7.3 Intellectual Property Rights and Traditional Knowledge

Indigenous communities have developed rich traditional knowledge over generations, encompassing medicine, agriculture, and cultural practices. This wisdom forms the core of their identity and sustainable living, but it faces challenges in protection and preservation.

Existing intellectual property laws clash with the communal nature of traditional knowledge. International efforts, like the Convention on Biological Diversity, aim to safeguard these practices. Innovative strategies, such as community-based rights and benefit-sharing agreements, are emerging to protect this valuable heritage.

Traditional Knowledge for Native Communities

Concept and Significance

Top images from around the web for Concept and Significance

• 

  "Dr. Kilmer's Standard Herbal Remedies" Residence, consult… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Indigenization Guide: Indigenous Ways of Knowing and Being – BCcampus View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Herbal Remedies | Peppermint, Seneca Snakeroot, Slippery Elm… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  "Dr. Kilmer's Standard Herbal Remedies" Residence, consult… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Indigenization Guide: Indigenous Ways of Knowing and Being – BCcampus View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Concept and Significance

• 

  "Dr. Kilmer's Standard Herbal Remedies" Residence, consult… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Indigenization Guide: Indigenous Ways of Knowing and Being – BCcampus View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Herbal Remedies | Peppermint, Seneca Snakeroot, Slippery Elm… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  "Dr. Kilmer's Standard Herbal Remedies" Residence, consult… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Indigenization Guide: Indigenous Ways of Knowing and Being – BCcampus View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Traditional knowledge encompasses collective wisdom, practices, and innovations developed by indigenous communities over generations
  • Includes medicinal knowledge (herbal remedies)
  • Agricultural practices (crop rotation techniques)
  • Cultural expressions (storytelling, art forms)
• Holistic integration of spiritual, cultural, and practical elements
  • Deeply rooted in community's relationship with environment and ancestral lands
  • Example: Native American sweat lodge ceremonies combining spiritual cleansing with physical healing
• Forms basis of cultural identity, social cohesion, and sustainable resource management
  • Shapes community values, customs, and worldviews
  • Guides decision-making processes and governance structures
• Typically transmitted orally or through demonstration
  • Makes knowledge vulnerable to loss or misappropriation without proper documentation
  • Example: Elders teaching younger generations traditional fishing techniques through hands-on practice

Importance and Value

• Crucial for maintaining biodiversity and promoting sustainable development
  • Traditional ecological knowledge often aligns with modern conservation practices
  • Example: Indigenous fire management techniques in Australia improving ecosystem health
• Ensures cultural survival of Native American communities
  • Preserves language, customs, and spiritual beliefs
  • Strengthens intergenerational bonds and community resilience
• Significant economic value in various fields
  • Pharmaceuticals (plant-based medicines)
  • Agriculture (drought-resistant crop varieties)
  • Biotechnology (traditional fermentation processes)
• Challenges Western notions of individual intellectual property rights
  • Communally held and developed over long periods
  • Emphasizes collective ownership and stewardship rather than individual invention

Challenges in Protecting Traditional Knowledge

Conflicts with Existing Intellectual Property Laws

• Designed primarily for individual or corporate innovations
  • Clashes with communal nature of traditional knowledge
  • Example: Patent laws favoring single inventors over community-held knowledge
• Concept of novelty problematic for traditional knowledge
  • Knowledge practiced for generations may not meet "new invention" criteria
  • Example: Traditional medicinal use of a plant not considered novel for patent purposes
• Copyright laws require fixed, tangible form of expression
  • May not apply to orally transmitted knowledge or cultural practices
  • Example: Traditional songs or dances not easily protected under copyright law
• Limited duration of intellectual property rights
  • Conflicts with perpetual nature of traditional knowledge
  • Example: 20-year patent term inadequate for knowledge intended to be preserved indefinitely

Practical and Conceptual Barriers

• Failure to recognize spiritual and cultural significance
  • Focus solely on commercial or utilitarian aspects
  • Example: Sacred ceremonial knowledge reduced to potential marketable products
• High costs and complex procedures for obtaining and enforcing rights
  • Prohibitive for many indigenous communities with limited resources
  • Example: Expensive patent application and maintenance fees
• Lack of formal documentation for traditional knowledge
  • Difficult to establish prior art or prove ownership
  • Example: Oral histories not accepted as evidence in patent disputes
• Challenges in defining boundaries and ownership of knowledge
  • Traditional knowledge often shared across multiple communities
  • Example: Medicinal plant knowledge spanning several indigenous groups

International Legal Framework for Traditional Knowledge

Global Conventions and Agreements

• Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD)
  • Recognizes importance of traditional knowledge
  • Calls for protection, particularly related to genetic resources and benefit-sharing
• Nagoya Protocol (supplementary to CBD)
  • Provides framework for fair and equitable sharing of benefits
  • Addresses utilization of genetic resources and associated traditional knowledge
• World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) initiatives
  • Established Intergovernmental Committee on Intellectual Property and Genetic Resources, Traditional Knowledge and Folklore
  • Developing international legal instruments for traditional knowledge protection
• United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP)
  • Affirms indigenous peoples' rights to maintain, control, protect, and develop traditional knowledge
  • Emphasizes self-determination and cultural integrity

Regional and Sector-Specific Frameworks

• World Trade Organization's Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS)
  • Criticized for limited recognition of traditional knowledge
  • Potential facilitation of biopiracy through patent systems
• Regional agreements providing protection models
  • African Union's Swakopmund Protocol on Protection of Traditional Knowledge and Expressions of Folklore
  • Andean Community Decision 391 on Access to Genetic Resources
• International Treaty on Plant Genetic Resources for Food and Agriculture
  • Addresses farmers' rights and protection of traditional agricultural knowledge
  • Establishes multilateral system for access and benefit-sharing

Safeguarding Traditional Knowledge and Equitable Benefit-Sharing

Innovative Protection Strategies

• Development of sui generis systems tailored to traditional knowledge
  • Community-based rights and perpetual protection
  • Example: New Zealand's Toi Iho trademark for Maori art and artists
• Creation of traditional knowledge databases and registries
  • Documents and preserves knowledge
  • Establishes defensive protection against misappropriation
  • Example: India's Traditional Knowledge Digital Library
• Implementation of prior informed consent protocols
  • Ensures community approval before access to or use of traditional knowledge
  • Example: Australian government's guidelines for engaging with Aboriginal communities
• Establishment of community protocols
  • Outlines customary laws and procedures for engaging with knowledge holders
  • Example: Biocultural community protocols in South Africa

Benefit-Sharing and Empowerment Initiatives

• Development of equitable benefit-sharing agreements
  • Ensures fair compensation and recognition for communities
  • Example: San people's agreement with South African government for Hoodia plant commercialization
• Capacity-building initiatives for indigenous communities
  • Empowers effective negotiation, documentation, and management of traditional knowledge
  • Example: Training programs on intellectual property rights for tribal leaders
• Integration of traditional knowledge protection into national policies
  • Incorporation into biodiversity strategies and broader development plans
  • Example: Peru's national strategy on traditional knowledge protection
• Promotion of ethical research guidelines
  • Codes of conduct for academics and companies working with traditional knowledge
  • Example: Canadian Institutes of Health Research guidelines for research involving indigenous peoples
• Exploration of alternative protection forms
  • Geographical indications or trade secrets as complements to conventional IP rights
  • Example: Use of geographical indications for traditional Native American crafts
• Advocacy for international legal reforms
  • Push for accommodating traditional knowledge within global IP system
  • Example: Proposals for new WIPO treaties on traditional knowledge protection