7.1 The Great American Novel concept

The Great American Novel concept emerged in the late 19th century as writers sought to capture the essence of American experience. It reflected the nation's growing cultural confidence and ambition following the Civil War and rapid industrialization.

This idea shaped generations of writers, influencing their aspirations and creative approaches. It also impacted how American literature is taught, studied, and marketed, creating expectations for ambitious works that tackle big themes and social issues.

Origins of the concept

• Emerged in the late 19th century as American literature sought to establish its own identity distinct from European traditions
• Reflected the growing cultural confidence and ambition of the United States following the Civil War and rapid industrialization

Early literary aspirations

Top images from around the web for Early literary aspirations

• 

  Great American Novel - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Great American Novel - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  American Literature I: An Anthology of Texts From Early America the Early 20th Century – Simple ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Great American Novel - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Great American Novel - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Early literary aspirations

• 

  Great American Novel - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Great American Novel - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  American Literature I: An Anthology of Texts From Early America the Early 20th Century – Simple ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Great American Novel - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Great American Novel - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Writers aimed to capture the essence of American experience in expansive, ambitious works
• Sought to create a distinctly American literary voice that reflected the nation's democratic ideals and diverse landscapes
• Drew inspiration from European literary traditions while striving to forge a unique American style
• Emphasized themes of individualism, frontier spirit, and social mobility

Cultural significance

• Represented a desire to define and celebrate American national identity through literature
• Served as a means of cultural self-reflection and critique during a period of rapid social and economic change
• Contributed to the formation of a shared national narrative and mythology
• Influenced public discourse on American values, history, and social issues

Characteristics of great novels

• Embody the complexity and contradictions of American society and culture
• Explore universal themes through distinctly American contexts and experiences
• Demonstrate literary innovation in form, style, or narrative technique

Scope and ambition

• Tackle broad, sweeping narratives that encompass multiple aspects of American life
• Attempt to capture the totality of American experience across diverse regions, social classes, and time periods
• Often employ epic or encyclopedic structures to convey the vastness of American society
• Incorporate historical events and social movements as backdrops for personal narratives

American themes and values

• Explore concepts of individualism, self-reliance, and the pursuit of the American Dream
• Grapple with issues of race, class, and social mobility in American society
• Examine the tension between tradition and progress, rural and urban life
• Address the complexities of American identity and the immigrant experience

Linguistic innovation

• Incorporate regional dialects and vernacular speech to capture authentic American voices
• Experiment with narrative techniques to reflect the fragmentation and diversity of American experience
• Develop new literary forms and styles to express uniquely American sensibilities
• Challenge conventional literary norms to push the boundaries of storytelling

Notable contenders

• Represent seminal works that have shaped the discourse around the Great American Novel
• Continue to influence contemporary American literature and cultural discussions

Moby-Dick vs Huckleberry Finn

• Moby-Dick (1851) by Herman Melville epitomizes the ambitious scope and symbolic depth associated with the Great American Novel
• Explores themes of obsession, man vs nature, and the dark side of American ambition
• Huckleberry Finn (1884) by Mark Twain captures the vernacular voice and moral complexities of 19th-century America
• Addresses issues of race, freedom, and social hypocrisy through the lens of a young boy's journey

The Great Gatsby

• F. Scott Fitzgerald's 1925 novel embodies the Jazz Age and critiques the American Dream
• Explores themes of wealth, class, and the corruption of the American ideal
• Uses lyrical prose and symbolic imagery to capture the spirit of the Roaring Twenties
• Continues to resonate with readers as a quintessential American story of aspiration and disillusionment

Beloved

• Toni Morrison's 1987 novel reimagines the Great American Novel through the lens of African American experience
• Addresses the legacy of slavery and its impact on individual and collective identity
• Employs magical realism and non-linear narrative to explore trauma and memory
• Challenges traditional notions of the Great American Novel by centering marginalized voices and experiences

Critical debates

• Ongoing discussions in literary circles and academia about the validity and relevance of the Great American Novel concept
• Reflect changing perspectives on American literature and culture over time

Defining greatness

• Debates center on criteria for literary merit, cultural impact, and enduring relevance
• Questions arise about the balance between artistic innovation and popular appeal
• Considerations include the novel's ability to capture the zeitgeist of its era while remaining timeless
• Discussions explore the role of critical reception, academic study, and popular readership in determining greatness

Canon formation and revision

• Examines the process by which certain novels become enshrined in the literary canon
• Addresses the role of academic institutions, literary critics, and cultural gatekeepers in shaping the canon
• Considers the impact of changing social values and historical perspectives on canon revision
• Explores efforts to expand the canon to include previously marginalized voices and experiences

Representation and diversity

• Questions the historical dominance of white male authors in discussions of the Great American Novel
• Examines how diverse voices and experiences can reshape understanding of American literature
• Considers the role of intersectionality in capturing the complexity of American identity
• Debates the balance between acknowledging historical literary traditions and promoting inclusivity

Evolution of the concept

• Traces the changing interpretations and expectations of the Great American Novel over time
• Reflects broader shifts in American society, culture, and literary movements

19th century expectations

• Focused on creating a distinct American literary voice separate from European traditions
• Emphasized grand narratives that captured the spirit of westward expansion and national growth
• Valued realism and detailed portrayals of American life across diverse regions
• Sought to establish a national literary tradition that could rival European classics

Modernist interpretations

• Shifted towards more experimental and fragmented narratives reflecting urban experiences
• Incorporated stream-of-consciousness techniques and non-linear storytelling
• Explored themes of alienation, disillusionment, and the impact of rapid technological change
• Challenged traditional narrative structures and linguistic conventions

Postmodern challenges

• Questioned the very notion of a single, definitive Great American Novel
• Embraced plurality, irony, and metafictional techniques
• Explored the constructed nature of reality and the limitations of language
• Incorporated diverse cultural influences and blurred boundaries between high and low art

Impact on American literature

• Shaped the aspirations and creative approaches of generations of American writers
• Influenced the way American literature is taught, studied, and marketed

Influence on writers

• Inspired authors to tackle ambitious, sweeping narratives that capture the American experience
• Encouraged experimentation with form, style, and narrative techniques
• Created a sense of literary lineage and tradition for American writers to engage with or rebel against
• Motivated writers to address pressing social and cultural issues through their work

Reader expectations

• Shaped public perceptions of what constitutes important or significant American literature
• Created a market for ambitious, socially engaged novels that tackle big themes
• Influenced reading habits and preferences for certain types of narratives or writing styles
• Contributed to the formation of a shared cultural literacy around key American texts

Publishing industry effects

• Influenced marketing strategies and promotional campaigns for literary fiction
• Affected acquisition decisions and the types of novels publishers seek
• Impacted the way books are packaged and presented to readers (cover design, blurbs)
• Contributed to the creation of literary prizes and awards that shape the literary landscape

Contemporary perspectives

• Reflect ongoing reevaluations of the Great American Novel concept in light of changing social and cultural dynamics
• Consider the impact of globalization and digital technology on American literature

Multicultural reinterpretations

• Emphasize the importance of diverse voices and experiences in defining American literature
• Explore how immigrant narratives and transnational identities reshape notions of American-ness
• Reconsider historical narratives from perspectives of previously marginalized groups
• Examine how intersectionality and hybrid identities complicate traditional ideas of the American experience

Digital age considerations

• Explore how digital media and online platforms are changing the way stories are told and consumed
• Consider the impact of social media on narrative structure and language use
• Examine the role of hypertext and interactive storytelling in reimagining the novel form
• Discuss how digital publishing and self-publishing are democratizing access to literary production

Global reception

• Analyze how American literature is perceived and interpreted in international contexts
• Examine the influence of American literary traditions on global writing and vice versa
• Consider how translation and cultural adaptation affect the reception of American novels abroad
• Explore the concept of world literature and its relationship to the idea of a Great American Novel

Critiques and controversies

• Examine ongoing debates and criticisms surrounding the concept of the Great American Novel
• Reflect broader discussions about representation, power, and cultural value in literature

Elitism and exclusion

• Critique the concept as reinforcing a narrow, elite-driven view of literary merit
• Examine how academic institutions and literary establishments perpetuate certain canons
• Discuss the role of cultural capital and access to education in shaping literary tastes
• Consider alternative models for valuing and celebrating diverse literary traditions

Gender and racial bias

• Analyze the historical underrepresentation of women and writers of color in Great American Novel discussions
• Examine how gender and racial stereotypes have influenced literary criticism and canon formation
• Explore efforts to recover and revalue works by marginalized authors from earlier periods
• Discuss the impact of feminist and postcolonial literary theories on reevaluating the American literary canon

Commercial vs literary merit

• Debate the relationship between popular success and literary quality
• Examine how market forces and publishing trends influence perceptions of literary greatness
• Consider the role of film adaptations and multimedia tie-ins in shaping a novel's cultural impact
• Discuss the tension between accessibility and complexity in evaluating literary merit