PACs may also pursue an access strategy, contributing to incumbent legislators in positions of power, regardless of party or ideology, to gain access and build relationships that can influence policy decisions

Correlations and Causality Debates

• Research has identified patterns of correlation between PAC contributions and legislative voting behavior, particularly on issues of high salience to the contributing groups
  • However, the direction of causality is often unclear
  • Legislators may vote in ways that align with their contributors' interests due to shared ideology, constituent preferences, or other factors, rather than as a direct result of PAC influence
• Some studies suggest that PAC contributions have a more discernible impact on low-salience or narrow, industry-specific issues that do not attract broad public attention

Concerns and Defenses

• Critics contend that the appearance of quid pro quo arrangements between PACs and legislators erodes public trust in government and raises concerns about undue influence
• Defenders argue that PAC contributions are a form of constitutionally protected political speech and that voting decisions are influenced by a multitude of factors beyond campaign contributions