7.4 Immigration and Its Effect on the Labor Market

Immigration transformed America's labor market during the Gilded Age. Millions of newcomers, mainly from Southern and Eastern Europe, flocked to cities and factories. This massive influx reshaped the workforce, fueling rapid industrialization but also sparking tensions with native-born workers.

Immigrant labor powered key industries like railroads, steel, and textiles. While providing cheap labor for economic growth, immigrants often faced exploitation and discrimination. Their presence sparked debates on wages, working conditions, and American identity that would shape labor relations for decades to come.

Immigration Patterns in the Gilded Age

Massive Influx and Changing Demographics

Top images from around the web for Massive Influx and Changing Demographics

• 

  The Gilded Age 1876-1900 - FamilySearch Wiki View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Introduction | HIST 1302: US after 1877 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Rise of Immigration | Boundless US History View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Gilded Age 1876-1900 - FamilySearch Wiki View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Introduction | HIST 1302: US after 1877 View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Massive Influx and Changing Demographics

• 

  The Gilded Age 1876-1900 - FamilySearch Wiki View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Introduction | HIST 1302: US after 1877 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Rise of Immigration | Boundless US History View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Gilded Age 1876-1900 - FamilySearch Wiki View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Introduction | HIST 1302: US after 1877 View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Gilded Age (1870-1900) witnessed unprecedented immigration to the United States, primarily from Southern and Eastern Europe
• Push factors driving immigration
  • Economic hardship in home countries (widespread poverty, lack of job opportunities)
  • Political instability (revolutions, wars, oppressive regimes)
  • Religious persecution (anti-Semitism in Eastern Europe, restrictions on religious minorities)
• Pull factors attracting immigrants to the United States
  • Economic opportunities (industrialization, urbanization, higher wages)
  • Political freedom (democratic system, constitutional rights)
  • Promise of land ownership (Homestead Act of 1862)
• Steamship technology advancements enabled faster and cheaper transatlantic travel
  • Reduced journey time from months to weeks
  • Lowered costs made immigration accessible to more people
• Shift in immigration patterns from Northern and Western European countries to Southern and Eastern European countries
  • Earlier waves primarily from (Ireland, Germany, Scandinavia)
  • Later waves predominantly from (Italy, Poland, Russia, Austria-Hungary)

Urban Settlement and Policy Changes

• Formation of ethnic enclaves and immigrant communities in major urban centers
  • Created distinct cultural neighborhoods (Little Italy, Chinatown)
  • Provided support networks for new arrivals
  • Preserved cultural traditions and languages
• Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 marked a significant shift in U.S. immigration policy
  • First major restrictive immigration law in U.S. history
  • Prohibited Chinese laborers from entering the country
  • Set precedent for future discriminatory legislation based on national origin

Immigration's Impact on Labor

Labor Market Dynamics

• Influx of immigrants significantly increased the supply of unskilled labor in the American workforce
  • Created a surplus of workers in many industries
  • Allowed for rapid expansion of manufacturing and construction sectors
• Increased labor supply generally led to downward pressure on wages
  • Particularly affected industries heavily employing immigrant workers (textiles, mining)
  • Native workers often saw their wages stagnate or decline
• Creation of a dual labor market
  • Immigrants often occupied lower-paying, less desirable jobs (factory work, domestic service)
  • Native-born workers moved into higher-skilled positions (management, skilled trades)
• Abundance of cheap labor facilitated rapid industrialization and economic growth
  • Allowed businesses to expand production at lower costs
  • Contributed to the United States becoming a global economic power

Working Conditions and Labor Relations

• Immigrant workers often faced exploitation
  • Long working hours (12-16 hour workdays common)
  • Dangerous conditions (lack of safety regulations, hazardous machinery)
  • Limited legal protections (weak labor laws, difficulty accessing legal system)
• Labor unions struggled to incorporate immigrant workers
  • Language barriers and cultural differences hindered organization efforts
  • Some unions actively excluded immigrants to protect native workers' interests
  • Led to tensions between organized labor and new arrivals
• Large immigrant workforce contributed to the development of the "American System" of mass production
  • Relied on division of labor and specialization
  • Allowed for increased efficiency and output in manufacturing

Immigrant Labor in Key Industries

Infrastructure and Heavy Industry

• Railroad industry expansion heavily relied on immigrant labor
  • Immigrants comprised a significant portion of workforce building the transcontinental railroad
  • Chinese workers on the Central Pacific line, Irish workers on the Union Pacific line
• Steel industry growth depended on immigrant workforce
  • Immigrants formed a large part of the workforce in steel mills and related manufacturing facilities
  • Contributed to the rapid industrialization of cities (Pittsburgh, Cleveland)
• Mining industry, particularly coal mining, heavily dependent on immigrant labor
  • Immigrants worked in dangerous conditions to extract resources necessary for industrial growth
  • Notable immigrant groups in mining (Welsh, Polish, Italian)

Manufacturing and Agriculture

• Textile industry heavily relied on immigrant labor
  • Women and children often employed in mills and factories of New England
  • Contributed to the growth of cities (Lowell, Lawrence)
• Agriculture sector benefited from immigrant labor
  • Immigrants worked as farm laborers, particularly in the West
  • Many eventually became landowners themselves, contributing to agricultural expansion
• Construction industry employed significant immigrant workforce
  • Built infrastructure of rapidly growing urban centers (bridges, buildings, roads)
  • Contributed to the transformation of American cities

Entrepreneurship and New Industries

• Immigrant entrepreneurs contributed to the development of new industries
  • Often catered to the needs of their own ethnic communities
  • Examples include (kosher food production, ethnic newspapers, import/export businesses)
• Immigrants introduced new techniques and products
  • Brought specialized skills from their home countries
  • Contributed to innovation in various sectors (culinary arts, craftsmanship)

Societal Responses to Immigration

Nativism and Social Theories

• Nativism and anti-immigrant sentiment grew in response to large influx of immigrants
  • Led to discrimination and calls for restrictive immigration policies
  • Formation of nativist organizations (Know-Nothing Party, American Protective Association)
• Emergence of social Darwinism and eugenics theories influenced public perception of immigrants
  • Often portrayed immigrants as inferior to native-born Americans
  • Used pseudoscientific arguments to justify discrimination
• Concept of Americanization gained prominence
  • Efforts to assimilate immigrants into American culture and society
  • Programs focused on teaching English, American history, and civic values

Political and Institutional Responses

• Political machines in major cities often relied on immigrant votes
  • Provided services and patronage in exchange for political support
  • Examples include (Tammany Hall in New York City, Democratic machine in Chicago)
• Progressive Era reformers focused on improving conditions for immigrants
  • Establishment of settlement houses (Hull House in Chicago)
  • Educational programs and advocacy for better working conditions
  • Efforts to combat poverty and improve public health in immigrant communities
• Labor unions had mixed responses to immigration
  • Some advocated for restrictions to protect native workers' jobs and wages
  • Others attempted to organize immigrant workers to improve overall labor conditions
• Immigration Act of 1891 established the Office of Immigration
  • Marked the beginning of federal control over immigration policy
  • Created framework for enforcing immigration laws and processing new arrivals